Am I doing the right thing?

sassandbells

Well-Known Member
Joined
13 February 2022
Messages
220
Visit site
I’ve written this post about 5 times already, but I guess I just want some reassurance that I’m doing what’s best for my mare by deciding to put to sleep.

Bellas a 10 year old thoroughbred, I’ve had her since she was 5 and she’s now 10.

She has severe separation anxiety - to the point I ended up buying 2 additional horses just so I could be sure she’d never be alone (they are a joy to work with and I think the only thing that’s kept me sane over the years!) it doesn’t really help though, she still reacts badly when another horse leaves the yard, even if she doesn’t know them.

She is not an easy keeper & incredibly fragile, has spent more time off with injuries (mostly minor) in the 5 years than she has being able to be ridden.

In the past 2 years her behaviour deteriorated, both under saddle and on the ground. Did the full work up with the vets, she has kissing spine, arthritis in her neck & hocks, SI issues, recurrent ulcers and probably a whole heap of other issues we haven’t explored. Did all the recommended treatments & rehab with no minor improvements. We also had NPA in her feet although we worked on this and seems to be one of the few things I actually managed to fix!

She can be very aggressive toward the other horses, I’m petrified she’s going to kick them one day and seriously injure them. They both always seem on edge around her too.

She’s not easy to handle, the behaviour is unpredictable to a point sometimes she can be tied up fine and others she will panic and do everything she can to get free. She’s bolted a couple of times when I’ve been leading her. She’s not afraid to bite or kick. I won’t let anyone else handle her just in case she injures them.

I have had everyone possible I can out to help her, countless professionals to ride / work with her in hand. Saddle fitter, bit & bridle fitters, chiro, physio, a holistic vet, animal communicator, you name it - I’ve probably tried it and still no improvement.

Last October decided she wasn’t happy schooling, but was quite happy to just go for a short hack around the heath so would just semi retire her and stick to that while she was ok with it. She’s never been easy to ride though and I am constantly on edge about what she might do.. she’s had me & professionals off multiple times and I’ve had quite a few injuries from riding her.

Back in November her insurance ran out and she wasn’t covered for anything so I cancelled and came to the conclusion if anything major happened then that would be it.. but then last Wednesday I notice she was lame trotting in the field. Not super bad, but just not entirely right..

I think over the years I hadn’t realised quite how bad it was until I saw her lame and almost didn’t want to investigate.. when I look at everything she doesn’t seem like a happy horse at all and I think a lot of it has been blinded by how sweet she can be at times.

I’ve had a long chat with my vet and he wouldn’t blame me if I decided to put to sleep, I’ve put so much time, effort and money into trying to get her “right” over the years and things just seem to be getting worse.

I’ve had people suggest I either put her in foal (absolutely not) or send her to a retirement livery, but I couldn’t live with myself if she ended up hurting either another person or anyone else’s horse.

I feel like I could pour thousands of pounds into investigating more things and doing various different treatments but at the end of the day still end up with a horse isn’t comfortable or happy.. don’t get me wrong, there has been some good stuff thrown in there, but not enough to discredit the bad.

I’m just mentally exhausted.. people think it’s a drastic option for what seems like a mild lameness and minor issues, but when I look at her I just don’t think there’s any quality of life there - she’s always on edge even just in the field.

It’s such a tough decision and I almost feel guilty, but even just reading this back I feel like maybe it should’ve been done sooner? I don’t know, I think I’m doing the right thing but any words of wisdom would be much appreciated.
 

nagblagger

Well-Known Member
Joined
21 October 2021
Messages
8,447
Location
dorset
Visit site
As you can't safely turn her away, she is is pain in the field and not happy, the decision, in my opinion, has already been made. You have gone above and beyond what a lot of people would have done.
Now so the horse doesn't suffer, or get passed around, you are doing what is right for you both.
 

meleeka

Well-Known Member
Joined
14 September 2001
Messages
11,571
Location
Hants, England
Visit site
I got to the paragraph about the KS before I’d decided you were doing the right thing. I lost one this year because he couldn’t get up one day. That’s the eventual outcome of KS and arthritis. Mine was fine, until he wasn’t. The end result was the same though. You are just putting off the inevitable and for what, if she’s not even happy?
 

Widgeon

Well-Known Member
Joined
30 January 2017
Messages
3,830
Location
N Yorks
Visit site
I agree with all the previous posters. I would let her go at home, somewhere she feels safe. It's hard if she's relatively young, and basically a sweet person, but that's a long, long list of issues (the neck arthritis alone would be enough for me) and she doesn't sound happy at all. Your own mental health is really important too and it sounds like you're reaching the end of your tether. As an objective outsider, I would PTS and try to remember that you've done the best by her. Sorry you're in such a sad situation.
 

alibali

Well-Known Member
Joined
18 July 2010
Messages
1,065
Visit site
It sounds as if you have gone above and beyond to try to make your horse comfortable and she is still unhappy and in pain. I'm sorry you've had such a tough time with her, sadly just as with people, not all can be fixed mentally and/or physically and often the two are linked.

My advice would be to discuss with your vet and no one else in real life (except family). The last thing you need is a hundred and one opinions confusing you or making you doubt yourself. I have had to put a much beloved horse to sleep in the prime of his life because I couldn't take his pain away and it was one of the hardest things I've ever done. I nearly buckled and changed my mind at the last moment and that was with complete support of my vet and family. Hugs to you.
 

Snow Falcon

Hoping for drier days
Joined
1 July 2008
Messages
14,163
Location
Wiltshire
Visit site
The next few days will be hard but that will ease with the release and relief that Friday brings. Allow yourself to grieve anyway you need to, there is no right or wrong. Will be thinking of you. ((Hugs))
 

Birker2020

Well-Known Member
Joined
18 January 2021
Messages
10,549
Location
West Mids
Visit site
I’ve had people suggest I either put her in foal (absolutely not) or send her to a retirement livery, but I couldn’t live with myself if she ended up hurting either another person or anyone else’s horse.


I’m just mentally exhausted.. people think it’s a drastic option for what seems like a mild lameness and minor issues, but when I look at her I just don’t think there’s any quality of life there - she’s always on edge even just in the field.

It’s such a tough decision and I almost feel guilty, but even just reading this back I feel like maybe it should’ve been done sooner? I don’t know, I think I’m doing the right thing but any words of wisdom would be much appreciated.

Don't feel guilty, you are doing right for both of you.

Give her lots of fuss and treats and say goodbye with you by her side on Friday. Big hugs x
 

Fluffypiglet

Well-Known Member
Joined
14 October 2016
Messages
817
Location
West Sussex
Visit site
I’ve just read this and whilst awful for you it definitely sounds like the right decision.you have absolutely done your best for her and despite all you have done she doesn’t sound like she’s enjoying life and you are giving the ultimate kindness. Hugs for Friday x
 

Pearlsacarolsinger

Up in the clouds
Joined
20 February 2009
Messages
46,960
Location
W. Yorks
Visit site
It is especially hard to make the decision for a young horse, as I know from experience, but you have done as much as you possibly can to try to mend her and it just isn't possible.
You know that she is unhappy and you know why that is. You have no further options but pts imo, for both your sakes.
 

Equi

Well-Known Member
Joined
25 October 2010
Messages
14,541
Visit site
You poor thing. It’s a horrible time for anyone to go through. Don’t let anyone else get in your head because they are not the ones who have to live through this. The horse seems like they are in a fair amount of pain and you have done everything you can and this is the final good you can do for them.
 
Top