Calmers NAF or Feel Good 30??

[Cate21]

Im having trouble deciding on which calmer to use. It is a choice between NAF magic or feel good 30 calmer. He can be very spooky when ridden. FG30 says it contains lecithin which is good for spooky horses, but I dont think this is in both only the FG 30. I know people who have recommended NAF magic on here, was your horse just nuts at competitions etc ?!
Did it help with general riding on a daily basis? He is great in the stable but sharp and spooky when ridden which is knocking my confidence.
Any help greatly recieved

 

[vicijp]

I have never used FG30, simply because of the fact their advertising literature is misleading - a 10yr old could dream it up.
I use Naf Magic, but find it helps more with muscle tenseness than attitude.
Id look at other management issues first.

 

[Sags_Deer]

funny ive been using magic on my boy, changed feed to simple systems months ago as he is spooky on road, it did help to relax muscles but not the spooking so if anyone comes up with any other ideas with this post then great and cate21 sorry to jump in on your post.x

 

[Janette]

I was in a local saddlery - chatting, like you do

, and they (unofficially) recommended Naf Magic over FG30 - despite the fact that they had a big display of the FG products...

 

[Cate21]

Thanks everyone, I have looked at his feed but he is still spooky.

I will give it a go and see what happens. At least I can say I tried it!

Maybe I should have a spoonful myself!!

 

[Taboo1968]

My warmblood was generally nuts all the time! So I used the FG30 one and the results are brilliant!

 

[wizzer]

I would use FG30 everytime and but the science formula one not the herbal one.

 

[Teasel]

Hi there - I use Feedmark's Steady Up which has worked wonders on my ex-spooky mare

Excellent product IMHO and now with added magnesium!