Chronically unstable/sore pelvis area (also in CR)

kerilli

Well-Known Member
Joined
1 April 2002
Messages
27,417
Location
Lovely Northamptonshire again!
Visit site
Advice/help please. Sorry, it's very long...
I have a 5 yr old homebred mare who as far as I know has never had any significant trauma. She's never been off the place. She has always had a really vicious buck out in the field, these appeared when she was about 2. She will do repeated snappy high bucks on the spot (like a buckaroo toy) as well as huge flybucks. She bucks in temper in the stable, if another horse (in adjoining field) looks at her when she's eating, etc.
I have had her treated by McTimoney Chiropractors, irregularly when she was a youngster (occasional check-ups) and regularly last year when she started work under saddle. She needed treating every 3 weeks because her pelvis kept moving but went nicely under saddle, was hacking out alone very happily, loved her work, jumping small jumps etc.
Then we had The Incident, when she somehow, for no apparent reason (and I still don't know how, one second I was fine and then on the floor) launched and ditched me last November and I dislocated my knee etc etc. This led to 6 months off for all of mine.
Got her going again and did a little bit with my (small, light) stable jockey, but tbh the horse was obviously not comfortable so I stopped this because I didn't want to risk anyone. rested, treated, lunged long and low, had excellent saddle totally reflocked, tried again...
had one day when she was happily walking and trotting around the arena for 30 mins, nicely swinging forward (but not asked into an outline) with stable jockey mark II, but then the next day the mare didn't even want to walk a circle under saddle...
I KNOW this mare, I am 100% convinced (as is my vet) this is a pain response, not her being a shirker. She snaps ears back, braces neck, and gives a tiny hop behind, lifts a hindleg. A warning that if pushed she will buck...
Have had her treated very regularly by McT Chiro, and also vet did painkilling injections into her back and hindquarter muscles a couple of weeks ago. this made a difference for about 1 day...
After talking to Chiro, I tried box resting her for the last 2 weeks so that her pelvis might stabilise and give her muscles time to adjust. She kicked the hell out of the walls, the door, tried to attack any horse that came in the stables, and then crowned it all by jumping out over a 4'3" door in the pitch dark. Great.

Mare has changes to near fore pedal bone - dropped slightly, tip has bent upwards - N.B. she has never had laminitis - and was very slightly lame on it but now she's shod she is sound. They may be to do with her breeding (Fleetwater Opp sire, I've been told some of his have this sort of thing) or to do with the diagonal, as her opposite hindleg is the problem area...

Current symptoms: cannot/won't stand square. stands with front and rear pairs of legs unevenly placed at all times.
snaps ears back and looks utterly miserable on the lunge (in cavesson only) at any pace other than walk. bends to the left all the time, including on the right rein. Picks up canter easily on both reins, but prefers right lead on right rein (offers it instead of trotting) in spite of being bent left like a banana...
if brought to a small circle, can easily bend right, cross hindlegs over, etc.
can easily do carrot stretches both ways.
has heat in right pelvis area.
Comes immediately to call, shoves head in headcollar, loves fuss, really wants to do stuff...
Argh.

I know that an MRI scan or similar is probably the next logical step but I cannot afford one at the moment. (She's not insured.)
I've heard good things about Chris Collis and team with this sort of thing... any comments? Other recommendations?
McT and vet suspect: Pelvis, Sacro-iliac area.
McT thinks her pelvic synthesis may be 'out', but it's too deep to adjust. Anyone have any experience of this?
Help, please. Anything.
Thankyou.
 
Could you send her for a bone scan?

My mare was diagnosed with a sacroiliac prob 2 weeks ago. She was in for 10 days (had to be there a bit longer than necessary as I was away at a PC camp and she's a pain to load). My TOTAL bill was £2600.

Bone Scan was £1500. It showed an uptake in that area, she then had an x ray, then they nerve blocked her sacroiliac.
 
I can't help you but recognise some of the things you describe in our ex racer (now 6). She's gone through phases of constantly resting foot, unable to hold it up for very long for the farrier, bucking, rearing, unable to work through her back properly at times. We get her regularly seen by a McT chiro but we're about to try an osteopath recommended by our farrier.

I will be interested to read other people's experiences.
 
You REALLY won't like this answer!

The only option for her are steroid injections into her sacroiliac. They will cost about £300 per injection, only available at major hospital and she will prob need 3 ish a year to keep her in work for the rest of her life!!!

She is field sound....

Worst part of mine is that she was for sale! (£4000) I sold her for £1 to a good home. :(
 
My horse was discovered to have rotated pedal bones 18 months ago - toes up. Like yours, no laminitis. Corrective farriery and pads have made a huge difference, but hard work is a no, no.

From the day I bought him he's had a sore back - and was treated only ever for a sore back by a Bowen lady. Some days he would be very, very unhappy about being ridden. And the sweet natured horse I'd bought turned in to someone very unpleasant with a huge nap.

Fast forward to comming in from the field extremely lame. Immediate consultation and full lameness workup done which discovered the problem with the pedal bones, confirmed paper thin soles and the start of coffin joint disease. Feet are now managed very carefully - and bad back has vanished.

I would say a horse that bucks like your's couldn't possibly have a SC problem. They simply wouldn't be up to chucking themselves around like that.

I'd be focussing on the feet.

X-rays and scans plus the nerve blocks came to a grand total of £500.00. Bargin.

I will also never go near a back person again - unless specifically recommended by my vet. My expereicnes have led me to believe that most of them are full of *******s......
 
My horse was discovered to have rotated pedal bones 18 months ago - toes up. Like yours, no laminitis. Corrective farriery and pads have made a huge difference, but hard work is a no, no.

From the day I bought him he's had a sore back - and was treated only ever for a sore back by a Bowen lady. Some days he would be very, very unhappy about being ridden. And the sweet natured horse I'd bought turned in to someone very unpleasant with a huge nap.

Fast forward to comming in from the field extremely lame. Immediate consultation and full lameness workup done which discovered the problem with the pedal bones, confirmed paper thin soles and the start of coffin joint disease. Feet are now managed very carefully - and bad back has vanished.

I would say a horse that bucks like your's couldn't possibly have a SC problem. They simply wouldn't be up to chucking themselves around like that.

I'd be focussing on the feet.

X-rays and scans plus the nerve blocks came to a grand total of £500.00. Bargin.

I will also never go near a back person again - unless specifically recommended by my vet. My expereicnes have led me to believe that most of them are full of *******s......

Sounds very reasonable Amymay.

My mare never bucked out anything like that. She would just sit down slightly when mounted (stood up as she walked off) and was becoming increasingly unlevel under saddle. To palpate her back was not particularly sore. She hadn't been in work long however, only broken this year and due to circumstances was in and out of work. I have been told that if she does not have the injections she will be in no pain in the field. If I gave her a load of time off she would come back into work sound, but then increasinly become lame again.

But then every case may be different! I am certainly no expert.
 
could definatly be a front foot problem, displayed as a pelvis issue, mine had pelvis problems due to navicular (prob not the case with yours but that is how it showed itself). I know another horse with hock problems that again was showing as a back problem. Will PM you RE Chris Collis if you like.
 
have checked, can push down as hard as I like on SI area, no reaction at all.
Even more perplexing. Surely if it was a SI problem she'd react?
A friend has suggested that a horse can have a naturally asymmetric pelvis. This could explain the problem I guess.
Thanks for all the pm's and the suggestions on the thread, really appreciated.
 
have checked, can push down as hard as I like on SI area, no reaction at all.
Even more perplexing. Surely if it was a SI problem she'd react?
A friend has suggested that a horse can have a naturally asymmetric pelvis. This could explain the problem I guess.
Thanks for all the pm's and the suggestions on the thread, really appreciated.

My mare gave no reaction when pressed anywhere on her back. It was only under saddle that we saw anything wrong, sitting slightly when mounted and fractionally unlevel (very fractionally) under saddle.

Only way to diagnose was bone scan and then nerve block the area. Her whole way of going completely changed.
 
Top