Totally disagree! Until you reach a certain level it is a waste of money training with these highly priced specialists, but they will be happy to take your money when they are charging £100 per hour as your instructor/trainer is. Dressage trainers are specialists at relieving clients of vast amounts very quickly. Even Dick Turpin had the decency to wear a mask when he robbed you. Cheaper instructors will give you a great lesson & plenty of homework to do after a lesson as well, you are not getting value for your money.
If you were to contact someone like Tim Stockdale for a show jumping lesson he would not take you on unless you were competing at Foxhunter & above. He would direct you to one of his staff who would give you a lesson at the standard you are currently at. Needless to say the cost of a lesson with his staff would be cheaper than with him.
Well I'm not sure why I have to justify my choices to you, but as my horse is training medium and starting toward AM then I don't consider it a tremendous jump to train with someone who has ridden & trained Grand Prix. I want us to learn things the right way, with an eye on the future. I don't want to pay peanuts for the BHSAI down the road, I want someone who can see the potential in both of us and help us to develop.
I did the same when I was eventing (Novice/CCI* if it matters), I trained with an Olympic event rider and it paid dividends.
I find that they see the bigger picture of where one is heading and have more exercises, more tools and my progress goes in the correct direction. It does depend on the individual teaching -if Tim Stockdale choses not to teach those at a low level that is his decision - but I'm truly grateful that my jumps trainer was happy to watch me over x poles so that I can maybe reach Foxhunter one day.
I don't consider their charges extortionate, just a fair reflection of the skills they bring to the lesson.
^^ this, exactly this, for me. Not many people would look at my current ride, a 14hh section D with an attitude problem and say "yep, we can work with this" and see her talents, her ability to sit and quick hind leg, that is going to be really trainable at the higher levels. Most people would say I've got the wrong horse - that's not much use to me when it's the only one I've got.
Each to their own, but usually you get what you pay for IMO.