Both look nice tbh, just comes down to personal preference really! I have these and love them http://www.trot2.com/detail.jsp?pid=18003932&id=18003942&src=froogle super smart, close fitting and comfy as well as being lovely and thin for riding. I hate bulky gloves and the stretch bit between the fingers on these keeps them fitting really neatly, but is basically invisable so it doesn't affect the look.