Help - horse pinning ear back - an evasion?

Grumbledor

Well-Known Member
Joined
17 August 2007
Messages
1,067
Visit site
Hi all,

I need some help or at least find out if anyone has experienced the same behaviour in a horse...

My horse has developed a fairly intermittent behaviour that has become a problem in the last 6 months, following a free walk, or walk break, when asked to work again he pins his ear back as though a bug has flown inside or something. Now I do remember this behaviour on occasion over the last 3-4 years but it has become much more frequent since January.

It can be either ear, usually the ear on the outside, so after a free walk across diagonal, when I then have to collect to a medium walk and then ask for canter, he can be pinning the ear back to the outside, tensing his neck and therefore get the wrong canter strike off. I have tried giving him more rein, trying to barely use any rein and only the seat, I have tried being firmer, I have tried telling him off, I have tried patting him and praising him. Usually towards the end of a session, he won't do it, and I praise him very much when he doesn't do it, but then, next session, he will do it again (he never does it right at the beginning of a session either, usually when he's starting to work a bit harder).

I have had physio, which is routine anyway, physio has known him since he was a foal and says he looks the best she's ever seen him. I have had saddles checked by a fitter who works closely with the physio, I have teeth done every 6 months, I have had vet look inside the ears. He is in no way head shy, I can very comfortably touch, play, even stick my fingers in his ears (not too far of course!!). His ears were scoped by the vet with no sedation and nothing seen inside. Have also changed bits, he does it in various snaffle/double combinations. Both bridles are padded comfort bridles. I have also given him a month off in April.

He has also done it out hacking, when asked to come back onto more of a contact following walking on a loose rein. Once he has done it for no reason at all, when I have been walking on a consistent contact. I had a grid work lesson about a month ago and he was fab, not a hint of the behaviour at all, but I often ride alone and regular jumping sessions are difficult.

Sometimes he doesn't pin the ear back, some times he shakes the ears. This shaking is very similar to what he does just before he pulls back on a rope when he is tied up (an 'I'm bored of standing here' kind of behaviour).

It is so frustrating, we have really made progress recently, its just this little problem, and it passes after about a minute of riding him through it, it is just enough to ruin 4-5 movements of a test following the free walk. I really feel it is a sort of resistance.

Next steps are physio under sedation, bute trial or blood tests - but just wanted to ask if anyone has experienced anything similar?

Sorry for the essay - just to add he is 9yrs old, Dutch WB, Gelding. Had surgery on kissing spine as a 3 year old, now works lovely across his back, stretches well, as I mentioned, physio said he's the best she's ever seen him, and when he wants to scratch a difficult area he can comfortably contort his back into all sorts of flexible positions! Physio has worked on poll and neck flexions and found no resistance. I always stretch thoroughly before asking for more work in a schooling session.

Thankies :)
 
My mare does this as well, when we first got her she was very nappy, this got better but say if we worked her say from walk to canter she would put her ears flat back to scare me. But when my instructor rides her she does not do it
 
Sounds exactly the same as my mare does sometimes. I don't think it is an evasion in itself, but I think it can be as a sort of 'testing the water before an evasion' type of behaviour.

Initially I would let her off work, back off with my leg and try and settle her before continuing. This made no difference, if anything she did it much more than she does it now. Now I insist that she continues working through it and just ignore it, and it now happens an awful lot less.

She is naturally sensitive around her ears, and having a brow band on that is even the smallest bit small or too big (so that it can move a little) is enough to set her off. I thread her noseband headstrap over her headpiece and that helps too, as does wearing an sj style fly veil in windy or buggy conditions.

She also has the back lady out regularly as she does tend to hold tension in her atlas (I would have thought because she does have a tendency to headshaking sometimes) and releasing this helps her too.

If she is extra spooky on a hack or in the school then I sometimes have a bad habit of picking her up too soon before she is fully warmed up, this results in the same response so I think it is partly a 'this is difficult/I am a bit stiff' type behaviour too. I think it is sometimes her letting me know that things are a little hard for her. I don't let her off it there and then as she does need to work on sometimes even though it is getting hard work, but I do take the hint and work in a stretch on a long rein in the next few minutes.
 
My boy does this. What my instructor has said to do is keep leg on and riding forward. If he still puts ears back and backs off I also use my reins, sort of slap them on his neck, and he stops being silly!! He usually does it when he knows he has got to work!!
 
Hi guys, firstly thank you so much for taking the time to reply. It is interesting that there are horses that do this and also that is seems mostly attitude related. ThePony - I have also had the suspiscion that he does it when things get a bit harder, but like you say, don't want to reward him with a stretch and a break there and then because he will just get out of what I want him to do. Also he often does it after he has just had a break, kind of like, oh I thought I had finished! I am also going to get him a big fly veil, I got one but it was too small, and see if that helps but I'm not sure there will be any quick fixes. Thank you again! X
 
I agree that it is almost a testing the water type reaction...

My mare was very nappy when I got her (she was 3 at the time) and when you asked for the canter she would flatten her ears against her head and the come right back at you. I worked really hard to get her really swinging over her back, lots of stretching work and transitions and now I hardly ever see her ears coming back because she is much more relaxed and they remain nice and floppy.
 
My big coloured does this, when I first got him it was really extreme and he would spin in circles doing it! He was checked out by a vet who asked if he did it out hunting, which he didn't, and said that he was taking the piss and to work him through it!
I used to make life really hard for him for ten minutes, then be nice and although he never stopped it completely, it gradually got to the point where he would twitch an ear then get on with it.
I always rode in a comfort headpiece and an over sized browband, just in case though! :D
 
My mare does something similar - I call it the 'Ears of Death' as when she starts doing it it's probably best to just give up there and then. She would only do it when being nappy/spooky and to be honest after her recent spell in bootcamp she hasn't done it since. One ear stays up as normal and the other one moves about and she pins it back or to the side, this would usually be accompanied by going sideways or headshaking. All physical components were checked and found ok, but after intense schooling with help of instructor it stopped.
 
Ah this is really interesting, thank you again - I think I am getting in a tizz about it because is has ruined a few tests that would have been really good! I think I'll try and not get worked up about it and work him through it. He does have an attitude anyway, most of the time its to his advantage, but in this instance not. He's quite an opinionated boy!!

Thank you all again so much for your replies! xxx
 
Thank you Orangehorse, he has his teeth done on a 6monthly basis and he has not changed the behaviour following his dentist visit in the last 6 months. Vet has also had a feel of his teeth.
 
I was just thinnking that the ear goes back when you pick up the reins after a free walk so wondered if there is "something" that might be causing it. Sounds as though the vet thought of that though.

How frustrating. Horses, if only they could talk!
 
Top