Today I wrote for a BD judge at an unaffiliated RC comp. I've never ridden an intro test so it was interesting to find out what she was looking for. Basically accuracy, rhythm and suppleness in that order, didn't matter where the head was really and riders who tried to fiddle their horses heads down at the expense of rhythm, lost marks. At prelim she was looking pretty much for the same. Her remarks were accurate but not unkind. tbh I think you had a very poor judge, throw the sheets in the bin and keep taking your horse out!