i only have a dressage saddle for my mare and we have started jumping. Im not a positions to buy A new saddle for her, but it is quite uncomfortable because of the deep seat, so we 0nly manage up to about 2'6
not very high at all - the stirrup bars are set further back than on a jump saddle so it is really difficult to shorten up and still remain in balance. I hack out and school in my dressage saddle but never gallop or stand to canter - just not comfortable.
I've jumped 4 foot in a very straight cut showing saddle which is dressage biased, but I also fell of several times. I would have thought that you can jump whatever you feel comfortable jumping.
I agree with FMM - it depends entirely on the person. If you can stay in balance in the dressage saddle then it should in no way hinder the horse. However it's not very comfortable! I once jumped a 2' log in the woods out hacking, in a Wintec Isabell. I then vowed never to do it again as it strained all the muscles down the front of my legs! It didn't help that the horse had a tendancy to cat-leap though!
my GP saddle is v straight cut so is pretty much a dressage saddle - i hunt, to xc and sj in it jump well over 1 m... i am getting a new saddle soon as this one no longer fits my boy and am looking for something more forward cut for jumping - it will be interesting to see if my technique improves with a jumping saddle!!
I've jumped 3'7'' in a working hunter saddle and 4'3'' in my GP saddle as I don't have a jumping or dressage saddle. I'd say jump as big as you feel comfortable.
I've done RC areas on a 14.3 pony with a dressage saddle. It was fine!!
Also jump in mine at home if I've got bored of flatwork and dont struggle at around 3'3/3'6ish
Well lol, I've jumped about 18" in a dressage saddle (that was the size of the jump) however, Bud cleared it with another 4' to spare, so unintentionally, have jumped quite big