In a Pickle. :/ What do you think?

Stormy123456

Well-Known Member
Joined
25 February 2010
Messages
696
Visit site
I have two horses at the moment, one my parents bought (Ballet) and one I bought (Spanner).

Ballet will be staying with us forever now (she's my horse of a lifetime), and I bought Spanner last year as a project, to fund another eventer in the future really. But yeh a project (just broken 4y/o). Spanner is also 15.2hh, whereas I need something over 16hh at least, she will not make the height, so although she would make a lovely eventer, just not for me :(

Well Ballet has done something to her legs and is out of work for at least 2 monthes, however Vets think it may be permanent, they arn't sure. Spanner is at the stage of schooling at home and a few parties, but I don't want to push her or over do it.

I've had various kind offers of competition horses to borrow/school for over the Summer, however yesterday my parents went out to see a potential eventer (I was gobsmacked, they didn't mention it to me! Although they did say it was only because he wasn't up for much, a opportunity as they put it....). Came back saying, it was very nice, well bred, masses of scope, floating light paces, but a really strong sturdy build, 16.3hh - so the right size, basically that next horse. I went to ride it today, and it's lovely, needs some more schooling on the flat, and a different bit, and would take some getting used to (huge stride), but all the ingredients are there. (It's also V fat at the moment!)

Problem is; it's come around too early. I can't afford to keep 3 long term really, maybe over the Summer, but it depends on Ballet. This horse isn't likely to stick around for long (because of it's price tag) and I most certainly won't be able to afford a "made" eventer later on, I would be going back to the 4 y/o stage, but this horse is 8 (just not done anything competition wise due to owner illness).

Do I sell Spanner now and buy the horse, or keep Spanner and get a small comp record and go back to a 4 y/o later? Don't know whether this horse would be for keeps or a long term project.....

The only thing with the horse is it's slightly flat footed, and was lame on and off for a few weeks two years ago, Vets put it down to leaving it too long between shoeing. :/ No problems since.

Instructor loves the horse and says that we should have a long trial (owner kindly agreed it would be possible) with it, keep Spanner til end of Summer with a small comp record + sell her, and see how Ballet gets on with Vets.

In a way wishing I hadn't seen it, as don't particularly want to give up on Spanner now, as it's been hard and would be nice to see it through, but then again.....

Any suggestions or advice? :/

BE Refunds? Since Ballet and I have managed to get to 1 event in our first year (and last year of JRN -gutted) I presume BE do membership refunds? Otherwise £140 wasted.
 
1. If Ballet has damaged herself permanently what's going to happen? How long until you know?

2. Not sure why Spanner would make a good eventer, but not for you? We have a 15.2 mare that was evented by a tall male pro before we got her - size aint important if it's got the talent. You could do BYEH classes and have a lot of fun.

3. The new horse is 8 but hasn't done anything. It's end of May now. You'll not be competition fit and ready for at least 9 weeks with a following wind. You might get a few events in before the end of the season if all goes well. My question would be - he's 8 and nobody has done anything with him? That's kind of the same as he's 4 and nobody has done anything with him. Just because he's older and bigger doesn't make him better, especially if he has a history of lameness. That's why he's cheap.

I would walk away and concentrate on your youngster who is not too small and could still make you enough money to help fund the next horse up.
 
I would be careful of a horse that age who has done nothing. A girl I know very well had a 16.3 well-bred 'eventer', she sold her at 9 as having not done much, still got £4k for her. The reason she hadn't done much? A catalogue of injuries - tendon injury, splint flare-ups, sliced it's coronet band in a trailer, permanent bad back... literally one thing after another. Girl told potential purchasers that she had been 'too busy' to take the horse to competitions. Poor new owners will have NO idea of what a crock they've bought.
Be very careful!!! You'll kick yourself if you sell a good horse and end up with something useless.
 
I would be careful of a horse that age who has done nothing. A girl I know very well had a 16.3 well-bred 'eventer', she sold her at 9 as having not done much, still got £4k for her. The reason she hadn't done much? A catalogue of injuries - tendon injury, splint flare-ups, sliced it's coronet band in a trailer, permanent bad back... literally one thing after another. Girl told potential purchasers that she had been 'too busy' to take the horse to competitions. Poor new owners will have NO idea of what a crock they've bought.
Be very careful!!! You'll kick yourself if you sell a good horse and end up with something useless.

Thanks for the advice, I probably should have mentioned the a close friend told us about the horse, which she knows well, (she would never have told me about him if there were a problem she knew about), the reason the horse hasn't been competed really is because the owner was diagnosed with Multiplesclerosis three years ago, and he's far too big for her 13 year old daughter to compete (she jumps him at home though), but has her own ponies to compete. He's for sale due to personal reasons, which she has explained, and are understandable.

She has also said we could have him on loan with view to buy, and we would have him 5* vetted. Still mulling it over. :/

It will be another 2 monthes before the Vets will even consider looking (and shes on corrective shoeing which won't show anything up til after 5 shoeings - so she's out for a fair while) at Ballet again and then she'll be off for MRI scans etc etc. And Ballet will stay whatever the injury, however long it takes, even if it doesn't get better.
Spanner was bought with the intention of selling, because I am too big for her, as she is a very fine 15.1/15.2 ISH, and I am 5 foot 11 and look more than silly on her. Honest.

I should have said he's well schooled, just need tweaking, and has masses of ability, just hasn't done anything as in hasn't competed. He's XC schooled, jumping well at home, and has been out once or twice, and won his only ODE last year.


Spanner came in a little lame today aswell, just my luck, so no baby dressage for her tomorrow. :(

Thanks for the opinions. Definately something to think about. :/
 
Last edited:
Top