Is it time to part ways?

HGre17

New User
Joined
4 June 2023
Messages
3
Visit site
Bare with me this might get a bit long and ranty...

TLDR; Appreciate I haven't had my mare for a long time but I have lots of issues getting in the way of me enjoying her varying from my physical health (fibromyalgia and fatigue issues suck), personal family and work related stress, stress relating to me thinking we're not bonding and I'm too much of a novice for her, and others getting on much better with her. I feel as though I can't offer her what she deserves which is a better rider going out and doing things with her whether that be showing, dressage, or whatever. I dread going to the yard as although she's lovely, we're just not clicking and my confidence is being knocked due to numerous bad rides.

Background on me: I'm technically a disabled rider, in my mid 20s and been doing 'horsey stuff' for around 9 years, riding for 8. Would class myself as a novice though as haven't really progressed much in the last 6 years. Wanted my own pony after loaning for a few years to improve my riding and horsemanship skills. Though lots of issues have been piling up in the last 4 months or so with my health fluctuating, being under pressure under work as we're a little understaffed due to people leaving in succession, anxiety over a family member's illness, and the general cost of living etc. But anyway-

I searched for a good few months for my first horse/pony and finally settled on a nice mare (believe she is a New Forest/Welsh) who I've had for about 5 months now. The first 2 months went pretty well considering she was in her past home for around 5 years- she was really good in the school and would come over to me in the field etc. We did a load of groundwork to establish trust and respect and enjoyed being around each other. Then spring properly kicked in and she had her first season and became a pain in the arse calling out all the time, being unfocused, strong on the ground and in the school, not listening to my aids, and running off (not bolting, just doing fast canters when I'd just ask for a trot in random directions). Previous owner said they'd never had an issue with her when in season. She'd be the exact same on the ground and in the school regardless of her season, time of the year, or length of time in between rides. So I thought maybe its just because its her first one of the year in a new place and she needs a little help staying focused and not getting stressy. Put her on a calming supplement (Oestress) with the loading dose for a week and then lowering onto a maintenance dose.

Seemed to settle for another 2 weeks before becoming unfocused and nappy again in the school so I thought maybe its her season again? This would repeat for a while with her having good and bad days for me in the school. She's really good hacking in company, doesn't nap, will follow or lead, not phased by traffic, generally a good girl. I try and hack as much as I can with others so she doesn't go sour in the school. So everything was going so-so until a week before our first show where she started acting up again- would refuse to trot circles, trying to canter where I wasn't asking, and trotting fast when asking for canter instead of going nicely like she used to. Had her back checked and she was absolutely fine. Had other people ride her and was told she went lovely for them and so tried again... same result. Thought she might just be having a few off days with me and tried not to dwell on it. Show comes around and she pissed about in the warm up arena, nearly crashing into a mirror (assume she thought it was another pony and ran up to say hello despite me doing all that I could to get her away from it before she smacked her nose right into it), again not doing simple circles properly, refusing to canter, and wanting to pay more attention to the other pony in the arena.
So that knocked me of course but tried to stay positive for the actual dressage test. She was going ok until I asked for a canter to which she actually did this time but was going far too fast, ignoring my half halts and careened over the arena markers. Twice. The judge was lovely and said go in and try again and pony was determined to not do this and cantered out of the markers again so obviously we had to withdraw. I was really upset and felt even worse when the previous owner messaged to ask how the show went to which I had to say she'd been naughty. Got the 'Oh she's never done that before' message and 'She loves dressage she's good at it and has been out loads with us so don't know why she acted that way'. If she was a green pony and had barely been out before I'd understand her acting this way but she's not.

So that's in the past and we've continued to have lessons etc but again, we have more bad than good sessions. We enjoy our hacks though (when I can find someone to go with) but for the past 3 or so weeks I've been dreading going to the yard. Riding doesn't seem as fun and enjoyable to me and I just don't think this is going to work out anymore. If I had the time, money, and mental/physical energy to keep at it for a few more months then I would but I realistically just don't see this happening. Nobody in my family is horsey and can't really offer much advice so they suggested asking on forums. Please don't be too critical, I've tried my best with her but can only do so much as my body allows me. I can only be so firm/strong and can only 'get after her' so much before my body just says NO!
 

Pearlsasinger

Up in the clouds
Joined
20 February 2009
Messages
47,239
Location
W. Yorks
Visit site
I think you are being hard on yourself. Have you discussed your mare with a vet? It sounds as if you need to bring her seasons to your vet's attention.
I wonder, as well, if you are on the right yard, with the right instructor. 'Getting after' a horse with a health problem, is rarely the best way to deal it.
I think your first step should be to call your vet tbh. It sounds as if the root of your problems are your mare's seasons.
 

HGre17

New User
Joined
4 June 2023
Messages
3
Visit site
I think you are being hard on yourself. Have you discussed your mare with a vet? It sounds as if you need to bring her seasons to your vet's attention.
I wonder, as well, if you are on the right yard, with the right instructor. 'Getting after' a horse with a health problem, is rarely the best way to deal it.
I think your first step should be to call your vet tbh. It sounds as if the root of your problems are your mare's seasons.
No I haven't. Only because she seems to go fine with other people riding her even in season. Plus her previous owners know virtually all about her and said she was never a bother in season so much so that they'd forget she was in season for not showing any signs! I figured a yard change etc would make her hormonal but this would have settled after being established into a routine surely?
 

Pearlsasinger

Up in the clouds
Joined
20 February 2009
Messages
47,239
Location
W. Yorks
Visit site
No I haven't. Only because she seems to go fine with other people riding her even in season. Plus her previous owners know virtually all about her and said she was never a bother in season so much so that they'd forget she was in season for not showing any signs! I figured a yard change etc would make her hormonal but this would have settled after being established into a routine surely?
Strong riders can make even horses with really serious problems (not saying yours has) go well. If she were mine, I would want the vet to examine her before passing her onto someone else.
 

OrangeAndLemon

Afraid of exorcism
Joined
5 October 2015
Messages
12,143
Location
Cheshire
Visit site
I'm thinking she's testing the boundaries. You've enjoyed the honeymoon period and now she's seeing what she can get away with and it seems like quite a lot.

I think you need more lessons with someone who can help build your confidence and help you understand what she wants from the relationship. This may start with groundwork lessons before ridden lessons.

As for "others ride my horse better' I think that's normal. Our horses get to know us and know our weaknesses.

But as YCBM said, if you're not enjoying it, call it a day and find a new best friend. Sounds like she and you aren't a good match.
 

Red-1

I used to be decisive, now I'm not so sure...
Joined
7 February 2013
Messages
18,448
Location
Outstanding in my field!
Visit site
It is a hobby and it is up to you what to do. Options include selling or getting more help.

If it helps, I sold my last horse because I wasn't enjoying her any more. I had a lot of non horse stress with mum being ill and it made it not fun. I sold her and bought an old cob! He has been a hit as a stress buster, whilst my previous horse went on to compete pretty much immediately with the new owners and won stacks.

As long as you sell honourably, there is nothing wrong with selling.
 

smolmaus

Well-Known Member
Joined
3 December 2019
Messages
3,546
Location
Belfast
Visit site
If you aren't enjoying her you're allowed to sell her to someone else who might, so if you posted the thread looking for permission you don't need it!

If you think you would regret not trying everything first then I would have a proper vet workup done, it could be anything other than her back. Ulcers would be one thing or low grade pain somewhere that is worse on a surface than when hacking. It could also just be a communication problem, she could be picking up on tension from you that makes her anxious. When its your own horse and things aren't going well you are so emotionally invested that you give off so many signals they can pick up on. When its someone else they literally just don't care as much and bingo, relaxed horse. I've seen this from both directions and its very frustrating!

Personally, it would be vet, physio and I also know a local equine behaviourist. I know that is a lot, and you don't have to, but you still have so many options if you want them.
 

paddy555

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 December 2010
Messages
13,810
Visit site
I can't see anywhere you have said you totally adore this horse, will do anything for her and would soooo much hate to be without her.
If that is the case and other people don't have a problem with her then let her go. Someone will click and have a wonderful time with her.

Either give it some time and see if you really want a horse or look for an older gelding who will act more as a schoolmaster and be easier and more fun.

Unless you adore her and really want to keep her I wouldn't bother with the vet, physio, behaviourist or anyone else. Either find a dealer/sales livery or sell her yourself and get one of your friends who rides her well to demonstrate her.
Not every person gets on with every horse.
 

oldie48

Well-Known Member
Joined
15 April 2013
Messages
7,056
Location
South Worcestershire
Visit site
In the past I have hung onto a couple of horses I should have moved on to a more suitable home. I'm older and wiser now, this mare doesn't sound right for you but she would probably be right in another home. As another has said, send her to a reputable dealer who will find her another home and just take time to reassess what you want in a horse or in deed if you want to own or just ride when you feel up to it. No shame in deciding you've bought the wrong horse, I wish more people would do it. Good luck with whatever you decide and I'm sorry your health isn't great, that really sucks, focus on what is in your best interests.
 
Top