Need advice re loan of pony. Help

puppleshweeple39

New User
Joined
25 March 2012
Messages
5
Visit site
Sorry everybody but this is going to be a long post but I feel i have to let you know the full story so I can get proper advice.

3 weeks ago today I took possession of a pony on a month's trial before deciding to loan for a 2-3 year period. We had been to see the pony on 2 occasions before agreeing on the month's trial. I was told that she hadn't been used properly for nearly a year but was easy going and good on the road. The owners had bought it for their daughter who decided she didn't want it and as far as i am aware never rode it. It was then sent out on loan to somebody who apparently never got on it's back even though this was someone who had 2 horses of her own and according to the owner was determined to have this pony (Summer). My 14 yr old daughter rode the pony in the field where the pony was brought back to (to allow us to see her). She could only really walk her as the ground was really boggy. On the next visit I took my very knowledgeable friend to check Summer over and give me her opinion. She advised that pony would need work to bring her up to a decent fitness level but once the pony got back into the swing of things after not being ridden for a year she would be a nice pony for us to have.

After a lot of thought and working out re time and money I advised the owner that we would like to take the pony on loan. They responded that would actually like to sell her for £650. I was a bit taken aback as I had only ever mentioned loaning. I finally managed to persuade them to let us have on loan if the month's trial was a success. They agreed.

The pony was brought over to our local livery yard and I was immediately told by the stable manager that her back needed seen to as she couldn't stand square at the back end. Also her feet had been neglected: front shoes only on that had been on for months, the edge of the hoof was reaching over the shoe. In the first few days I tried to lunge her myself without much success as all she wanted to to do was come into me and on one occasion turned her back end and lashed out and also reared up in front of me. After about 3 days I decided to ask the stable manager if he would help me which he did. He managed to lunge her but mentioned that she was as green as grass and she didn't even know how to canter in a schooling environment. After he had given her a good work out my daughter was able to ride her round the arena at a walk for 20 mins. The pony kept throwing her head up and down quite badly and the manager advised that she would probably need her teeth lookd at as she didn't like bit in her mouth.

The next day I tried to ride her but she was having none of it and tried to throw me off. Tried to lunge again but was unsuccessful. I panicked at the thought of having an unruly pony and texted the owner and told him that I didn't think it was going to work out as i was looking for a pony that had done stuff and that myself and my daughter could get on without fear of being thrown off (this is our first family pony, although I have had ponies of my own years ago). I didn't think I had the experience or the time to go back to basics with Summer. He didn't reply to my text so I had to phone him and he advised that he didn't have the field to put her in as the farmer was using it for lambing but he would try and sort something out. I didn't hear from him for about 2 or 3 days. In the meantime I was spending as much time as I could at the stable trying to bond with the pony and eventually was able to get a decent lunge out of her. This happened for 2 or 3 days and I started to feel a bit more positive her so much so that to give the pony the benefit of the doubt I agreed to get her back sorted and her hoofs and teeth done.

Her pelvis was out and got realigned and her shoes taken off and feet trimmed. Unfortunately her teeth are in such a state that she will have to be sedated to get extractions and rasping done. On Friday just gone we decided to back her again to see if the work had made things easier for her. She had a loose run round the arena and then lunged with tack on for 15mins or so. My daughter was first up with my Dad at the other end of the lunge rope but the pony wouldn't move and when you tried to get her going all she would do was back up, try and rear or bolt out the side door. As my daughter has not had experience of this kind of behaviour and didn't know how to react I decided to get on and try and ease the pony into a walk. No luck! she wouldn't move anywhere apart from up the way at one point my Dad was trying to hold her down with two hands on the halter. In the end I had to get off as I couldn't even turn her in a circle as it was like pulling on a concrete block, there was no response from her. I made the decision there and then that we couldn't keep her as she was not what we were looking for and certainly not the pony that we thought we were getting.

I texted the owner and advised him that we weren't keeping her and wanted to send her back and that my Stable Manager would bring her back to him today at 10 am. Well, he phoned me and told me that I was a time waster and had b*ggered him about 1st not wanting the pony then deciding to persevere for the remainder of the month then wanting to take her back. I told him there was no point in keeping a pony that we couldn't ride and that there are other horses in line for my stable and that the manager wants the stable emptied for next week. He told me that we could take the pony back today but at his convenience, not mine and that she was to be brought over between 5 &6 pm. I told him i would have to see if the person who would be transporting the pony would be available at that time but also I had prior arrangement elswhere (daughters running competition) and wasn't 100% sure if I would be able to come with the pony. He went ballistic and told me to play the game and that i was to come over with the pony and explain exactly what was wrong with the pony and not just to dump in the field by the stable manager. I advised him that if he would take her at 10am I would certainly be there in person but couldn't guarantee when the competition would finish in the afternoon. He hung up on me!

As it turns out the transport can't do this afternoon but can do the same time any night this week. I have texted the owner to this effect but he hasn't got back to me as yet and I don't want to phone him just to get into a fight again as I have been ill all weekend over this. Up till now he hasn't replied andI don't know what to do. Where do I go from here? The stable manager says he will take the pony over and just leave her in the field regardless but I think it will just kick off even more which I don't want. Also I will have to return the tack (saddle which was too small with a girth that would have suited a shetland not a 14.2 warmblood x a bridle with a bit that was too big for her - I have had to beg borrow and steal bits of equipment to allow me to ride her at all).

What are my rights here or is he right, am I a time waster?
 
Gosh, I think one option would be this...

1) Take the pony when you are able to take it, if you can get it to the field that it came out of and it has a companion in there then I would check the perimeter myself and make sure I was satisfied at putting her back and that she would be safe.

2) Take some kind of box for the tack and leave the tack on the property, out of plain sight so that it can't be stolen and let the owner know where it is.

OR - If it were me, I would want a chance to speak to the owner face to face and so I would try my best to arrange transport for when I could see him.

To be honest it sounds a bit like if you told him you would be there with the pony at 11am - he would be there too. Sounds a bit like he is just trying to put you out.

Sorry this has turned bad. It can be so hard finding the right one!!


P.s - Might it be worth giving this pony some time - sounds like she has had a tough life and I would be wanting to do what I could to put her right. Even if that meant her being unridden for some time!
x
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sorry not able to advise particularly, but this sounds like a thoroughly dodgy set-up. Surely the price of £650 seemed a bit too good to be true???? And did it not occur to you to have the pony vetted? Sorry, easy to be wise after the event I know.

Poor little pony, I can't help feeling sorry for it coz there are obviously pain issues involved here which is why its reacting under saddle.
 
Thanks for your reply,

I know I should be there but tbh I don't want go just to get verbally abused. Should i contact him and advise that if he doesn't tell what day to deliver I will give him until Friday and then the pony will be taken back regardless.
 
Mijodsr2blinkintite - there are lots of things that are going through my mind about what I should or shouldn't have done but the bottom line is that this has all happened within the month's trial where it was agreed that Summer would go back to them if things didn't work out. I don't feel that I am a time waster has I have spent money on a pony that I don't own trying to get her working right with the best of intentions for the future. I feel very sorry for the pony as it sounds as if she has been passed from pillar to post and I really wanted it to work out but now my daughter won't go near her and i am wondering if this has been the case with the owners daughter and the previous loanee. If i had known how little she had done I would never have taken her on.
 
Texting is no good - you have to phone. Give him choice of two days to return pony, and if he's still difficult tell him you will expect recompense for livery.

And where you stand is quite simple. The pony is not rideable, end of.
 
Sorry not able to advise particularly, but this sounds like a thoroughly dodgy set-up. Surely the price of £650 seemed a bit too good to be true???? And did it not occur to you to have the pony vetted? Sorry, easy to be wise after the event I know.

Poor little pony, I can't help feeling sorry for it coz there are obviously pain issues involved here which is why its reacting under saddle.

Would you get a loan pony vetted? I certainly wouldn't shell out vetting fees for an animal I wasn't going to be owning.

OP - Agree with amymay, ring the guy up, don't text him and try to come to some arrangement that suits you both.
Good luck in sorting it :)
 
Funny isn't it, when you want them to stand by the contract, they tell you you are a difficult person, I would just send pony back to whence it came, they now have a better pony than before, and can try their luck with some other poor sucker.
 
All sounds a bit odd to me! I would just call him and if he doesn't pick up leave a voicemail explaining when you will be returning the pony and back it up with a text. If he doesn't show up, I would leave the pony in the field (checking it was secure first) as Billie1007 suggested with the tack as well.

Have to say I feel bit sorry for pony sounds like she's pulled around a bit but at the end of the day if she's not ride for your family, then you need to get rid!
 
From several things you mention in your post, you do not seem experienced enough to have a pony on loan, maybe it would be better to invest in some lessons for yourself and your daughter or look for a share scheme where you will have constant experienced support on hand?

Surely you or your experienced friend should have picked up at your inital viewings that the pony had issues with her feet, pelvis and teeth?

You've been told her teeth are in a state and need a lot of work yet you continued riding her.

Bottom line is you need to arrange a mutually convenient time to return the pony to her owner, who has been irresponsible buy misleading you regarding the pony's experience and by loaning her to you in the first place.
 
From several things you mention in your post, you do not seem experienced enough to have a pony on loan, maybe it would be better to invest in some lessons for yourself and your daughter or look for a share scheme where you will have constant experienced support on hand?

Surely you or your experienced friend should have picked up at your inital viewings that the pony had issues with her feet, pelvis and teeth?

You've been told her teeth are in a state and need a lot of work yet you continued riding her.

Bottom line is you need to arrange a mutually convenient time to return the pony to her owner, who has been irresponsible buy misleading you regarding the pony's experience and by loaning her to you in the first place.

rather harsh!! i have never inspected every tooth in the mouth of any horse i have ever bought,the front ones to check correct bite etc certainly but not way at the back where you need a gag, headtorch and long arms!! yes the state of the feet should have been noticed but pony was in a boggy field so not the easiest thing to do.
The fact that the OP has realised that the pony is not suitable and has not let herself be swayed by her heart to 'rescue' it suggests that she's not a complete muppet!!

I know this is so unpc OP but do you have a man who could phone the ponies owner for you? some people still think they can treat a woman different from a man and if the owner is one of these who thinks he can bully you into keeping and buying the pony just because you're a woman, getting a man to phone up to arrange the return may just be the answer.;)
 
thanks every one for your posts. Some of you have been very helpful even I do sound like a bit of a "muppet"

I did say in my post that I had owned my own pony years ago and rode to local competition SJ levels but that was 20 years ago and my pony was an absolute gem had done everything, seen everything so I have not had a tremendous amount of experience with green ponies therefore don't know how to handle them to bring them on but when we enquired about the pony(and I have an email sent buy the owner to prove the next phrase) we were told she was an "easy going pony" who is great in the stable. Unfortunately our experience in the stable is nips with ears back at any given time. My reasons for sending back are because were told the pony just needed to get back into the swing of things after not been ridden for so long but it turns out that the pony didn't know what the "swing of things" are.

The month trial is up next Sunday and the pony will go back regardless. I am worried what will happen to her as these people have admitted that they don't know the first thing about horses and the man actually said that he is scared of them. I'd like to think that someone who has the time and the knowledge of green ponies to make a difference will get her, but if they advertise her as an easy going pony again I fear the worst.
 
No you are not a time-waster. The pony's owner has wasted your time and money. The pony was mis-advertised.

I feel very sorry for the pony, she is obviously in pain, despite having had her back and feet done. It is possible that when the dentist has finished with her, she may be much better to ride, or she may not be, because she is very green and she may remember the pain and associate it with the work you have been doing with her.

In your position, I would make your daughter and her confidence, the priority. I would tell the pony's owner a time when the pony and its tack will be returned, at a time when a reasonable person could be expected to be available, or to have made arrangements for someone else to be there. then I would take the pony back, whence it came. It is not your responsibility.

Next time you go to try a pony for your daughter, take a truly experienced person with you and ask this person to check the pony's conformation, way of going and feet. See the pony ridden in all the situations your daughter will want to ride it. Then put your daughter on and let her try it in all the same situations.
If ALL is well, consider loaning the pony. If there are any question marks at all, walk away.
 
Thank you for that. I really did feel that I had done as much by the book as my knowledge allowed and I trusted my friends judgement as she has had ponies of her own for years and she has managed to choose 2 exceptional ponies for her own daughter (same age as mine). In the circumstances of the viewing it was difficult to fully assess the pony and with first impressions and the anecdotes of the owners we assumed that essentially that the pony was just in need of some time and regular riding which she would most definitely have received from us. How wrong we were.:(
 
Sorry you have had so many problems but to be honest I am not surprised she is rearing if she has very bad teeth that require extensive dental work that hasn't been done. The bit may be agony for the poor thing especially if they previosly had her in an ill fitting bit. Poor pony :( hope you get it sorted.
 
...also like op I wouldn't vet s loan pony & from my experience as a loaner & loanee people are generally quite up front about animal. Pays to be completely honest if you want loan to work. Appreciate this was s loan WVTB but if owner had been honest far greater chance of it being a succesful placement.
 
I feel sorry for both you and the pony, it's such a shame it didn't work out but agree you have to be sensible and return within the time specified for the initial loan period. Hope you find a suitable pony in the future.
 
Top