Opinions needed please, WWYD?

horsemadelsie

Well-Known Member
Joined
3 November 2010
Messages
559
Visit site
Bit of a long story, but I really need some help choosing the best course of action. Before anyone asks, I have discussed this with my vet.
My JRT is 9 years old, and for the last few months I have noticed that she makes noise when breathing lying down. She doesn't always make the noise, and it doesn't seem to bother her at all, even though she is a nervous dog. It sounds a bit like she is snoring, but it happens when she is wide awake, and she has never snored before in her life (she sleeps right next to my bed and I am a light sleeper). She is completely fine when she is up and moving- she competes at grade 6 KC agility, with some 1st and 2nd places this summer, so she clearly is not struggling to breathe! I never hear the noise when she is standing or sitting, even when she is out of breath from running.
The vet has examined her throat as much as he can, and cannot see or feel anything wrong. He gave us some anti-inflammatories for a week in case her tonsils were inflamed with a minor virus or something, but these made no difference. He advised that if I was still worried the only thing to do to investigate further is to knock her out and scope her so they can see if there is anything there too small to feel, they would have to have her in for the day.
My problem is, is it worth putting her through it? She is a very nervous dog, panting and shaking violently when in sight of the vets, and she hates strange people, even when they aren't vets. She has been gradually getting better the last 6 years, but progress is painfully slow. She seems fine and happy in herself, and has not got worse in the last 2 months. Do I want to put her through such an ordeal and risk increasing her fear (she was only bad at the vets when she was last knocked out, when she was spayed at 1 year old). But then a little voice in the back of my head says what if there is a problem, and by catching it early the prognosis would be so much better? She's my dog of a lifetime, what if I left it and it was the wrong decision?
My vet says only I can make the decision, as I know her best, but what would you all do?
 
I suspect a quick knock out to view with a scope is not a huge procedure - but mu question is what would you do if you found something? If it were a lump would the vet be able to operate? What would he/she project the success rate to be?

For me that would be the crux of it.
 
Sounds like a minor soft palate problem perhaps? I would just leave it well alone if it isn't bothering her or impacting on her quality of life
 
That's a huge dilemma, but if it's recent, I think I'd see if you could get her sedated before taking her to the vet. Is there a canine equivalent to ACP? I'd want her checked out, but I don't know if scoping her throat would give you answers? If not, where do you go next?
 
Thanks everyone :) The vet wasn't sure if there would be anything to find or not- obviously if there was something found on a scope then it would depend what it was as to the plan of action/prognosis etc. If there was nothing found then we would leave her as she is, just raise the issue again if there were any changes or if she was struggling with breathing at all.
 
Nine isn't old for a jrt. Could you sedate her prior to going to vets? Unfortunately it's difficult to say because if you do nothing and it turns out to be something that's easily treated you may well wish you'd done something.
Only you know your dog well enough to decide.
 
I suspect a quick knock out to view with a scope is not a huge procedure - but mu question is what would you do if you found something? If it were a lump would the vet be able to operate? What would he/she project the success rate to be?

For me that would be the crux of it.

^ This. No diagnosis is useful if there is no treatment.

Vet needs to
(a) have a decent success rate for GA (should be fine for dogs - I apply this to other animals that are trickier)
(b) know what things they are looking for, and for some of those to be pretty serious
(c) be in a position to treat (op, ideally whilst under after quick call to me/medicate) at least some of the things they check for in (b) with decent prognosis
before I'd consider it.
 
Ok, my border terrier who is no longer with me (unrelated to the breathing thing) had a similar sounding thing. I had him scoped but he was already out for a dental, so it wasn't like I had a GA just for that. They found nothing sinister. However, when he was a youngster, he had snorted up a grass seed which was removed and I think maybe there was some scarring from that which as he got older became more loose or somehow obstructed the breathing to a degree. If, like you say, it's not hindering your dogs breathing to be able to carry on at G6 I'd say you're doing ok. But I'd keep an eye (and ear) on it and if it becomes an issue later, scope.

I must say, now that he's gone, I miss his snores
 
I had a similar decision to take about my dog, totally unrelated medically.

I took the decision to go ahead with investigations as I felt that if later she was seriously ill and untreatable I would not forgive myself for not going ahead although I knew she would react badly to GA and after affects of minor investigative surgery.
 
Top