Preferred turn out - mixed or seperate?

How much does an average visit cost?


  • Total voters
    0

pocket

Well-Known Member
Joined
21 August 2005
Messages
883
Location
KENT
Visit site
For the past 20 years, I have been at yards that have mixed herds. There has never been a problem and all the horses have been happily mixed.

Last year, a few dominant mares came to the yard and have rocked the herd, by 'turning' the geldings, mine being one of them. He has been pinned against the fence by 3 mares all squirting at him! It was vile. In all my years around horses, I have never seen this, they even stop outside his stable and squirt. Geldings have been fighting in order to get a little hareem and mares have been agressive as well.

After much debate, we were able to get the YO to split the fields, but this has caused concern with some as they are worried that the fields will not be rested, not at all worried that their horses may be injured!

If I were to move, I will never go back to a mixed herd and would only consider small group turn out. What do most other yards do?
 

reddie

Well-Known Member
Joined
29 March 2007
Messages
1,978
Visit site
Mine's in a large group of geldings on a livery yard and fortunately they all get on pretty well, don't get the problem of one being left on thier own. if i could choose i would like the group ot be abit smaller though. I definitely wouldn't want individual turnout though now. My lads much happier running with a herd.
 

Paint it Lucky

Well-Known Member
Joined
19 March 2007
Messages
3,587
Location
Surrey
Visit site
I think it very much depends on the particular mares and geldings, some get on fine others are very flirty/aggressive etc and so need to be seperated. I don't particularly like individual turnout (although i know it suits some horses) but i think most horses are happier with company.
 

hellybelly6

Well-Known Member
Joined
24 June 2008
Messages
3,310
Visit site
My gelding can go out with mares, but needs to be the only gelding as he will fight other geldings over them.

He is fine t/o with geldings, but will assert his authority as he is the biggest and the most dominant (he still has a 'nut sack')

I prefer sep gelds/mares in nice small herds of 3/4.
 

ChowChow

Well-Known Member
Joined
27 October 2007
Messages
262
Location
Up North
Visit site
[ QUOTE ]
I think it very much depends on the particular mares and geldings, some get on fine others are very flirty/aggressive etc and so need to be seperated. I don't particularly like individual turnout (although i know it suits some horses) but i think most horses are happier with company.

[/ QUOTE ]

Did you do those lovely paintings?
 

RachelB

Well-Known Member
Joined
25 December 2004
Messages
6,881
Location
back of beyond
Visit site
I can't vote, because my "preferred" method of turnout is in pairs. My mare was in with a gelding whilst I had her on livery, and this not only worked well in that they paired up, got on well (they were paired with suitability for eachother in mind) but also I shared chores with the gelding's owner so we each got a lie-in once in a while.
My horse is now in her own field though, at her new home. There are only three horses and while putting all of them in together seems a good idea, the one gelding gets very aggressive and difficult when he's in with mares (even just one). Our other issue is restricting our grazing - my horse gets very little grass, but the other two get far more and it just wouldn't work keeping them together. I HATE keeping my horse seperate but until our grazing can be less restricted and we get a fourth horse, they will stay seperate. I also don't like large mixed herds when the horses are shod - too risky.
 

hellybelly6

Well-Known Member
Joined
24 June 2008
Messages
3,310
Visit site
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I think it very much depends on the particular mares and geldings, some get on fine others are very flirty/aggressive etc and so need to be seperated. I don't particularly like individual turnout (although i know it suits some horses) but i think most horses are happier with company.

[/ QUOTE ]

Did you do those lovely paintings?

[/ QUOTE ]

I was wondering the same thing, they are fab
 

ChowChow

Well-Known Member
Joined
27 October 2007
Messages
262
Location
Up North
Visit site
I prefer seperate. Although my previous horse was turned out in a mixed herd after being kept seperate for years without much bother but he became very attached to one of the mares and was a pain if either one of them were seperated.

On yard is seperate we tried mixed and it caused no end of trouble.
 

luckilotti

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 January 2006
Messages
2,176
Location
Lancashire
hillhousestables.co.uk
what do you class as a large and small herd?
we offer mixed grazing in a larger herd (about 15max) there is normally a few fields open so they can wonder at their leisure and there is plenty of space. however we pretty much do what the liveries want! We have some smaller groups for the 'fatties', one that is hard to catch in the bigger fields etc.
On occassions we have had to seperate one or two over the years as they have 'rocked the boat' but from my experience, mixed seems to work best providing that there is ample space for them all, Seperate grazing from when i was a livery on a yard did not work when the fields were adjoinging - mare jumped in with gelding - was chased until she collapsed!
 

not_with_it

Well-Known Member
Joined
14 April 2002
Messages
4,019
Location
Yorkshire
Visit site
It really depends on the horse. My mare is out on her own and is very happy. My gelding is still a baby so goes out with 1 or 2 other geldings.

My mare was recently out with a gelding who jumped on her back causing her to have a haematoma on her sacroiliac joint. She was out of work for over 2 months and it cost me a fortune in vets bills.
Once my youngster is backed he will go out with my mare if they get on. That way if they injure each other I can only blame myself.
 

loopylucifer

Well-Known Member
Joined
26 March 2003
Messages
736
Location
button moon
Visit site
did not vote as didn't have a 'it depends'.but if field big enough then a few geldings in with mares is fine offten too many geldings with only a few mares caurses problems. dont like pairs or three as seperation can be an issue about 5-10 in a big field 10acers.
 

CrazyMare

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 December 2005
Messages
11,713
Visit site
We turn out in pairs
smile.gif
works well for us. My filly will go into a small herd of 2 yearlings and an older mare after she is weaned.
 

flyingfeet

Well-Known Member
Joined
16 March 2006
Messages
8,073
Location
South West
Visit site
I put individual - if I was at a livey yard, I would not be happy with my horses turned out with 'unknown' quantities. So for sake of an easy life I would want my own turnout space (also better if they want poo picking done). Grass has never been an issue, as I have fat horses, so lack of food wouldn't worry me!

At home I have my herd and a pair of competing boys. I carefully mix the herd and make sure the personalities don't clash!
 

Marchtime

Well-Known Member
Joined
5 December 2007
Messages
1,397
Visit site
Individual! But only because my horse is rather evil. He likes his own space and won't share. Individual also prevents horses injuring each other and rugs getting ripped etc. It's simpler. However, I'd hate my pony to be on individual turn out as she lives out and loves company. She has a best mate and they are out as a pair.
 

Chex

Well-Known Member
Joined
31 October 2006
Messages
4,024
Location
Scotland
Visit site
Chex is out with a mare and a gelding. He's always been in mixed herds and its always been fine unless there's a very dominant mare. I don't like turning out in pairs because he gets soooo clingy, making it near impossible to do things separately. Ideally he'd be out with about 4 other horses, but none that will pick on him
frown.gif
. He was kept by himself during the day over summer in a piggy paddock, but he was really miserable so its not something I'd choose to do.
 

piebaldsparkle

Well-Known Member
Joined
26 July 2006
Messages
13,017
Visit site
Sparks is on her own which isn't ideal, but is easier and safer!!! I don't like turning out in pairs as the get too clingy IMO. Small herd would be my preferance (but only if it was 'my herd'), I wouldn't want unknown animals being added.
 

amandaco2

Well-Known Member
Joined
2 November 2006
Messages
6,705
Location
sheffield up t'road
Visit site
i think mixed are fine
as long as the horse get on and there is a clear leader and plenty of space.
i think if there are constant fights the offending horses need to be removed
my horses have been out in small groups, althoughg if the fields were bigger i wouldnt mind them being in a bigger herd.
 

Gorgeous George

Well-Known Member
Joined
2 April 2007
Messages
6,268
Location
Essex
Visit site
there are only geldings where I am, they go out in groups of 3 or 4 and the groups only change if there is a major problem or a horse leaves. At my previous yard it was indiv trurnout and whilst it is peace of mind against injuries I just didn't like George being on his own - esp as he couldn't even touch another horse over the fence.
 

Tia

Well-Known Member
Joined
21 January 2004
Messages
26,100
Visit site
I have 6 fields in action right now and they are a very mixed bag of horses. I put horses that get along together well in with each other; I don't care whether they are mares or geldings, it's just which horses like each other best.

One field I have only has geldings in it, mainly because they are big horses whereas most of the other horses are small QHs. This is the "boys field"; always has been known as this even if there are a couple of mares in there from time to time, Lol! At present there are 7 geldings in this field.

Another field has 8 babies and 5 mares. Two of the yearlings in this field are colts, the rest are mares and fillies. The colts are very very well behaved; they are being gelded next month but not because they are bad mannered (they aren't, they are exceptionally well behaved as per usual in a situation like this).

A couple of my fields have just mares in them, not for any reason other than these horses get along well.

Another field has a mixed group.

I rarely have more than 7 or 8 adult horses in any one field but once in a while I will combine 2 herds if there is a lot of grass in one particular field.

I don't put up with any bullying and if this ever happens then I split the culprits up and generally find a more manageable group to put together.

The majority of the horses who live here have lived here for years, and at some point in time most of them have lived in the same field so they all know each other well, and I know which horses get along and which don't.

For a couple of years I had mares, my stallion and a gelding living in a field together. Then when my stallions babies came along I moved the gelding out and left the stallion with his mares and his foals. Worked perfectly; everyone got along beautifully.
smile.gif


Most of my fields are decent sized though - generally about 10 acres each and then I have some smaller paddocks which I use intermittently.

Works for me and my lot.
smile.gif
 

RachelFerd

Well-Known Member
Joined
24 April 2005
Messages
3,492
Location
NW
www.facebook.com
I think the yard I am at has a good system - the part and full liveries are turned out in pairs (except a few that need to be turned out individually) and the pairs are decided in a logical fashion so they all get on.

The grass liveries are split into mares and geldings and turned out in small herds (max 5) so there aren't too many problems when introducing a new horse.
 

Theresa_F

Well-Known Member
Joined
10 August 2005
Messages
5,577
Location
London - Essex side
Visit site
All depends on the horses - to date, all of mine mares or geldings have been fine with the opposite sex. I just keep my two together and now have one of each.

Several times a week they are taken away from each other so they don't get too attached and are happy to be parted and even more happier to be back together.

When Chancer was by himself, even though horses were next door, he was very unhappy. Luckily Farra loves to groom him as much as he loves to groom her and they get on very well.
 

keekee

Well-Known Member
Joined
1 April 2008
Messages
456
Visit site
I have gone from keepig my mare with 1 other to intrducing her to a small heard i was so worried about her being injured but at this particular yard it was this or nothing and 2 monthes in she is happier than ever 3 gelding and 3 mares it,s strange but gelds go in 1 direction and mares in other but all is well so far ..
 

SouthWestWhippet

Well-Known Member
Joined
7 June 2006
Messages
2,343
Location
Somerset
Visit site
Voted seperate mares/geldings small herds.

I have found that you can get away with bigger herds of geldings than you seem to be able to with mares before 'injuries' start appearing. The geldings seem to 'play' more with each other - play fighting etc - whilst when the mares kick off they mean business.

But that is just my experience.
 

badgerdog

Well-Known Member
Joined
22 February 2008
Messages
1,188
Location
Northumberland
Visit site
Mine are in a mixed herd of about 12 on 20 acres with access to two fields. They seem very contented. There are a few mini herds and pairs and there is never any bother. My two year old has been in this herd since she was a yearling and has thrived in the company of a diverse age range of both sexes. She was previously in a field with 3 other youngsters of the same age but she was nervous of older horses. Since being with the mixed herd she is much more settled and confident. We have a field with a pair in and they are very clingy, whinnying and pacing up and down when one leaves. I would much prefer to keep my horses in a mixed herd as long as there is plenty of space of them.
 
Top