Problematic breed traits

Spudlet

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 April 2009
Messages
19,800
Visit site
Just a general musing really...

So to take one at random, some people think Arabs are very spooky horses, cobs are slow and fat, etc etc...

But are these traits totally down to the breed of horse, or are they partly down to people not taking the tendencies of the breed into account and not adjusting the way they keep them accordingly?

So for example, moving away from horses to dogs for a moment: many people will tell you spaniels are crazy dogs. But often, the problems people experience happen (in my opinion anyway) because people take a dog that was bred for working and hunting all day and expect it to be happy with a wander round the park a couple of times a day. If you exercise them enough and train in a way that harnesses those traits, you are much less likely to have a loopy dog. Surely the same could be said for horses?

So cobs, for example - bred to be in hard work with possibly not much in the way of high-quality nutrition available - so very good at getting maximum benefit from minimum grazing. Keep them on a lush pasture with just a small amount of work, and surely it's obvious that they'll get porky?

And Arabs - bred to survive in the desert and be warhorses that needed little in the way of food or water - surely the same applies - except that they may well get a wee bit loopy?

Do people have enough awareness of the breed traits of the horses they buy, or is there still a tendency to think of horses as just horses - and to assume that the way you keep one breed will be ok for another?

Just a Sunday morning musing really:)
 
I think people who own all species of pet animal should take more notice of what the breed was bred to do - I think that way we'd have less wastage of good animals that just weren't right for what they were bought for. Me included :)
 
defo the living arrangements affect them, we have a Siberian husky & as long as she can get down yard with me twice a day & have a long run she is a sweetheart but miss those runs & god help the house!

as for Welshies they are all bloody minded & stubbern, the sec D & sec C i used to ride were, my sec A is & so is my OH (also welsh!) think its just a welsh thing.
 
Not problematic but the few Connie x tb's that I have owned/know have been difficult rides to say the least, incredibly sweet and kind and I couldn't ask for more gentle, quietly affectionate horses but they were troublesome to ride! It wouldn't stop me having one though as all their amazing natures make the hiccups worth while :)
 
Not problematic but the few Connie x tb's that I have owned/know have been difficult rides to say the least, incredibly sweet and kind and I couldn't ask for more gentle, quietly affectionate horses but they were troublesome to ride! It wouldn't stop me having one though as all their amazing natures make the hiccups worth while :)

Ooops. Heck. I've just bought a Connie x TB...... I was hoping she was going to be a sweetheart to ride, and although young, did seem chilled when I rode her. She has seemed to display rather more 'spirit' since she arrived, though I haven't ridden her yet as I don't have a saddle - so looks like I could be in for more than I bargained!!!
 
Lets face it, people dont even stop to think if they are suitable breeders themselves before knocking out kids so why on earth would they think about what breed of dog or cat they are likely to get :D
 
Not problematic but the few Connie x tb's that I have owned/know have been difficult rides to say the least, incredibly sweet and kind and I couldn't ask for more gentle, quietly affectionate horses but they were troublesome to ride! It wouldn't stop me having one though as all their amazing natures make the hiccups worth while :)

Based on my experience of them I definitely agree!
 
on the same sort of note why do people think that its JUST a native pony so therefore dosent need to be treated with respect and are then suprised when it wont do as they ask or that if a native isnt shivering then it is over rugged and should have less rugs on than the unclipped horses even though he is fully clipped out (and I do mean fully clipped no hair left).
sorry that turned in to a bit of a rant :o
 
Top