Problems with my sharer - should I let her go or persevere?

Tash88

Well-Known Member
Joined
2 January 2012
Messages
1,782
Visit site
I'm going to try to keep this brief so bear with me...

Some of you will remember my post a couple of months ago about the lady who was interested in sharing my horse - I had never had a sharer before and I was worried about her being much better than me and my feelings as a result. To cut a long story short the viewing went well and she agreed to share him - she is quite bossy and could come across as rude if you didn't know her better, I can be sensitive but have just got used to it. She rides my horse quite well, although in a different style to me, shorter stirrups and with a fairly strong contact that looks quite defensive; she is beginning to relax a bit though.

She loves schooling and bringing on young horses, and seems to think she is really good at it, so she was interested in schooling him more than hacking him. We arranged for her to have him two days a week and I said that she could school both days but I'd prefer it if she hacked one day and schooled the other because I wanted to school him as well and I didn't want him to be in the school all week. She seemed to appreciate that, but has only hacked him once since she's been riding him independently (started on the 1st May), despite me showing her the routes (borrowing a horse and taking her out) and other liveries offering to hack out with her.

I will say that she has helped me with my horse, his schooling has improved (she is a tougher rider than me) and he has got fitter, but this has come with a price. He is rather sharp and has a nasty 180 degree spin in him; he usually does this when frightened and it is very difficult to sit to. He hasn't done this with me since November last year, but she has come off him five times now, all in the school. Four of those were spins and the first one was just him getting angry with her constantly asking all the time, so bucking hugely and tanking off down the school. Since that first fall I have reiterated that she has to tell him when he's been good as he is very trainable but also very sensitive, and he needs to be reassured and praised rather than nagged all the time. She took that on board and was doing well with him until last week, when she came off twice.

She called me and was clearly cross with him - he had chucked her off in the indoor school so she took him into the outdoor school, where he did it again. Apparently then she was in tears out of frustration - she got back on but only had ten minutes of riding time left because she had to get back to her 18 month old daughter. She said that if she had time she would have walked him round for an hour and made him listen to her, but obviously she couldn't. She is incredibly stubborn and my horse doesn't seem to be reacting well to this - he is being difficult for her to catch in the field and is really pushing the boundaries with her. Since that incident on Wednesday I have hacked him out twice and he has been fine. I am meant to be watching her school him tomorrow evening with an instructor at the yard to see if there is anything she should be doing differently. She seems reluctant to have lessons.

She is a nice woman and we have developed a bit of a friendship, but I don't think this arrangement is working out. She seems to actively dislike my horse now, but she doesn't want to give up or give in; when things go well she adores him. She has a toddler and wants to expand her family, I'd always had this in the back of my mind and the other evening she told me that she wouldn't ride my horse if she was pregnant, she is trying now and conceives quickly apparently so I doubt she'll be around for much longer anyway. There is a safer horse at the yard who needs a sharer so he might be a better bet for her, but then she probably won't get the ego-boost that she seems to desire from bringing him on.

I don't know whether to see how tomorrow and the next few weeks pan out or just let her go now. I emailed her yesterday evening and usually she gets back to me straight away - have heard nothing. I do want her to keep sharing my horse, but I am wondering if there is any point. My friends at the yard think that I should get rid of her as I've apparently done a good job with him and they are worried that she is ruining him for me - I can't see evidence of that yet but it could happen.

I'm sorry that this is really badly written, but I think some impartial and straight-talking HHO advice would be very useful :o, thanks in advance.

Tash x
 
So let me get this straight . . . she thinks she is good at bringing horses on, your horse thinks otherwise and is increasingly bolshy with her, she isn't working him to your requirements (school AND hack every week), and she seems to actively dislike your horse . . . and you want to continue the share?

Honestly, Hon, I'd get rid. I wouldn't want anyone sitting on my boy who a) wasn't going to take on board what I told them about him and behave accordingly; b) be sympathetic and patient with his quirkiness and ride him through it rather than getting stroppy and either moaning or wanting to exhaust him out of it; c) my horse didn't like.

Hope this doesn't come across too harsh.

P
 
Your horse, your rules.
If she can't follow the rules, she can't ride your horse.
End of story for me I'm afraid :o
 
It sounds like your horse is trying to stay out of her way, even when she riding him. I'd listen to your horse. Tell her maybe they are not a good match, and get shut as soon as.
 
I think you horse is giving you every single signal possible lol !

I'd let her go will end up painful by the sounds of it :(
 
As everybody else. Get shot of her. She may be the bees' knees (or not) but your horse clearly doesn't like her (5 times of being dumped needs to be listened to) he's starting to regress (the spinning round). You could end up with a horse NEITHER of you can ride.

I had this situation with a sharer. I specifically asked that when hacking, she did not start to canter or gallop the moment she got onto grass, as it had taken me 3 years to break my extremely strong horse of this habit. And what did she do?? Let him rip every time he saw a bit of green. He then started shying at full tilt, and dumped her. I ended the relationship, but was left with a horse that I never got back to 'my' way of hacking, i.e. we'll have a canter when I say so, not you.

You went to a a lot of trouble to get people to show her the hacking routes etc. I think your horse will be sick to the back teeth of schooling. And also, as you too like to school, he won't know what's expected of him. End the deal!
 
In two months she's come off 5 times? I'd be worried that shes got away with no injuries so far and if she's coming off that often she's going to hurt herself? With an 18month to go back to surely its not sensible for her to put herself at risk? Let along the chance she might be getting pregnant again?

I may be wrong and I think I've read right,but she's not listening to you or even your horse and.for a 'strong rider' to come off that often is not normal?

IMO you are letting your pride or your wallet get in the way (I assume she contributes) and if there is a horse that would be safer for her then don't risk your horses reputation.
 
As a fellow sharer I'd echo what others have said. It does sound like he does not like her methods but she's not listening to him. Her getting angry and frustrated with him is not helping either. Neither emotion has any place when riding or handling horses in my opinion.
 
Yes agree - stop the arrangement. If you find it difficult to let her down you can just say that you are worried sick about her coming off and can't take the responsibility especially as she has a young child. Do it quick before your horse becomes a problem for you!
 
My rather sensitive lad absolutly hated my sharer, even on the ground he was on edge and if she called him in the field he totally ignored her. A week after her going he was back to the happy relaxed cheerful cheeky soul of old.

My advice would be to stop the arrangement.
 
End this it's does not sound like its doing your or the sharer any good.
He's your horse you are the one who will have to pick up the pieces if it makes him sour.
 
Thanks all - the reason that I haven't stopped it already is because apart from the falling off, she has been doing a good job with him and my YO says that she looks great on him. But this can't keep happening - he isn't doing anything with her that he didn't do with me 18 months ago; I think these are just teething problems and he is testing her, but I can't have that affecting what I do with him.

I think she has made a decision as she hasn't replied to any texts or emails for a couple of days which is unlike her, hopefully she'll tell me that it's over otherwise I'll have to tell her.

To the poster who said my pride/wallet was in the way - thanks for your response but I feel like I need to say something to that. I think it is her pride that is the problem and she doesn't really pay me that much; I can cope without her, it's just that I have a very busy job and her time is more useful to me.
 
Yes agree - stop the arrangement. If you find it difficult to let her down you can just say that you are worried sick about her coming off and can't take the responsibility especially as she has a young child. Do it quick before your horse becomes a problem for you!

I have tried this, fortunately she hasn't been hurt yet but it could only be a matter of time. I think she is coming around to it now, tbh there's no point in me keeping her on if she's just going to get pregnant and stop riding anyway. I know that sounds a bit mercenary but it's true. She may have ridden for Olympic showjumpers in Canada and numerous people over here, but she can't get on with my horse and that's it.
 
Top