Shall I get boots that are slightly too large or too tight

Scuderia

Active Member
Joined
22 December 2011
Messages
35
Location
London
Visit site
Another newbie question to do with sizes.

I ordered a pair of extra wide (I have no idea why) boots online and they arrived a couple of days ago but they don't fit. I'm sending them back for a replacement but my calves seem to be in between the two other sizes they have on offer. They have a wide width size 10 that's 41.5cm and a regular width size 9 that has a 39cm calf. They don't have a regular width size 10 but I think I could squeeze into the 9s because the 10s had lots of wiggle room on the foot, a centimetre at the front and lots on the sides of my ankle. Could this be because they're extra wide?

My calves are 40.5cms and 41cms and I read online that boots get slightly looser when you wear them in. Bearing this in mind, shall I go for the smaller size 9s and let them loosen up or go for the size 10s and hope they don't end up like wellies?

For the record, the boots are Rhinegold Olympic Boots with zips and the extra wide boots are for a 43cm calf and they're like buckets! Not sure how much of a difference 1.5cm will make to the fit. They're dirt cheap at £55 and I'll want them to last about 6 months to a year. If I decide to keep riding I'll get an upgrade.
 

rhino

Well-Known Member
Joined
19 July 2009
Messages
10,111
Location
Border Reiver
Visit site
I would be tempted to go for the bigger ones; nothing worse than having too tight shoes/boots. I end up wearing long ski socks under my boots in the winter and often ride in jeans instead of jodhs which I wouldn't be able to do if my boots were tight.

In my experience leather boots tend to 'drop' more than expand really :)
 

caberston

Well-Known Member
Joined
16 February 2011
Messages
353
Visit site
i'd go for the smaller size... otherwise you risk ending up with a pair of baggy wellies when they drop. i bought a pair of ariat bromonts in summer which i was sure weren't even going to do up in the shop... i persevered and wore them in, now they've dropped and the leather's stretched a bit so they fit fine.
 
Top