Swapped at birth...

GinnieRedwings

Well-Known Member
Joined
5 February 2009
Messages
1,181
Location
Norfolk
Visit site
Well not quite. Swapped at a day old by their Mums.
I was just wondering if anyone had ever heard of this happening.
10 years ago, next door's colt jumped in with my mares and 11 months later, Minnie, a 13.2hh Welsh Section C, and Bracken, a 15hh TBx, gave birth on the very same day to a bay filly (Rosebud) and a tobiano colt (Hugo).

This is Hugo on the day he was born with him Mum Bracken & Rosie at 4 months with Mum Minnie:
H13-1.jpg


They both foaled in the paddock on 21/04/02, but the weather turned very wet cold and nasty in the evening so they went in their stables with their respective foal. In the morning, the weather had improved, so I turned the 4 of them out in the stables paddock - Minnie & Bracken had been field companions for 2 years and got on very well.

When I came back at lunchtime to check on everyone, this is what I found:
S25C-111032212070_0004-1.jpg

S25C-111032212070_0001-1.jpg


I did try to return the foals to they true Mum, but didn’t get anywhere… Bracken’s face in that second picture says it all “don’t touch my baby… get your own!”.

I was very new to this game and was a bit puzzled as to what to do… so I phoned the local Arabian stud and asked them for advice. They’d never heard of anything like this, but said that if the foals were suckling fine and the Mums were happy, then I should just leave it!

So in the evening, I led each Mum to her stable, with the wrong baby at foot…

In the morning, I fed and just opened the stable doors onto the paddock as the babies were lying down so I wanted to let them come out in their own time. Bracken suddenly barged out of her stable, leaving Rosie behind, barged into Minnie’s stable, booted her out and got her own baby Hugo back. And that was it. They were always turned out together until the foals were weaned and there was no more swapping babies or suckling from the wrong Mum.

Very weird. Anyone ever seen/heard of something like that happening?
 
Wow that is fascinating, I have never heard of that before. We do have one mare that will allow any foal to suckle from her, but foals tootle back to their own mums when they are full (good job she always has lots of milk).
 
Gosh - thats a funny story ! I can imagine the matter of fact manner the mares behaved in being really puzzling for you ! After all they know best
 
I remeber one mare on the stud snoozing in the sun when a foal came up to her and started sucking. The dozed on with eyes shut and then turned to nudge the foal and realised that it wasn't hers but an imposter! The look on her face was priceless. Foal was duly chased off but ran and hid behind her mother, who was the big boss, and defied the wronged mare to come any closer.
 
Actually I was working at a stud when two mares turned out together foaled unexpectedly one night. In the morning the chestnut Sec C mare who had gone to a chestnut stallion had a huge bay foal and the enormous bay D mare had a smaller chestnut foal. Obviously they had done a nighttime switcheroo.

Anyway the outcome was that the foals were each raised by the wrong mare until weaning with no ill effects. Even if the colour issue hadn't made the switch over obvious within a couple of months it would have been very clear what had happened as each foal was the spitting image of the real dam & sire combination it had, and nothing like the surrogate!

Not seen it happen anywhere before or after though..
 
I was told a story by a previous employer about 2 mares swapping foals... they'd had pretty much identical looking foals!! plain bay with no markings. the only difference was 1 had a whorl behind poll and the other had it about an inch behind...... they swapped.. it wasn't till they were dna tested once they'd gone back to owners that the mistake was noticed!!!

We had to be very vigilant over ensuring mares hadn't swapped!!!

I have seen random foals coming and drinking from a mare while her foal was off playing!!! She was obviously the local milk bar!!! :)
 
Ive neard some parents say they wish their children had been swapped at birth but this is something else!!
Lovely story, thanks for sharing.
 
It sounds like this is more likely to happen if the mares have foaled out in the field together. We keep our newly foaled mares in a nursery paddock on their own for a while before putting them back in with the herd. Because of this the bond with their foals is very strong, so I doubt it would ever happen with any of our girls.
 
Anyway the outcome was that the foals were each raised by the wrong mare until weaning with no ill effects.

See, THAT would have made more sense! I can easily imagine a situation where the foals decided to go and say hello to each other, mares not initially noticing then one retrieving the wrong foal in the confusion and panic that might have ensued... and then keep the "new" baby until weaning.

But, they did swap back the morning after, and the way they did it - or at least the way Bracken did it - was strangest of all. Interestingly, she was the one that WASN'T a maiden. Perhaps it occured to her in the middle of the night that Rosie wasn't hers after all (though I would have defied anyone to try and take her away from her that first day!!! Fierce mare :D). But she didn't hurt her.

they'd had pretty much identical looking foals!! plain bay with no markings. the only difference was 1 had a whorl behind poll and the other had it about an inch behind...... they swapped.. it wasn't till they were dna tested once they'd gone back to owners that the mistake was noticed!!!

:D :D No such issue in this case... The size difference actually made the swap quite comical. Hugo was nearly on his knees suckling the Section C & Rosie (who was named Rosebud because she was such a tiny delicate thing when she was born - though she didn't stay that way :eek:) just whizzed under Bracken's belly if anyone tried to go near!!!

We keep our newly foaled mares in a nursery paddock on their own for a while before putting them back in with the herd. Because of this the bond with their foals is very strong, so I doubt it would ever happen with any of our girls.

The saying "you live and learn" was invented for that situation :o...

I also now wait a couple of weeks before mixing mums & babies with each other/other horses!
 
Top