Tekna girth - stud girth?

[m1stify]

http://www.equestrianclearance.com/westgate_efi/tekna_ergonomic_girth/index.html?clearance=1

Just wondering would you consider this girth a stud girth. Small studs and small jumps .. In 2 minds whether I need a stud guard at all and was considering an attachment but they look really fiddly & this one is same price as the attachment

 

[Sare]

I use those and no, they are definitely not big enough to be used as a stud girth, theyre only a little wider than a normal girth on the fat bit. They are fab girths though!