Toughest lightweight turnout

[noblesteed]

I am looking for a new no-fill turnout for my middleweight rug-trasher. An Amigo fits him very well but he has trashed the last two I have bought him, even losing the tail flap off the newest one!!! SO although I love the amigo I don;t want to get another 600d one as it will be in pieces in a couple of weeks.
SO any ideas as to which rug is the least rippable? I have looked at Amigo 1200d, a caldene one which is v expensive, but I saw a Masta Aztex one in the sale which is meant to be really tough? Any ideas if the Masta is any good?
Or do I just get the tougher Amigo?
I am expecting to start my maternity leave after xmas so I want horsey well kitted out before I go down to beans on toast wages and husband takes charge of finances.... Eeeeek!!!!

 

[ISHmad]

The Amigo 1200D ones are very tough, really like those. Also the Mark Todd ones.

 

[Toffee44]

Have a look on Ebay there are a few makes onthere that might do 1600d ones.

 

[Tammytoo]

I've had the Amigo 1200D and its definitely loads tougher than the 600D!

 

[becca1305]

The shires rainsheets/ lightweights have done a good job for me...I wouldnt say my horses are awful rug trashers but several have gone in the past and it has never been a shires. They also seem to fit great on everything ; 15.2hh 3/4 cob xTB, 16.1hhh full TB exrace, 16.3hh 3/4TBXID and 16hh ISH all fit well in them

 

[Silmarillion]

I have a Rambo Supreme, it's fab