I also used Duplo. They last for ages, I seemed to keep going with just getting removes.I haven’t used the Versa’s but when I took my Connie out of steel shoes due to hock arthritis and before he retired I used Duplos which are another composite brand and they were brilliant. They were nailed on rather than glued and they regularly lasted at least 3 cycles which is good as they were £180 for a full set. If he ever needed shoes again I would put him in glue ons.
Our horses are in on pea gravel pens over winter so not much chance to check them out in mud.What's your ground like? I'd be interested to hear how they perform in sticky mud, I mentioned glue ons to our farrier (to minimise concussion, arthritis) but he felt that with our clay-ey ground they'd be difficult to keep on.