Vets jumping to conclusions?

libbyandblue

Well-Known Member
Joined
28 September 2008
Messages
460
Location
Edinburgh
Visit site
So for those of you how know me, my eventer got diagnosed with metabolic syndrome last year after he came down with unexpected laminitis after doing our first novice at Oatridge where he hit a big table and got eliminated at the water after, very unlike him, so we thought he lost his confidence but looking back he could have sore feet. He was off from June to September and now back in full work, and finally sold :( (fingers crossed!! he was meant to be sold at the end of summer before I went to uni but obviously couldn't). My sister went down to Liverpool to the vet school as she might be doing a Phd in equine obesity, and there were some top vets there who were asking about my horse. They asked what tests our vets did, they just did a simple blood glucose test (can't remember what its called) which showed high levels of glucose and they then diagnosed him from that. Apparently they shouldn't have diagnosed him at all. There are loads more tests to do to actually prove the reason why his glucose levels were so high - que very annoyed sisters!! It seems to be a fairly new disease and vets just want to diagnose everything with it, I'd never heard of it, but now another one of our ponies (who had been sold on a couple of times) got put down of it, and I know a couple of others with it too.

It was so annoying, because we advertised him saying he had EMS, and he was on metformin tablets for 3/4 months which are very expensive, and there may not have been any need for it at all. He was fasted before the test was taken, he was also run on hard ground at Oatridge, and there were many other factors to show that he could've actually had laminitis caused by stress/concussion. I know it could be EMS, but we will never know now!!

So has anyone else had vets jumping to conclusions? Or anything similar to the EMS problem?
 
Do you mind me asking what other symptoms if any, your horse had. Just that my horse is fine when ridden but really stiffens up after exercise and farrier said she was turning on a circle as if she'd got laminitis. Called vet out on Monday, he checked her for laminitis and said she doesn't have usual clinical signs of lami. Taking her to Somerford tomorrow for x rays of feet.
 
I have a pet theory that these so called 'Glucose Intollerence' desieses are caused by the Soy products that are being fed to horses.

I still feed mine a very basic traditional diet - no processed feeds at all. Have worked with and owned horses for over 45 years and have never had a problem with metabolic diseases.
 
It is not fair to compare your local vet to those based at a vet school, the vet school vets have access to everything and can explore what ever they want with less cost limitations, your own vet, who's job is almost totally different has major financial limitations, symptoms of disease are often idiosyncratic.

Medicine is not an exact science and if you are unsure of your vets opinion talk to them about it or try for a second opinion, but remeber vets rely on you as you do them as they only see the animal for 30 mins at a time.
 
Top