Which boots? MH Rimfrost Rider or MH Stella Polaris?

[JenniferS]

Does anyone own any of the two? Which one is better? Any opinions?

http://www.robinsons-uk.com/products/search.asp?keyword=rimfrost&x=0&y=0#sku.21704

http://www.robinsons-uk.com/products/search.asp?keyword=stella&x=0&y=0#sku.21729

My Tuffa Norfolks are too cold so I'm going to buy a pair for the winter. I'm open to other suggestions (not Ariat!) as well.

They have to be:

Waterproof
Warm
Good quality
Suitable for daily riding & yardwork

Thank you.

 

[Chestnuttymare]

i have had the rimfrost ones, i really liked them, only issue was that the zip went in one and i had it replaced at the saddlers. They were really warm and waterproof, they were comfortable too. I think I had them for 2 years before they needed replaced. They actually tick all your boxes, I wore them daily and in the worst weather and conditions (live in scotland )
I haven't had the other ones but tbh, i don't think they are very good to look at. They do look really cozy though.

 

[Chestnut mare]

Same as chestnutty mare the zip also broke in my rimfrosts!! They are on their way to be repaired and I only wore them a few times! When I did wear them they were warm, comfortable and waterproof!

 

[Shay]

I have Rimfrosts and love them. I've never managed to break a zip on them though. I'm on my second pair (in about 8 years!). My daughter (becuase she grows out of them) is on her 4th or 5th.

Someone down the yard did buy a new pair of High riders and her zip broke. MH replaced the boots without question.

 

[kylie88]

I have the rimfrosts they are really warm and comfy but not worth the money in my opinion!
I was bought a pair not last xmas but the xmas before and had to have the replaced under warrenty within a year as they split and the second pair have done exactly the same! I should get theses replaced under warrenty to but I really can't be bothered with the hassel. Ive followed the instructions with both pairs about how to look after them too.I wouldn't buy another pair.