Would you cover their vet bill?

Inky1986

Member
Joined
25 June 2020
Messages
14
Visit site
Last week I was up the yard and one of the other owner's had her 2 dogs with her. Our yard does allow dogs on site as long as they are under control & well behaved.

Unfortunately one of them went too close to my gelding's back legs and was kicked and suffered a broken pelvis. Obviously I was mortified.

Fast forward a few days and the owner messaged me on Facebook saying her dog required an operation & subsequent PT (no insurance) and would I be able to pay half "as it was my horse's fault".

I haven't responded yet but I want to say no- it's a lot of money to fork out & my horse was safely tied up & minding his own business until then.

Am I being too tough? Would others agree to pay!?!
 

CanteringCarrot

Well-Known Member
Joined
1 April 2018
Messages
5,469
Visit site
Nope. She brought her dog to a yard where there are horses. This person knows that horses can kick.

Not your fault she has no insurance.

Not your fault she let her dog get so (inappropriately, IMO) close to a horse.

I don't know why people love to mix dogs and horses and think nothing can go wrong. My dog does come to the yard on occasion, mostly for walks on the trails there or swimming, and I am absolutely strict about her not going near any horses. If she did and got kicked, I would never imagine blaming the horse or owner and expecting some sort of financial assistance with the vet bills. I could never imagine doing that!
 

Pinkvboots

Well-Known Member
Joined
25 August 2010
Messages
21,373
Location
Hertfordshire
Visit site
No chance that is taking the p if you decide to let your dog off around horses unfortunately you take the risk they could get hurt end off, your horse was tied up and obviously felt threatened so kicked out that's what they do tell her to jog on.

The fact that she did it via Facebook would really piss me off what a cheek.
 

Trouper

Well-Known Member
Joined
11 May 2015
Messages
2,463
Visit site
I am sure her vet bill will be horrendous - but that is what insurance is for. I would never keep a dog without insurance - not just for the vet bills - but for the 3rd party cover for the animal "causing" harm to others. I know that the yard is not deemed as a "public place" in terms of keeping a dog under control but the yard rules are an effective substitute and she should have been on watch. Your horse was unable to remove itself from the threat of the dog as he was tied up, so to kick out was his only recourse.

I realise that it may make for an uncomfortable atmosphere on the yard but you should not be paying for her mistakes.
 

SAujla

Well-Known Member
Joined
4 September 2019
Messages
918
Visit site
No, dog was loose and horse was protecting itself, also they should have insurance if they know the dog would be in situations like this where accidents can easily happen.

I'm in a slightly similar position in that my dog got kennel cough from another dog she meets regularly and who was coughing for several days last week, but owner said they thought it was a scratch in the dogs throat, was £80 vet bill and confirmed kennel cough (sorry for going off point)
 

Winters100

Well-Known Member
Joined
18 April 2015
Messages
2,519
Visit site
What a sad situation, but I am afraid that I would not be paying any part of the bill. If I took a horse to a dog kennel and let it free I would not expect the dog owners to pay if it got bitten. I would also dispute her claim that it is your horse's 'fault' - he was following his instinct to protect himself from a perceived threat.

The reality is that the dog should not have been close enough to get kicked. Very sad, but it is the dog owner who made a mistake in this case, not you or your horse. As the owner of dogs who cannot be trusted around horses I have some sympathy, but as dog owners we have many solutions. On the very rare occasions that my dogs come to the yard they are on leashes or shut into a box, certainly nowhere near the back legs of a horse. The reality is that she was not in control of her dog, as if she had been it would not have been so close to your horse.

I suggest that you speak to her sympathetically and just explain that the horse was in the correct place, that any horse can kick, and that while you are very sorry that this occurred, you are not willing in the circumstances to contribute.

Edited to add that you may want to ask for the support of YO. I had a slightly similar situation a while back when another owner told me that my mare had "attacked" her dog. My horses were in the paddock, and it finally came out that her dog had been in the paddock chasing them and had got kicked. YO was very helpful in telling her that not only was I not liable for her vets bill, but that had one of my horses been injured then that cost would also have been on her. Thankfully she left the yard soon after.
 
Last edited:

abbijay

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 April 2011
Messages
1,384
Location
Cheshire
Visit site
This drives me mad. You have followed the rules and done no wrong but now there is going to be one hell of an atmosphere because of her stupidity.
I believe my horses to be good around dogs and kids but I will always tell people that I can't guarantee they won't kick - because they are horses!
I used to be on a yard where an owner let her dog loose whenever he came up; apparently as a rescue he couldn't go on a lead :rolleyes: this dog was very friendly but completely unaware of the horses - he would walk under their bellies and was once found in a stable with a known kicker (we used stable chains in good weather there). The problem was when asked to keep him under control or away from horses she just said "oh he's fine with horses" but had my horse reacted I know the expectation would have been that it was my fault. Interestingly this same owner's horse kicked a friend's horse and broke its leg. Strangely she didn't think that was her responsibility.
Definitely not your problem but expect her to make your life difficult as a result of you not paying for her stupidity.
 

BeckyFlowers

Well-Known Member
Joined
25 July 2017
Messages
1,665
Visit site
Not a chance. As per what the others have said, but also your horse was where he was supposed to be - on a livery yard, the purpose of which is to keep horses. The purpose of a livery yard is not a dog exercise area. If you took your horse into a dog exercise pen or a kennel without invitation and it booted a dog then you would be responsible. But that is not the case. Sad for the dog.
 

milliepops

Wears headscarf aggressively
Joined
26 July 2008
Messages
27,538
Visit site
another no from me.

several years ago someone had a young puppy loose on the yard where i kept my horse at the time, really really young. it was just scampering around and as my horse and I arrived back onto the yard from a hack it ran round the corner and went under my horse's feet, how on earth it wasn't killed immediately i will never know. I was furious rather than guilty because it was so irresponsible letting a pup that young with no idea of how to keep itself safe to just roam free.

we all know how dangerous horses can be, it's not your responsibility to pay for their error. if it was that close to your horse the dog wasn't under control, was it. :(
 

Upthecreek

Well-Known Member
Joined
9 May 2019
Messages
2,553
Visit site
We get so many dogs at our yard, sometimes there are almost as many dogs there as horses. Some idiots bring their puppies to ‘socialise’ them, which unfortunately usually means letting them run around unsupervised and leaving them to their own devices the minute they arrive at the yard. There have been a few accidents; a Jack Russell puppy got trod on and killed a few years ago. It was so tiny I don’t think the horse even knew it was there. Also a couple dogs have been hit by cars. People still don’t learn. And don’t get me started on the dog sh*t that owners fail to pick up ?

At the end of the day the owner is (or should be) responsible for keeping their pet safe. I definitely don’t think OP should contribute to the vet bill.
 
Top