Yard decisions - thoughts appreciated

tigers_eye

Well-Known Member
Joined
7 February 2006
Messages
6,150
Location
Hoeilaart, Belgium
Visit site
As I'm sure I've gone on enough for most people to be aware I recently moved to Belgium. My two boys are on a friend's yard and in many ways it's very good, however there are a few "buts". I went to look at another today, and will lay out the pro's and con's of each and then any thoughts of yours would be much appreciated. It's in here, not NL or SY, as they are competition horses and this has to be bourne in mind imo. I should add that both places are full livery and there are very few places that will allow anything else.

Where they are now:

14 horses on yard, 5 belong to owner.

Outdoor 60x30 with some jumps, indoor 35x18, surfaces ok but not great.

Hacking is pretty decent, though if we had a really dry summer the ground might be quite hard. Fair bit of road work, boys have had current shoes on 3.5 weeks and there isn't much thickness left!

Shavings beds, well kept but a bit thin.

Hay 3x per day, excellent quality, quantity altered to exactly my requests.

Fed 2x per day, mix provided by owner, quantity as requested.

2 other international eventers based on yard, but tbh haven't even seen them since I've been there.

Turned out every day, my two in own paddock, not much grass atm but hayed whilst there. Come Sept/Oct won't be allowed 4 - 8 week total turnout holiday (will have to come in at night).

Absolute confidence that I could not show up for a week and they would be perfectly well looked after. Things like a lost shoe would be noticed.

Yard is absolutely full now, no signs of anyone leaving soon, so no possibility of buying more horses (to bring on and sell).

Yard is 22 miles away, is costing me approx 15 euros a day in petrol.

Horses cost 300 euros per month per horse.

Total cost atm (petrol and livery) = 1050 euros


Yard I just went to see:

Larger yard, approx 30 horses, "private" livery yard.

One arena, roof covering approx 40 x 25 area, then a further approx 30 x 25 area has no roof. Some jumps. Surface ok, but not great.

About 1.5 mile hack down residential streets I have to cross a busy road and then have unlimited hacking in the forest, loads of designated horse tracks with membranes and sand. Can also hack to old training circular gallops (also in the woods).

Straw beds, appear nice and deep, have been offered two outdoor stables (too small for my liking), or two indoor ones which are much bigger. One horse will have stallions either side of him though, however don't think this will be a problem.

Hay 1x per day. This concerns me. A lot of people here seem to think hay is optional and I don't think it's coincidence that you hear of a lot more colic here than in England. Mine have always had near as dammit ad-lib hay. It is given in the afternoon. If I wanted I could buy additional stuff of my own, however would have to store at home and transport in my car, so small bale haylage the only realistic possibility.

Feed 3x per day. Can either use their general mix, or owner quite happy for me to buy D&H which I've always used for competition horses and for which one of only 2 Belgian suppliers is a mile down the road
smile.gif
. Fed according to my instructions, and if I give him my feed receipts at the end of the month he deducts it from my bill. Could also buy chaff/similar to bulk out feeds with more fibre, and presumabley deduct that from my bill too as it's feed.

Doesn't seem to be any dressage diva's/showjumping pro's on yard, but might be wrong! More people though.

Boys would have their own field for the afternoons, seem quite a good size and even a bit of grass! Not too muddy either which is amazing atm. They also have the biggest field I've ever seen (note to self - never put a horse in there that's bad to catch), which you are only allowed to use if the horse is unshod behind. This would be ideal come their autumn/winter holiday.

A few boxes always free. The owner has to do this as the council keeps tabs on how many horses he has there (on account of the muckheap... England will be like this one day you know
wink.gif
). He said if I was having a few in to sell it would be fine.

Yard is 1 mile away, could cycle, or minimal petrol anyway.

Cost is 460 euros per month per horse. Once a year I have to pay 45 euros per horse to the council (horse tax!). Memebrship (for me) per year is 125 euros.

Total per month: 920 euros, plus haylage, plus 215 euros per year in fees based on two horses.




Sorry that's been an epic comparison! Should perhaps also mention in both cases I have to keep the lorry at home, so from the point of view of early starts on competition days the closer yard is favourable.

Any thoughts hugely appreciated.
 
I'd go with the 2nd option, as long as I could guarantee that hay/haylege was given ad lib. It sounds like you may have to change some mindsets on that one. But that is the only 'con' I can see, against the additional cost of the 1st one and that its a friend you may risk upsetting
grin.gif
 
Wow -Hard decision! They both balance out I guess! If you are wantong to buy and sell a copuple then the second one. Ho hum...this really is a tough choice!!! Which would you feel your horses would be happier at?
 
Definately the closer yard, after a while driving a 44 mile round trip daily will be VERY exhausting!!

Am sure that things could be negotiated regarding more regular hay-ing?

The arenas sound pretty rubbish but if your going away for regular training and have all that forest to hack in, then you wont be needing the arenas all that much?
 
See - you're all showing me I'm not stupid humming and hahhing between the two!

I do really need to earn some sort of money, and buying and selling is my favourite way, which simply isn't possible where I am now. You're quite right a 44 mile round trip isn't a barrel of laughs: not only is it petrol, it's wear and tear, oh and it's over an hour out of my day!

I hadn't realised how much of a fan I'd become of the lovely wax-coated surfaces so many places have in the UK now - they just seem to reflect the natural spring of old turf so well. So now I'm turning my nose up a bit at plain sand and it's tendancy to inconsistencies! The place down the road waters the indoor surface (and outdoor if needed, ie. not atm!) twice a week, and harrows, so would probably try and pick those days to school.
 
Would go for closer yard. For me long term cost financially and in time would get very annoying. If you had a lame/colicking horse for instance that needed checking on it would be a real drag.
I would negotiate on hay even if you kept the bales at home in the garage and just took two haynets in your car with you every day.
 
Personally I would opt for the first yard.

The second appears much more dependant on the person who runs it. As a larger yard I can imagine there are more rules and regulations. She says she is happy for you to bring your on food etc, but will this remain the case forever? I have been in a situation where you have to completely comply with the 'orders' that are given, and these can be very restricting, particularly if you are running competition horses, which, ultimately, require more care and attention. From what you describe, I fear they would fail to recognise this, (unlike at the yard you are currently at.) The situation for me at a yard similar to the second one described detoriated when I asked (very politely) for things to be done SLIGHTLY differently. People can easily hold grudges even if you suggest that they might be able to give them a second haynet during the day!

Also, with 30 boxes and just one school, would you ever manage to get in it without having to share it with 5 other people?!
 
Thing is at the present yard I haven't seen the owner much at all - she's out of the country a lot, and I think I've seen her two or three times in the 4 weeks I've been there. The schools haven't been harrowed or rolled since I've been there.

I know what you mean about flexibility, I think I will ring the owner again of the nearer place and ask if giving a slice of haylage with the morning and evening feed would be acceptable before I go further on that front. One drawback of producing horses to sell from that place is if I have one I can't shift, it will add up pretty quick at that amount per month.
 
The hay issue at the second yard would bother me to be honest. I like mine to have almost ad lib forage. Whilst the big field would be fab for their annual holiday it might not be ideal for when they are in work - thinking weight issues? I think I would be inclined to stay were you are and keep looking
tongue.gif
 
Another who would worry about the hay issue especially after having a colicky horse who needed to eat little and often, as nature intended! Will be very easy for the closer yard to say "yes yes what ever you want" in order to get you there and have a paying customer but do you trust that what you want will actually happen, it is also more expensive per head but guess this balances out with the reduced petrol money.

As things are OK where you are and not unbearable I would stay put and continue the search.
 
If you got the hay thing sorted, then getting the feeling that you prefer the second yard. Lec is right - there has to be a way round that if everything else is right!!
Hope it works out, and if it doesn't that something else comes up soon.

Fiona
 
I think I would go for yard two and buy my own haylage. storage shouldn't be a problem if you keep it in a wheelie bin as it then doesn't smell or blow about or get wet. Perhaps if it was kept in a bin they may throw some in the field for them. You could buy a few bales and keep them at home for now even outside.
Crossing the busy road is worth it for decent hacking, and I'd take the inside boxes saying when something else outside is free you would like to move.
having a stallion will be fine so long as your horses are male, otherwise you could get a few squeals!
The grass is coming but I would imagine with the warmer weather you may get there it won't last for ever, so you might have to feed hay in the summer if the grass dries up a lot.
The second yard sounds a better option if you sort some extra haylage out, I'd move..
wink.gif
 
I would say the second yard as it is so near to home and you've got access to the forest for fitness work. Surely they can't have a problem with you buying your own haylage to give them in the morning? Is small bale haylage expensive there?
 
Don't know re haylage, haven't looked into it. Hay is MUCH cheaper though, everyone I've told so far how much I was paying for a small bale in England has needed resuscitation!

Have decided to go and look at a few more today. There is a new place I've heard is amazing, bit further (prob about 6 -7 miles), and I think they need to fill boxes so will go and have a nose!
 
Top