You have actually got to be joking - Irish SJ

H

Halfstep

Well-Known Member
Joined
4 July 2005
Messages
6,966
Location
Oxfordshire
Visit site
They've only gone and put Cian O'Bloody dope cheat Connor on the team instead of Denis Lynch. You have got to be taking the michael. Please someone say this is a bad joke. Or that HSI has actually gone clinically insane :confused::confused::confused::eek::eek::eek::mad::(
 
A

amage

Well-Known Member
Joined
19 December 2004
Messages
3,888
Visit site
Halfstep said:
They've only gone and put Cian O'Bloody dope cheat Connor on the team instead of Denis Lynch. You have got to be taking the michael. Please someone say this is a bad joke. Or that HSI has actually gone clinically insane :confused::confused::confused::eek::eek::eek::mad::(
Click to expand...

Could be considered insane...though in fairness he has maintained a clean slate since '04 jumping numerous horses at top level. From a publicity perspective it would have been far better to send Shane Sweetnam...he might have slightly less chance of a medal but he does have a clean record.
 
L

LegOn

Well-Known Member
Joined
14 September 2010
Messages
766
Visit site
In fairness their reasons for removing Lynch seem valid, see statement from HSI:

Horse Sport Ireland chief Damian McDonald has explained exactly why the decision was taken to replace Denis Lynch in the Irish Olympic team.

Lynch was replaced by Cian O’Connor in the Irish show jumping team after a meeting of the disqualification of his mount Lantinus during the Nations Cup event at Aachen last week.

“Unfortunately Denis Lynch’s horse Lantinus was disqualified in Aachen last Friday. His horse was found to be hypersensitive,” McDonald said on RTÉ’s Sport At 7.

“Hypersensitivity can be naturally occurring and there was no finding of wrong doing against Denis Lynch out of that.

“Unfortunately two other horses ridden by Denis in the past twelve months have tested positive for hypersensitivity and that meant this was the third incidence of hypersensitivity. He was disqualified from the Olympics in Beijing in 2008 so obviously that caused us a great deal of concern.

“We have a procedure which is set out in our selection criteria under article 2.8 to deal with matters like this, that was sent to the riders back in 1 March.

“We made it very clear that if we had any concerns about riders that we could require them to appear in front of the monitoring committee and that the monitoring committee could deal them ineligible for selection if their concerns weren’t satisfied.

“On Monday Denis attending a meeting of the monitoring committee in Dublin and after hearing (his) explanation and commitments and so on, the committee decided that its concerns hadn’t been satisfied and we had to take the decision to withdraw Denis’ nomination from the Olympic Council.”

When asked why Lynch’s explanations at the meeting had not satisfied the committee, McDonald pointed to those similar past occurrences of hypersensitivity and concerns that his horse could be disqualified in London.

“I think the reality of the situation is that horses ridden by Denis have been disqualified three times in the past twelve months. If it so happened that Denis’ horse that he was bringing to the games was found to be hypersensitive, even if there was no wrong doing, the horse would be disqualified.

“Our sport can’t afford to have anyone disqualified at the Olympic Games again.

“This is not about what happened in Aachen, it’s about concerns we have arising out of the fact that this has happened to a horse ridden by Denis three times in the last twelve months,” McDonald stressed.
Click to expand...

And as amage says, Cian has kept his record clean for the last 4 years & got himself the points to be selected so why shouldnt he picked to replace him.

It would have been nice to see Shane go, but they are hedging their bets by putting Cian forward in the hope of a medal.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top