I think they probably would. I have my other long boots so would use them over the Bromonts, however on a cold winters morning I think I'd be easily swayed to use them!!
They are very comfy too - didn't need any breaking in at all.
i dont know about those ariats in particular but i have 2 other pairs of ariats and love them. so comfortable if you're teaching/on the yard/walking xc courses all day...
heard really good reports about them tho! am very tempted....