Collegiate saddles vs HDR saddle vs Thornhill saddle? Opinions?

[ogriffith21534]

I am trying to find a jumping saddle for my horse and I found saddles from HDR and Collegiate that I particularly liked, but I'm not sure which one's better.

The HDR saddle that I was looking at was the 'HDR Advantage All Purpose Saddle'. I know it's not a jumping saddle, but it is in really good condition and has stirrups so I thought I might consider it.

I was also looking at the 'Collegiate Zeta Jumping Saddle' and what's your opinion on that saddle? it looks really nice to me :--)
[h=1][/h]The last saddle I was looking at was the 'Thornhill ProAm Jumper Saddle' .

So, what are your thoughts? any opinions good or bad will be appreciated

 

[Mince Pie]

No experience with that particular saddle but I have a Collegiate and it's very comfy - also has the advantage of an adjustable gullet so when pony gets a bit plump in the summer I don't have to change his saddle!