i have the stud girth and love it
machine washable so can always be kept clean, soft, lightweight, fits well, and the hexagonal pads on the stud bit are cushioning and absorbing
I also love their stud girth. The only niggle I have is that the actual stud guard bit is easily marked so it can look grubby even though you've washed it! But excellent girth.
Yep the stud girths are great. So easy to keep clean and fit really neatly without "gaping" like some of the leather ones do!! Currently saving up for new short one to go on his saddle, have a long girth one to get rid of first!!!