evil instructors!! (a bit of a long one!)

kcgibson

Well-Known Member
Joined
14 January 2007
Messages
260
Location
East Yorks
Visit site
when sending a reply to another post, it led me on to think about this.....
.... when we got my horse 8 1/2 years ago (i was only 14), my sister wanted to take him for jumping lessons. We went to an instructor (so wish i could name and shame here!!) once week. week one went ok except when my horse shied and my sister fell off and the instructor thought it appropriate to stab him in the ribs with his own stirrups - she was 'teaching him a lesson' she said. This upset me but at 14 years old i did not feel i could stand up to an imposing instructor (and i feel so bad in retrospect). A couple of weeks passed without too many problems, other than asking my sister and horse to do things above their capabilities and then getting mad cos they couldnt cope. week 4 was much worse, my horse had loads of energy so the instructor suggested lunging him first. well she made him go round and round and round. he was so frightened he dared not stop until he was sweated up. the instructor commented 'ooh he has more energy than my top showjumpers' (i came to realise that adrenaline goes a long way for a horse). Then the instructor asked if one of her stable girls could get on him, we allowed it as my sister was worried about getting on. Well this girl booted the life out of him whilst at the same time pulled so hard on his bit im surprised she didnt rip it from his mouth. At this point i burst into tears and it was only then that the instructor stopped. If she treated all her horse like this im not surprised they were all so perfect, they would not dare put a foot wrong. We never took our horse back there ever again. I still feel so bad that i did not stand up to that woman but now when i think back i wonder how people can be so cruel? Horses are so gentle (most of the time!) and their behaviour is only learnt from the people around them. Dont get me wrong, my horse was no angel but he did not deserve the treatment he got. To add to this, we had his back/teeth/tack checked and were told everything ok. It was only when we got another equine dentist a few months later we realised the problem - his back teeth had never been rasped!!! (he was around 71/2 years old). the previous dentist hadnt done a proper job and this new EDT spent over an hour just on my horse cos the hooks on his back teeth were so bad and they had caused painful sores in his cheeks. Again, i felt so bad but i thought we had done the right thing 6 months previously with the other dentist. Just wanted to share my story and ask if any one else had suffered from an awful instructor (or dentist!).
I'd like to say i am more knowledgable now and more old and wise and would never ever let any one treat my horse in that way.
 
Not instructor and dentisit - but similar from a YO and saddle fitter.
I had a saddle fitter out to my horse not long after I bought her and had a saddle supposedly professionally fitted and from then on it was a downward spiral of bad behaviour from my horse. It couldn't be the saddle though could it as it had been fitted by a professional! YO repeatedly told me my horses behaviour was because she was naughty/evil/needed bottoming/was playing a game with me that she really enjoyed winning(!) and that basically I was too much of a wimp to give her a good telling off. She tried "bottoming" her on the lunge too and she was no different behaviour wise afterwards - just tired and tense instead of just tense.
Anyway after finding a lovely new sympathetic instructor we've never looked back - although she pointed out on our first session that all my horses behaviour was because the "professionally" fitted saddle didn't fit at all. I had a different saddler out who fitted my WOW that I have now and she's been a different horse since. I knew all the way through there was a reason for my horses behaviour and that she wasn't evil/naughty etc. She even had her back x-rayed and steroids injected into her back at one point. It just goes to show you have to trust your instincts and try not to be swayed by those who might seem to be more experienced than you.
 
I had one like that recently, before i changed to a lovely lady called chris. But the first instructor used to hit him, boot him (with spurs) and wind him up so much he was sooo tense and sweating buckets, one of the liveries was watching the so called lesson and we both agreed that she was not the right person to be spending time with my horse. So along came chris and her empathy with both horse and rider was amazing- we ended up coming sencond in our affiliated test, with no comments on tenseness as we had got when i was being taught by other instructer. Its amazing what a differnce an instructor came make!
 
yeah you def have to go on your own instincts, i learnt that. But its as ann-jen said, its easy to be swayed by someone who is more experienced than yourself, although now i feel that i know my horse better than anyone and im the best person to judge him. my friend also sent her difficult horse for schooling (different instructor to the one i had). The horse would always return to my friend with marks on her and the horse would be really tense. So my friend decided to make a surprise visit one day to find her horse being thrashed (and i do mean thrashed). She took her horse home there and then and never returned. I just dont know how some people can be so cruel.
 
Top