For your info - buyer beware article

I have a question for you ilostmymarbles. Have you ever or did you ever actually see any of the horses advertised by 'bombproof' or 'lazyplods'? I did. In fact their website along with a few other horse selling websites were saved in my favourites section and bookmarked for reference. They were one of the websites that I would visit, sometimes on a daily basis both before I got my horses and afterwards too. So in effect I was studying them for quite a long time.
To someone who was perhaps a tad gullible or even an every day person they seemed good horse dealers. Their website was jazzy. All the horses looked in good condition that had pictures listed. All of the ones I can remember were wearing tack and showed photographs of them being ridden or else having someone on their back as the picture was taken. In a sense they appeared just as the companies namesake 'bombproof'. Ages were given or approximate ages, along with height, breeding, sex etc. I never spotted any illnesses or faults listed but judging by the pictures I saw none of them looked ill, scrawny or very obese.
If I didn't check the website for a week in most cases there would be a sold across the name of a horse which had only been listed the previous week. I think the message was that the website was updated daily or words to that affect.
Now to a complete novice horse buyer how would you perceive a horse dealer like that?
Horses looking well. Being ridden. Not showing any particular clear faults. A high turnover of horses.
I don't know about anyone else but if I were a novice I would most likely think rather than it all being too good to be true that these were clearly clever people. They must have a large base. A high number of staff to help train the seemingly large number of horses and most importantly must be very popular with Joe Public because some horses were being sold within days of being listed on their site.
Why would an average person think any different?
They offered a money back guarantee. You could buy tack from them direct so you would assume you would receive help in finding the right tack to fit the horse seeing as they had done work with them to help make them 'bombproof' and 'safeplods' and so must have had the correct tack as ill fitting tack in most cases would not make a horse happy and in some cases cause injury or pain.
I am not defending the couple totally as I do think they were a bit too naive to be buying a horse in those circumstances, but yes we are ALL capable of making mistakes in some point of our lives. No one is perfect.
However what I am saying is that this dealer came across in a positive manner and as such could inspire customers to flock to their gates so to speak. Certainly if the number of sold notices were all accurate then you would think that the couple in question were not the only ones convinced by their advertising techniques.
Most of the horses were sold pictured but there was more than one occasion when they seemingly had a clear out of reduced priced horses that were described as 'straight from the field'.
I would not have thought for one moment that Samson was sold in this category as I do seem to remember the name as I paid a little more attention to the taller stockier types as I was looking for a weight carrier.
Anyway whatever has been done cannot be undone.
I do feel very sorry for Samson and I do still think that the couple were done a very big injustice by the dealers judging by the story I have read. He should never have been sold like that with COPD. It is a fairly easy condition to spot in a horse and as most of their horses were clearly sold with riding in mind ( never saw any listed as companion, light hack from memory) then they were clearly out of order, imo. COPD unless treated does affect a horse significantly. I know of 3 horses personally who suffer with it to varying degrees but all have riding limitations as result. I cannot accept for one minute that these dealers did not know there was something seriously wrong with the horse. He should have been treated for it there and then at the dealers. He should have been sold with the condition listed in the description. I am guessing that it was omitted for pricing reasons seeing as the average price listed for the ones I saw was in the region of £4,000. I cannot imagine for one minute that a large horse, in his late teens with diagnosed COPD would be worth even half that amount which is why I don't think his condition was even mentioned.
I am sorry but that is so very wrong imo.
I am glad to hear that the horse has a final caring home in which to live out his days though and that the other horse the couple had is safe and secure too.
 
Yes taking more care would have been advisable - totally agree - but would still argue they were dealing with sellers deliberately out to mislead and who did knowingly mislead - but not right now.

Off to go and see to my horses now and not so close to the computer tomorrow - thank you to everyone who has taken part - very interesting and informative.

Emma
 
Sorry Staffs_oatcake did not realize you have posed in between.

Thank you for going to such trouble with your posts. It will mean a lot to novice buyers that not every one (who knows better) condemns them and can see how they can be misled.
Emma
 
No problems Emma x To be honest I would have considered buying from the same dealers as the couple who were duped. The only reasons that I didn't was the high prices I thought they were charging for the horses and the distance from me as I would have gone to visit for a look at them especially if I was parting with a few thousand. I did really like the look of a few of their horses which was the main reason I kept checking. I hoped they would drop the prices a bit but they never seemed to do so unless by a very small amount. Also most of the better looking ones were not listed for long before they had a big ( bright pink I think it was) sold sign across them. If I remember correctly I think once this happened you could not access all details of the horse in question either.
I am not a novice rider but when I got mine two years ago they were my first so I was a novice owner. We got the cob from a sale but a reputable one and also one which offered a vetting service for a relatively small amount too ( think it was £65 from memory) with the option of continuing the vetting to the next level with your own vet when you got home. I liked this idea because it gave me piece of mind. If he had failed the vetting it would have been up to me whether to go ahead with the purchase and if I had had him vetted at home and something untoward had shown up I had rights as a buyer from the sales and as such was afforded some protection.
I much preferred to buy a horse in this way than to buy privately and place my total trust in the seller. Also I liked the idea that there was a vet already present at the sales so you didn't have to prearrange and arranging transport home was easy too. These are all things that need to be considered when buying a horse unless the horse comes with an in date vetting certificate or you had your own transport. But in fairness most horses with a 5 stage certificate would not be cheap and I couldn't imagine someone spending really big money on their first horse if they were not 'horsey' people and those already with transport are unlikely to be novice owners anyway.
Caz
 
Basically from reading everything on here about ignorant people buying horses off crooks I think that a licence to own a horse is really becoming necessary. In most European countries (correct me if I am wrong) you need to complete a test to prove that you are a competant rider. Therefore you get a standard set from the start. Although this only applies if you compete. I think the licence should cover the issues of buying horses, basic care and road craft.
 
I have been on the website, i had a look when the first few cases came up.
Yes they were jazzy looking websites with reasonable looking horses, but as most reasonable people know that the internet is almost entirly unregulated so a fancy website means nothing. The bombproof site has been notorious for a while, had they checked in forums like this one they would have been told that. The person who ran it, whose name was on the website had previously been on watchdog and convicted for fraud! I still dont think that this absolves people of responsibility for thier own mistakes!
Whether or not there was a guarantee,To anyone with any common sense buying anything off a website unseen is a huge risk, but to buy a live animal, especially for someone who has specially needs like the man on the website, to ride, which is a very dangerous sport, completely untried, and to spend such a enormous amount of money without checking what your actually purchasing or doing any research on the subject is foolish and people should to face the consequences of thier mistakes rather then trying to pass the buck to others.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Sorry but the same naive ill informed buyer who buys his horse unseen could well be the one who goes on to bath it in cold water after a days hunting, or feed it concentrates and wonder why its mad, or leave it in a field full of ragwort.
Ignorance is not a good enough excuse.
SORRY!

[/ QUOTE ]

That is just the point I was trying to make. I pity any horse purchased by a novice unseen from an internet site.
 
No - I feel sorry for you if you have a chip on your shoulder.

Your pony clearly landed on it's feet and has a good home.

A lot aren't so lucky.
 
Because you feel the need to draw attention to yourself and your horse.

This thread is about horse welfare, horse sales, and muppets that buy horse's without learning anything about them or taking advice from qualified people. If your horse has a good home then your not one of those I am refering to. DUH!
 
Oh I see. I am very sorry that I have upset you. I wasn't trying to seek yours or anyone else's attention, I was just trying to put across the novice's point of view. Please be assured that I do take horse welfare very seriously indeed and I make regular monthly payments to the ILPH.

The thing is though I didn't take a qualified person's advice before deciding to buy my pony and I am a novice so I definitely do fall into the category that you call "muppets". I just wanted to highlight the other side of the story i.e. that novices could buy horses sight unseen from the internet without it necessarily ending in disaster for either themselves or the horse. I do hope that you can understand what I am trying to say? I feel that everyone has to start somewhere you see. Thank you for saying that you think my pony has a good home
grin.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
Oh I see. I am very sorry that I have upset you. I wasn't trying to seek yours or anyone else's attention, I was just trying to put across the novice's point of view. Please be assured that I do take horse welfare very seriously indeed and I make regular monthly payments to the ILPH.

The thing is though I didn't take a qualified person's advice before deciding to buy my pony and I am a novice so I definitely do fall into the category that you call "muppets". I just wanted to highlight the other side of the story i.e. that novices could buy horses sight unseen from the internet without it necessarily ending in disaster for either themselves or the horse. I do hope that you can understand what I am trying to say? I feel that everyone has to start somewhere you see. Thank you for saying that you think my pony has a good home
grin.gif


[/ QUOTE ]

Well said x For what it's worth I took both my horses on as well without seeking advice from 'qualified' people too. Although in fairness even the so called experts can get it wrong from time to time. I just did plenty of research, homework, calling up and emailing friends and so on for advice so I knew exactly what I was letting myself in for.
Heh and guess what ( not aimed at you btw) after over 25 years of being with horses I am still learning all about them even now, strange that. Do I have a chip then too? You bet I do but mine ain't on my shoulder it's in my nose where I tripped and fell onto a brick wall one day. I guess you could say Duh to that too lol.
Caz
 
Yes everyone has to start somewhere, but that doesnt mean that you shouldnt ask people who know more that you!!!
The horses welfare is far more important then the fact that you want people to not bother taking others advice!!
Just because your horse has landed on its feet and you've done reasonably well doesnt mean anyhting. Most novices are likely to make the sort of stupid mistakes that can endanger horses because thier too proud to ask for help.
Staffoatcakes. You've just defeated your own arguement by saying you asked more experienced people for advice before buying and yet arguing that 'experts' need not be consulted. The word 'expert' can have different meaning but the main one is a person wiht 'experience' in a particular area.
A novice who will put thier pride above any horses welfare, ought not have one.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Oh I see. I am very sorry that I have upset you. I wasn't trying to seek yours or anyone else's attention, I was just trying to put across the novice's point of view. Please be assured that I do take horse welfare very seriously indeed and I make regular monthly payments to the ILPH.

The thing is though I didn't take a qualified person's advice before deciding to buy my pony and I am a novice so I definitely do fall into the category that you call "muppets". I just wanted to highlight the other side of the story i.e. that novices could buy horses sight unseen from the internet without it necessarily ending in disaster for either themselves or the horse. I do hope that you can understand what I am trying to say? I feel that everyone has to start somewhere you see. Thank you for saying that you think my pony has a good home
grin.gif


[/ QUOTE ]

Sure, sorry if my comment was harsh, I don't have a problem with novices buying horse's - I sold a just broken cob to a complete novice and that could be considered irresponsable. But in this case the lady and her daughter wanted to keep it at working livery at a friends riding school (the YO had had my boy for schooling and had a lot of faith in him) The girl who the pony was for has regular lessons on him and now about 5 years later has a fab show cob that is worth much more than the £1200 her mother paid for him. The horse in question has had much more time and schooling that I could have given him so it worked out well for all.

The ones I don't like is those that can't even be bothered to pick up a book or do anything to learn at all. Like the berk that came to look at a pony of mine and wanted to keep it in a garage with the car?????
 
ilostmymarbles - when did I say that I wanted people not to bother taking the advice of others? If you read my thread in New Lounge you will see that this is the exact opposite of what I am saying so I think you have got a bit muddled up there!

Also, how do you know that I have done "reasonably well". How do you know I haven't done "appallingly" or "extremely well"? If you are a law student surely you must know that you have to back up your wild assertions with some evidence otherwise you could end up looking foolish?

Finally, where are all these "proud novices" of whom you speak? I haven't met any. I think you are letting your imagination run away with you a little. All the novices I've ever known (myself included) are eager to learn and willingly ask advice from others.

I don't think for one second that Staffsoatcake is putting her "pride" above her horses welfare. Quite the opposite from what I understand.
 
Shannagolden - keeping a pony in a garage with a car is a dreadful idea. Are you sure they were serious? I think the term numpty could actually apply there!

My pony is the 4th horse which I've bought and I keep her at full livery just as I did the other three. I have a weekly lesson and have had for about 6 years now and I studied for my BHS Stage 1 and am intending to study further this Autumn. I still consider myself a novice though because I have so much still to learn.
 
In that case you'r better qualified than me. We all have stuff to learn and mistakes to make, I wouldn't really class you as a novice though.

The 'pony in the garage' woman was for real. She was happy to pay big money for the horse but complained when told how much the wormer's and shoes cost!!!!
 
Shannon the impression you give from your post is that since you did alright with buying your horse as a novice without getting advice then other novices need not get advice before buying! Staff oatcakes' seems to sneer at the idea of even thinking of getting 'expert advice' thats where i got proud from. The post wasnt entirely directed at you.
I got 'reasonably well' from other posts you ahve made and by simply looking at the photos of your horse/poney that you have posted. The seemed to be in good health and well cared for. if you had done 'extemely poorly' i would expect the photos to be of too thin or too fat ponies and you to have posted threads wondering why your horse was ill/doing poorly. If you were doing 'extremely well' i'd have expected posts talking of qualifications for big competitions/ trainig going especially well/huge progress on a fault being made. All in all your post imply an average 'reasonably well'
 
[ QUOTE ]
Shannon the impression you give from your post is that since you did alright with buying your horse as a novice without getting advice then other novices need not get advice before buying! Staff oatcakes' seems to sneer at the idea of even thinking of getting 'expert advice' thats where i got proud from. The post wasnt entirely directed at you.
I got 'reasonably well' from other posts you ahve made and by simply looking at the photos of your horse/poney that you have posted. The seemed to be in good health and well cared for. if you had done 'extemely poorly' i would expect the photos to be of too thin or too fat ponies and you to have posted threads wondering why your horse was ill/doing poorly. If you were doing 'extremely well' i'd have expected posts talking of qualifications for big competitions/ trainig going especially well/huge progress on a fault being made. All in all your post imply an average 'reasonably well'

[/ QUOTE ]

EH? read my posts again
laugh.gif
 
ilostmymarbles - Re above I think your getting your self confused…..

In a previous post you said "Most novices are likely to make the sort of stupid mistakes that can endanger horses because their too proud to ask for help." - how many novices have you met or know, too proud to ask for help? How did you know they were too proud?


Hi FinellaGlen, thank you for posting on this thread even after seeing the friendly warm welcome for novices.

The garage scenario is not uncommon. Go to some tenements and you will find ponies in flats and garages. May equines live on rubbish dumps and back gardens all around the UK. That said it could be argued when you see some livery or dealer yards they may be better off. It is amazing how many horses, ponies and donkeys don’t even have access to clean air in this country.
Emma
 
I think ilostmymarbles is confused yet again and she thinks that you are me! As a law student I hope that she gets the names of her clients right if she goes into court or the judge won't be too impressed
grin.gif
 
I apologise shanna i did get you and finella mixed up. I was in a hurry and didnt look at the names properly. That post was aimed at her not you.

Voices for horses. I am suprised you've never run accross a 'proud novice' i've run accross hundreds of them. People who buy ill/injured horses without advice then try to blame others for thier foolishness. Poeple who completely overhorse themselves, refuse to take advice and end up wrecking a good horse by making it headshy or ruining its schooling or giving a hard mouth or making it ring shy. People who had 'vicious' horses put down because the horse has fought back after being clouted on the head one to many times. People who have run good riding schools into the ground by suing for things that were there own fault. Maybe theres just a glut of them where i live.

Finella nad JM07 i consider those personal attacks and if similar things happen again i'll report it to the moderators.
 
[ QUOTE ]
I apologise shanna i did get you and finella mixed up. I was in a hurry and didnt look at the names properly. That post was aimed at her not you.

Voices for horses. I am suprised you've never run accross a 'proud novice' i've run accross hundreds of them. People who buy ill/injured horses without advice then try to blame others for thier foolishness. Poeple who completely overhorse themselves, refuse to take advice and end up wrecking a good horse by making it headshy or ruining its schooling or giving a hard mouth or making it ring shy. People who had 'vicious' horses put down because the horse has fought back after being clouted on the head one to many times. People who have run good riding schools into the ground by suing for things that were there own fault. Maybe theres just a glut of them where i live.

Finella nad JM07 i consider those personal attacks and if similar things happen again i'll report it to the moderators.

[/ QUOTE ]

I did not say I had not met any proud novices! That aside you are not just describing novices here, these are problems across the board, the industry and equestrian world.
Emma
 
it is true to say that i bel you should never ( unless can afford to lose money) buy a horse unseen, i for one have never done it, nor would i recommend it, but if you are truely experienced and want to take the risk then you might get away with it!! I would consider it madness for a novice to do the same!! but and my point to this thread is that if a horse is standing or waiting for auction they should at very least have access to clean drinking water,,, this i feel is the responsibility of both the seller and the auction house,,, am sure horses tied to lorries all day at shows wouldnt be left for any length of time at a show without being offered water!!!!!!
 
[ QUOTE ]


Finella nad JM07 i consider those personal attacks and if similar things happen again i'll report it to the moderators.

[/ QUOTE ]

PMSL......
GO ON THEN...

and while you're at it..just make sure your spellcheck is working....
wink.gif
 
'Finella nad JM07 i consider those personal attacks and if similar things happen again i'll report it to the moderators.'
To be honest ilostmymarbles I could say the very same about you as you did seem to suggest that I may be too proud for my horses. What total poppycock. How the hell would you know anything about my pride? Look dear I lost my pride a few years ago when left penniless and begging for income support after my husband and I split up. So please don't make assumptions about my level of pride.
My earlier post was about asking for help. I was a novice owner in so much as I had never been involved in the care of a horse 24/7 before I got mine. Like someone said earlier we all have to start somewhere. Yes I agree there are numpties that don't take advice on board or even ask for it in the first place and sometimes putting the health and welfare of their horses at risk because of it. But there are also people who are so called experts who get it wrong from time to time, like vets for instance. That was what I meant by my earlier post, that some of these experts who are asked to help can sometimes get it wrong themselves so making mistakes is not just attributable to novices.
Hell knows I have made mistakes. Some have even been publicised on here and yes I hold my hands up and say that sometimes I had been wrong. However I have learned to move on. I have taken sound advice that was given on board and as such increased my knowledge and handling skills. But please don't tar every novice owner with the same brush or miscontrue what has been written on here.
As a law student I should hope that you have some familiarity with the law with one aspect of it being defamation which is applicable on a publicised public forum like this.
I would suggest that you take a long hard look at your own posts and try and work out if anything you have said could be seen as an attack on someone's personal character.
 
ilostmymarbles - as JM07 says, go ahead, report me too. I haven't done anything so it won't get you very far. Re-read what I have written and what you have written. I haven't made any personal attacks but you have. So far you have stated twice that I am advocating that novice owners refrain from asking advice when buying a horse when in fact I have strongly urged just the opposite. You have called me "average" which, to be fair, made me giggle because I feel quite proud to be average. I always thought I was some way below average you see!

Latterly, you've begun to use language more associated with warfare as you tell Shannagolden that you are "aiming" [posts] at me and then end by saying that I am "attacking" you. Please think about what you are saying.
 
Top