Have you ever had a dog you didn’t like?

blackcob

🖖
Joined
20 March 2007
Messages
12,389
Location
Shropshire
Visit site
Has anyone got a dog as an adult and honestly felt the same way about them as their dogs from pups?

Both of my first two, absolutely. If anything I have the most complicated relationship with the latest puppy at the moment - bit as Jenko said, I think - big shoes to fill and an unfair weight of expectation from me because of it. It's not that I don't like her, far from it, but I think greater strides will be made when we can start properly doing stuff.
 

marmalade76

Well-Known Member
Joined
24 April 2009
Messages
6,909
Location
Gloucestershire
Visit site
Interesting responses. I always felt guilty and not having liked her at first.
I can still say we never had that, or maybe she never had that complete adoration that I’ve had with previous dogs, maybe mostly Dougal my last dog.
I think it’s because she was adult aswell as not being my choice of dog. 🤷‍♀️
It would in reality put me off getting another adult, which is sad and why the pick a dog thread made me think of this.
maybe I’m wrong there.
Has anyone got a dog as an adult and honestly felt the same way about them as their dogs from pups?

As an adult I've only had adult dogs. Had puppies as a kid and plenty of my relatives have dogs from puppies and I just couldn't face the toilet training and chewing.
 

some show

Well-Known Member
Joined
5 September 2018
Messages
429
Visit site
I'm on my first ever dog and got him when he was 3, and I love him so much I worry that dog number two in the future won't live up to him! Took a while to warm up to each other as he was very aloof and difficult (reactive/wild prey drive/stubborn) at first but we got there.
 

windswoo

Well-Known Member
Joined
19 August 2021
Messages
782
Visit site
I didn't like our two for quite a few years after we had them, our previous dog had died 8 months earlier and I just wasn't ready for another dog. However OH had other ideas and decide to get two rescues, but deliberately picked wo dogs that looked nothing like our old dog.
I absolutely adored our previous dog and just didn't want them. The big problem was for the first two years they were an absolute nightmare - would bark constantly so P***ed off the new neighbours (we'd just moved house before older dog had died), the one dog was terrified of OH, so I had to train her which didn't go down well and they were just so high maintenance. It got to a stage where I threatened to leave if they didn't go, as I just couldn't cope with the stress from the neighbours. We tried everything and OH didn't want to send them back as he didn't want to feel that he'd failed them. I didn't end up leaving and we have a better relationship with the neighbours now, but I still always say they are his dogs if they misbehave. I love the one, but the other I like at a push, but then she's not bothered about me either. I've said that after these two I don't want any more dogs and this time I mean it.
 

Identityincrisis

Well-Known Member
Joined
10 November 2011
Messages
1,653
Visit site
Interesting responses. I always felt guilty and not having liked her at first.
I can still say we never had that, or maybe she never had that complete adoration that I’ve had with previous dogs, maybe mostly Dougal my last dog.
I think it’s because she was adult aswell as not being my choice of dog. 🤷‍♀️
It would in reality put me off getting another adult, which is sad and why the pick a dog thread made me think of this.
maybe I’m wrong there.
Has anyone got a dog as an adult and honestly felt the same way about them as their dogs from pups?

Me, i got my boy at 7-8 years old, I’ve had him 4 years and would (and do) move heaven and earth for him.

I didn’t want a dog when my partner decided to get one for his teenage son (🙄) and refused to look after it (🙄) as I didn’t have time, I’m sure everyone can guess how that ended! Anyway, he was very reactive, nervous Lurcher, the breed had never appealed to me but his big brown, soulful eyes just spoke to me and all he needed was love and security. We bonded immediately, i was his human and his voice from day one.

I decided to move out after a year and the only thing that concerned me was making sure I took him with me. I can’t love anything more than I love him and I have changed so much of my life to accommodate him, the big bag of spaghetti!
 

silv

Well-Known Member
Joined
10 April 2002
Messages
2,526
Location
new zealand
Visit site
My last foster dog I didn't really take to and would never have contemplated keeping, unlike all the rest. She was a labx which are normally adorable but she wasn't interested in me at all and had the very annoying habit of when she wanted attention pawing at me. She was very self contained and had selective hearing. I was pleased when she found a permanent home, I have never wanted updates which is unusual for me.
 

sarah.oxford

Well-Known Member
Joined
29 November 2011
Messages
271
Location
Oxfordshire
Visit site
I had a dog that was advertised on gumtree. The right breed for me but nothing else fitted. I realised very quickly it wouldn't work, had him neutered and got a rescue to offer lifetime back up.
I advertised him and the new owner paid for the neutering and travelled 150 miles to come and meet him. We have stayed in touch via FB and he fitted into the home perfectly. 2 years on, he's happy and I have since got my perfect dog, same breed but a very different brain.
 

Christmascinnamoncookie

Fais pas chier!
Joined
6 July 2010
Messages
36,406
Visit site
Jack came to live with us after his owners decided to move in to sheltered accommodation and couldn’t take him. I’d walked him for three years so knew him well. I was very fond of him (and Daisy adored him) so offering to rehome him was a no brainier.

He was very opinionated, could be aggressive (bit me and my niece) and was generally quite grumpy, and I spent the first six months of owning him sort of regretting having him. I was quite strict with him (he’d create all holy hell if you told him to get off a chair etc), and I do regret that. I also regret not appreciating how hard the move was for him ( despite him knowing us both very well). He adored my OH and tolerated me. He would make the most adorable cooing when being cuddled by my OH.

I only realised that I really loved him when he became ill. And the afternoon he crawled on to my lap for some love broke my heart.

We gave him a wonderful 18 months, but I wish I’d done some things differently. And next time I’ll try to be a more understanding person (we may be rehoming another 🙄).
That last bit sounds interesting. Any details?
 

druid

Well-Known Member
Joined
6 December 2004
Messages
7,635
Visit site
Just to update on the one I don't like he's been sold to a home I know well and will be a great fit for him, as a pet gundog rather than him trying to fit into a square hole as a round peg being a trialling dog. Good job all round.
 

Chucho

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 February 2023
Messages
154
Visit site
We rescued a father (5 years old) and daughter (2 years old) pair. Dad (the late great Chucho) was an angel from heaven. His daughter, B, an absolute nightmare in so many ways I can't begin to list them out. Incredibly intelligent and subverted every attempt at training her, fiercely independent, hugely reactive to other dogs due to fear, no off button, and a total gobshite :) . She drove me up the wall in the way no other sentient being had before or has since. I didn't hold her lead for 2 years because I simply couldn't manage her and, to be honest, was too mortified by her behaviour!

Fast forward a few more years and she became my dog of a lifetime. We climbed mountains and crossed oceans together... somewhere in the middle of it all we learned to compromise with each other. I'd have walked through fire for her and I know she'd have done the same for me. We were so in tune we could sense each others thoughts and intentions. She changed the way I think about so many things. The hardest thing when she passed away last year was that for the first time in 8 years there was no one there to lick away my tears. There still isn't and I still miss her every day.

We have had puppies since this pair and I can honestly say that whether we've rehomed an adult or taken in a pup it has always taken time to build a relationship with them but in the end the depth of those relationships have been the same. But maybe we've been lucky. It definitely didn't feel like it with B for a long time though!

This is her (right) with her pa (left) doing what they did best... be crazy!
 

Attachments

  • DSC_4557 - Copy.jpg
    DSC_4557 - Copy.jpg
    155.4 KB · Views: 16

windswoo

Well-Known Member
Joined
19 August 2021
Messages
782
Visit site
We rescued a father (5 years old) and daughter (2 years old) pair. Dad (the late great Chucho) was an angel from heaven. His daughter, B, an absolute nightmare in so many ways I can't begin to list them out. Incredibly intelligent and subverted every attempt at training her, fiercely independent, hugely reactive to other dogs due to fear, no off button, and a total gobshite :) . She drove me up the wall in the way no other sentient being had before or has since. I didn't hold her lead for 2 years because I simply couldn't manage her and, to be honest, was too mortified by her behaviour!

Fast forward a few more years and she became my dog of a lifetime. We climbed mountains and crossed oceans together... somewhere in the middle of it all we learned to compromise with each other. I'd have walked through fire for her and I know she'd have done the same for me. We were so in tune we could sense each others thoughts and intentions. She changed the way I think about so many things. The hardest thing when she passed away last year was that for the first time in 8 years there was no one there to lick away my tears. There still isn't and I still miss her every day.

We have had puppies since this pair and I can honestly say that whether we've rehomed an adult or taken in a pup it has always taken time to build a relationship with them but in the end the depth of those relationships have been the same. But maybe we've been lucky. It definitely didn't feel like it with B for a long time though!

This is her (right) with her pa (left) doing what they did best... be crazy!
I love boxers - they can just be so mental but in a really good way. I've only met one who wasn't friendly and he was huge!!
I'll probably be the same when the blond one goes - I'll miss her terribly even if she is a pain in the butt ;)
 

malwhit

Well-Known Member
Joined
17 September 2022
Messages
152
Visit site
I got an adult Mini Schnauzer exactly a year after the death of old Mini Schnauzer. At first I liked that she acted a lot like the old one. But it then started to annoy me, especially as she was a barker unlike Daisy had been.

I tolerated her as my Mini Schnauzer male liked her. I probably was nicer and gave more treats to her because I felt guilty for not liking her😁
When my male died 6 years later, I started to feel sorry for her, and grew to like her more, and after she died even missed her😁
 
Top