Help! My pony is never going to sell!

Starzaan

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 January 2010
Messages
4,084
Visit site
Long one...sorry everyone, but I desperately need some advice!

So...
last summer, my brother's wife called and asked me to start searching for a pony for their girls, aged 7 and 5. They live in Holland, and my sister in law isn't experienced enough to make a decision by herself (and bombproof kids ponies are like hen's teeth over there!). There followed a constant barrage of emails with suggestions of horses for me to go and look at, but when I asked if she was comfortable with me choosing something for them without her seeing it she said no, consequently they missed out on a hell of a lot of nice ponies! They came over for a weekend to stay with us and look at horses that I was supposed to have lined up, but as I'm sure all of you know, perfect kids ponies don't stay on the market for long, so I had nothing when they came over. I called the owner of a local riding school who I know very well, and asked if she had anything for the girls to which she said she had a few possibilities, but we'd have to go straight over and have a look!

When we got there, we were shown a few cobs who seemed ideal, but my sister in law being the stubborn inexperienced person that she is, said she didn't want them, she wanted to look at the leopard spot. History of the leopard spot is rather interesting... he was bought as a 2yr old by the YO to use as a stallion, however, his babies were all a rather funny poo colour, so he was gelded in 2008. Since being cut he had been used in the riding school, and was then sold on. The buyers funds fell through, so he was sent back to the riding school to be sold on. He is 15.2hh, and at the time was 5yrs old.

I tried him first, in the outdoor school, and really liked him - although he was a bit lazy he felt really safe and had fabulous paces. I then rode him in their jumping field, which is alongside a very busy main road, and had ponies turned out in it! He was more lively, and a bit stronger, but again very safe and sensible, and jumped beautifully! My sister in law tried him, and liked him, and so we let the girls ride him. They loved him instantly, and I decided that he was in fact perfect for them. This was because although safe, he didn't take any crap! My older niece was being a real brat, and when she didn't ask for something properly and he didn't do it, she whacked him and had a tantrum - this made him buck. Not nasty bucks, and he never unseated her, he just told her that she was being unfair and he didn't deserve a whack!

He was vetted and shipped over to Holland and then the problems began. When deal was made, the owner of the riding school said that it was imperative that he was led in a chifney, and wasn't allowed to get away with his stalliony rubbish - he's a typical boy, and likes to try it on, but when told off and shown who's boss he behaves beautifully. My sister in law decided that she would ignore this, and start leading him in a headcollar, and riding him in a bitless bridle.
There followed a hell of a lot of phonecalls to me to whine about how naughty he was and how he was too strong and kept pulling her over when she led him. She didn't have the excuse that she didn't have a chifney as I spent £60 on a chifney, headcollar, wormer etc. so that she had everything she needed. £60 which I never got back!

In October, he was spooked by another horse, and pulled back whilst tied up on the yard, bolting to the gate which my older niece was trying to shut, he tried to stop, but slipped on the concrete and knocked the gate onto her, resulting in her having severe brain injuries and a broken leg. Miraculously, she is now fine, but the horse has been sent over to me here in England to sell, as the girls are now frightened of him.

I had more problems with her re: transport and cost - after I had rung to say that he couldn't be shipped when planned due to the snow and us having an extra horse on the yard who couldn't be moved until the snow melted, I then got a phonecall saying "he's on his way, he'll be with you by 5". I went mental and rang the transport company, who said that they had also tried to convince her to to send him due to the snow, (strange, seeing as she blamed them for having to send him over) and that they were happy to have him on their yard for the next few weeks.

It then materialised that she hadn't sent me anything other than a headcollar and a bag of apples - what happened to all the tack and the rugs he went over with?! I called and told her that I had no money to kit him out, so she'd have to pay for tack and rugs etc. She said no! After a hell of a lot of arguing and me trying to explain that a horse for sale has to be seen to be hunting and competing etc. and therefore needs to be clipped so has to have rugs, she finally agreed. So now, we have tack and two rugs (wild, I know!) and I have a horse on my hands who has been ruined. There was also trouble with her unrealistic ideas about selling a horse, she said I could have a sliding scale of comission - 10 % if he was sold in the first month, then 5%, then nothing. I sent her a long and angry email explaining what selling horses entails, and saying that I would keep anything over the price she wanted for him - the standard deal I do with all owners.
When I sent him over there he was worth £6000, and now I'm not happy even advertising him due to his rearing, napping and bolting in hand. He has clearly been allowed to get away with murder, and I'm being put under immense pressure to sell him asap, but I'm not happy selling something that I wouldn't buy myself. He's learning again, and is getting better, but I'm really struggling to get any sense or money out of her. So far this horse has cost me about £500 that I haven't seen. He's also currently with my big eventer here where I work, which is all fine and dandy, but means that my wages are down by about £100 a week, and my mare, who needs company, is costing me £60 a month grass livery 40 miles away where she is just mooching about in a field and I can only see her on Sundays.

What shall I do?! Do I carry on and just get tough with her, or do I cut my losses and give up, and tell her to send him to a dealer? Getting so fed up with it, and feel sorry for him cause he's such a lovely boy, but I can't carry on like this!
HELP EVERYONE!
 

MrReally

Well-Known Member
Joined
19 February 2010
Messages
56
Visit site
Utterly useless post but offering support :)
Thats a really tough one! Not really anything I can say as I dont have a clue what to suggest, but I hope it gets sorted for you and the horse finds a nice new home
 

galaxy

Well-Known Member
Joined
5 September 2006
Messages
5,959
Location
Bucks
Visit site
I'd speak your your brother. Don't you think you could have a more frank discussion with him? If you can't come to an arrangement that you're happy with, I'd give them notice and tell them they have to remove him from your yard by X date to a dealer or a selling yard.

But a 5 yr old 15.2hh for a 5yr old and 7 yr old girl? I think something nearer 13hh would have been a lot more suitable.
 

trundle

Well-Known Member
Joined
30 April 2007
Messages
2,297
Location
Beds / Bucks borders
Visit site
I have to agree with galaxy - this horse sounded completely unsuitable from the start. My daughter is 7 (a pretty big strong 7 as well) and my horse is 15.2hh, there is no way she could ride my horse properly. A late-gelded 5 year old as well...what is WRONG with some people? Did they really pay £6k for him? For a "kids' pony" (which he isnt)???

If i were in your shoes, i would send him to a decent dealer on sales livery. if your SIL doesnt like it, tell her to come over and sell the horse herself.
 

EgerdenFarmStud

Well-Known Member
Joined
7 March 2010
Messages
487
Location
Nr Ashford, Kent
Visit site
She sounds like a total div to me ( sorry - family and all that ) If it was me I'd speak to your brother ( If it's your sister in law ) explain that she is being totally un reasonable and that you need to work with the horse before you are prepared to sell him, but that the work comes at a cost!! If she wants £6000 for him, thats fine, try to sell him at that price ( or whatever you think suitable ) and when he is sold take out your money ( feed, shoeing, livery for him and your mare that has lost her house etc etc...) I would send her a bill every month with exactly what he is costing you... So she knows beforehand that if she doesn't pay you, that the money will be deducted from his sale price... If he really is un-handleable, or you don't want to put your name to him when seling him, maybe it would be best to send him to a reputable dealer and just get what you can for him, still taking out the money that he has cost you. She has messed you around, and really, why the hell should you have to have a horse that she has ruined to sell...It's not really your problem is it? She sent it to you, so really , you have the upper hand...
 

Starzaan

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 January 2010
Messages
4,084
Visit site
Thank you for the support people, nice to know there are people sending us good vibes!

And to all those of you who are not helping and telling me that he was entirely wrong for the girls, please don't say anything at all if you can't be helpful! Although a brat, my older niece rides incredibly well for her age (youtube "Bluey the pony" to see her trying him), my younger niece just likes sitting on and being led about occasionally, and I would absolutely not have let them even think about buying him if I thought he was the wrong horse for them. The reason they wanted him was so that my older niece could stop stealing her mother's 16.3hh ex racer to do local children's dressage competitions on.
Please don't be nasty, I've asked for HELP not rudeness, and I knew what I was doing when I tried him - I've had horses all my life and have competed regularly for my country in polocrosse, so am not a total div when it comes to horses! I know that in theory it sounds crazy, but when if you haven't got anything constructive to say, kindly bugger off!
 

Starzaan

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 January 2010
Messages
4,084
Visit site
EgerdenFarmStud, thank you - that sounds like a plan! She IS a total div, and it's the fact that it's family that is making this so hard, with any other owner I could be much more blunt! At home (we have a livery yard specialising in rehab of injured racehorses and TB youngsters, and do a lot of sales for owners) we charge a standard full selling livery each week, but as she's family everyone expects me to bend over backwards for nothing! It wouldn't bother me so much if he hadn't been so fab when he left, but it's like a different horse has been sent back to me!
Will def. be sending her monthly invoices now!
 

CeeBee

Well-Known Member
Joined
11 November 2008
Messages
1,418
Location
Bedfordshire
Visit site
Actually I wasn't being nasty, I just asked if I understood the situation correctly i.e. perhaps 15.2 was a typing error (never mind the age and recently cut part). This is a public forum, so you will get opinions that you are happy to read and equally those that you are not.
So if you want advice, perhaps don't tell people to b*gger off if you don't like what they say!
 

skychick

Well-Known Member
Joined
12 March 2010
Messages
1,071
Location
Devon
Visit site
I have to admit i agree with CeeBee, it is a public forum and people will tell you their thoughts/opinions/criticisms/advice whether you want to hear it or not.
I have just had some good advice, helpfull suggestions and a hell of a lot of flack when i asked for advice.
You shouldnt tell people to b*gger off if you dont like their comment.....take it on the chin and dont rise to it.

You are in a tricky situation, one that could possibly have been avoided, even if you have represented the country for polo, been around horses all of your life, a 15.2 is simply too big for children of 5 and 7. The age of the horse is unimportant. My goddaughters sister has a lovely little pony a 12hh pony called Jack, he is 5 and is lovely. As does her cousin a 13.3 who i rising 5. Both lovely ponies for their age and sut her the girl with the 13.2 is 8 and will still have that pony for a couple of years without outgrowing it and she can enter all of the childs classes with a horse that size.
Dont take that as me having a go, we all have different ideas of what is right and what is wrong.
But that aside, your sister in law has left you in an awfull position which is simply not on.
Why should you be expected to sort out her mess.....even if you found the horse for her...at the end of the day it was her decision to pay £6000 for an unsuitable horse. It should be up to her to sort it out.....not palm it off on you.
But that is family business and we all know too well how tricky it can be when dealing with family.

Couldnt the lady you bought him off take the horse back for reschooling, so that either she pays you a reasonable price for the horse with the view of putting in some work and selling him to make a profit.
Otherwise, i know it is probably not practical but you could give your sister in law a sum of money, have the horse yourself and then go on to put some work into him (if he was a good horse once, in time he can be again) and then you could make some money to cover/get back some of the money he has cost you.

Good luck, i really hope you find a new home/get him back to his former self then find him a new home you dont deserve to have the hassle you have with what was a lovely horse before he was ruined by someone and then discarded when they "didnt want the hassle anymore"
 

Fransurrey

Well-Known Member
Joined
27 April 2004
Messages
6,630
Location
Surrey
Visit site
Crikey, OP, this sounds like a right royal mess. Don't know what to suggest, really. Is there anyone around who could loan him and therefore increase his saleability? If he is talented, there might be someone local who could go places with him and help you both, so to speak!
 

NeilM

Well-Known Member
Joined
15 January 2008
Messages
2,706
Location
Nth Somerset
Visit site
What about an ad somewhere like project horses. The ads there are pretty honest and it would seem like somewhere to try.

What a terrible shame, he sounds like he was a good little horse and could be again in the right hands. Talking of which, I am sitting (metaphorically) on mine, a 15.2 leopard spot, hmmmmmm).
 

DivaRosa

Well-Known Member
Joined
13 August 2009
Messages
210
Visit site
I don't really have any advice to offer apart from to get your money back off your SIL. However, I just watched the video on You Tube and he looks a total dude! I see what you mean about your niece being brave and she is def a confident wee rider!! Ace!!
 

Starzaan

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 January 2010
Messages
4,084
Visit site
Thank you all so much for your advice, and I'm really sorry if I seemed rude - I'm just stressing so much about this!
The original owner can't have him back as she has too many horses as it is, or that would be the ideal situation.
The idea of loaning him out for a bit is a good one, that would mean he could spend a summer with someone who is still able to do a bit of pony clubbing and have a bit of fun with him. It's driving me mad cause he had so much potential to do anything when he left, and now, although he's still a diamond in the school, I have a feeling she was scared of him and never took him hacking, so we just stand up and show everyone our belly button at the end of the drive!
 

1life

...
Joined
7 October 2009
Messages
368
Visit site
Actually I wasn't being nasty, I just asked if I understood the situation correctly i.e. perhaps 15.2 was a typing error (never mind the age and recently cut part). This is a public forum, so you will get opinions that you are happy to read and equally those that you are not.
So if you want advice, perhaps don't tell people to b*gger off if you don't like what they say!

Ah, but what you gave wasn't actually advice, was it? It was an opinion on what has happened before and that (although not perfect) is history. And, if you feel that everyone is entitled to voice their opinion then surely you should also accept being told to bugger off, if that is the OP's opinion..........
Staarzan, you have obviously tried your best in this situation but, as unfortunately happens, have ended up not helping yourself. Some good advice has been given already and if it were me I would advertise him truthfully, vet any potential new owners thoroughly and get back to spending time withmy own horses.
 

thoroughlybred1

Active Member
Joined
10 March 2008
Messages
46
Visit site
As the Original owner of this horse, i am absolutely GUTTED to read about this behaviour!

First of all, I didnt want to show this horse to the people as straight away no way would I have deemed him suitable for a child. However, at the buyers insistance i got him out of the stable as they turned their nose up at the smaller, older and more suitable ponies i had prepared for them to try. He was shown by one of my girls, then ridden by the OP before the 7 yr old child got on, and i have to say i was GOBSMACKED at how well she rode him and how he went for her.......AS i was led to believe the mother was going to ride the horse with a view to the child riding him inbetween times and eventually going on to him, I asked they come back and try him again (which they did) and indeed as many times as they wished to make sure they were happy they would cope with him.

I was MORTIFIED to hear of the accident in the field, but when i saw pictures of two small children stood next to him loose in a field with another horse next to a pile of hay just a few days after he had arrived in his new home the alarm bells started to sound! He is a big enough horse to be loose next to tiny children without taking into account food and another horse also loose!

I thought he was getting on well back over here......especially after being asked if one of my girls would ride him in a yard dressage comp coming up!

Also, He may well have been worth £6000, but this is no where near what he was sold for. And he was not cut because his foals all came out a "funny poo colour"......His foals are fantastic in colour, temperament and movement - I actually regretted cutting him, but as we are ultimately a riding school keeping a Stallion was no longer practical, and i also didnt want him to live a life of confinement as when he was entire we were very limited to who we could turn him out with.

PLEASE PLEASE dont sell him to a dealer - I will have him back and turn him out until i have room rather than that......It broke my heart deciding to sell him in the first place - i cried buckets when he left and if I had a use for him (he is too small for me, too slow for my pony racing son and far too good (and young) for the riding school) he would never have been sold and I would have him back in a heartbeat. If it comes to that PLEASE let me know first. I've had this horse since he was 2 and while he has obviously learned some pretty bad behaviour, he is only clever - not nasty or malicious.

OP - I'm sorry you have been saddled with the problem, and if it will make things easier for you I will make space for him to come back here on schooling/selling livery - I just wish you'd told me how bad he's got rather than tell me everything was fine!
 

Bowen4Horses

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 March 2009
Messages
4,970
Location
South Lincs/North Cambs
www.poppywebber.co.uk
As the Original owner of this horse, i am absolutely GUTTED to read about this behaviour!

First of all, I didnt want to show this horse to the people as straight away no way would I have deemed him suitable for a child. However, at the buyers insistance i got him out of the stable as they turned their nose up at the smaller, older and more suitable ponies i had prepared for them to try. He was shown by one of my girls, then ridden by the OP before the 7 yr old child got on, and i have to say i was GOBSMACKED at how well she rode him and how he went for her.......AS i was led to believe the mother was going to ride the horse with a view to the child riding him inbetween times and eventually going on to him, I asked they come back and try him again (which they did) and indeed as many times as they wished to make sure they were happy they would cope with him.

I was MORTIFIED to hear of the accident in the field, but when i saw pictures of two small children stood next to him loose in a field with another horse next to a pile of hay just a few days after he had arrived in his new home the alarm bells started to sound! He is a big enough horse to be loose next to tiny children without taking into account food and another horse also loose!

I thought he was getting on well back over here......especially after being asked if one of my girls would ride him in a yard dressage comp coming up!

Also, He may well have been worth £6000, but this is no where near what he was sold for. And he was not cut because his foals all came out a "funny poo colour"......His foals are fantastic in colour, temperament and movement - I actually regretted cutting him, but as we are ultimately a riding school keeping a Stallion was no longer practical, and i also didnt want him to live a life of confinement as when he was entire we were very limited to who we could turn him out with.

PLEASE PLEASE dont sell him to a dealer - I will have him back and turn him out until i have room rather than that......It broke my heart deciding to sell him in the first place - i cried buckets when he left and if I had a use for him (he is too small for me, too slow for my pony racing son and far too good (and young) for the riding school) he would never have been sold and I would have him back in a heartbeat. If it comes to that PLEASE let me know first. I've had this horse since he was 2 and while he has obviously learned some pretty bad behaviour, he is only clever - not nasty or malicious.

OP - I'm sorry you have been saddled with the problem, and if it will make things easier for you I will make space for him to come back here on schooling/selling livery - I just wish you'd told me how bad he's got rather than tell me everything was fine!

what a lovely, kind offer. i really hope you get him back and it all works out well. xxx
 

Luci07

Well-Known Member
Joined
13 October 2009
Messages
9,382
Location
Dorking
Visit site
Your SIL is bullying you and abusing you. I would take up the offer from his previous owner BUT whoever he ends up with you, judging from the post's I would strongly suggest that everything is put into writing first!! and you have nothing to lose from standing upto you SIL anymore.

Hope pony gets sorted out..
 

trundle

Well-Known Member
Joined
30 April 2007
Messages
2,297
Location
Beds / Bucks borders
Visit site
if he has come from TB1 then he is bound to be a good pony, just too much for children (and the little girl IS an exceptional rider, but she is still only 7!!). If you are still around, Starzaan, I would definitely take TB1 up on her kind offer. It would seem most sensible for all concerned.
 

exracerfan

Well-Known Member
Joined
8 June 2009
Messages
111
Visit site
I cannot believe how VERY lucky the OP is to have been made an offer like that by the original owner!!

When I first read OP's original post, I thought this has got to be a joke! Didnt know by the way that ponies went up to 15.2hh! I can not believe how irresponsible some adults and parents are with their children. I have watched the video, and just as I thought, the child is so small on him, that she would have no chance of staying on if he had wanted her off, as obviously her legs cannot wrap around him.

The OP was asked for help in finding a bomb proof childs pony. No wonder the SIL is mad. The OP said at the outset the SIL has not enough experience so sought help and advice. Think it was a case of the blind leading the blind. Sounds like the SIL also thinks she knows better than someone with experience too. Also there is no way any child, even one in their teens should have a young horse. The age of the horse DOES matter and all children when going from ponies to horses need a schoolmaster. They are not like ponies, which is why so many children dont make the transition from ponies to horses, because they need far more experienced riders and handlers in every way than a lot of ponies do.

I am glad the horse will probably be put back on the right track and hopefully find the right home. Sorry OP, if I sound blunt, but just am gobsmaked at what has happened. Think you are very lucky that he came from someone who obviously cares, as you could so easily have come unstuck if you had bought from someone else.
 

domane

Well-Known Member
Joined
16 September 2008
Messages
1,312
Location
South Shrops
Visit site
I would just like to add that I met the horse in question when he had been recently gelded and was still at the riding school... he was ridden out in my group on a hack and was perfectly behaved.

I also know TB1 and can vouch for the authenticity of her offer. I know the heartbreak she went through when the horse went.

I am shocked and saddened that his behaviour has been allowed to deteriorate with such poor management... he was such a poppet.
 

skychick

Well-Known Member
Joined
12 March 2010
Messages
1,071
Location
Devon
Visit site
Thoroughlybred1 you really do deserve a medal for putting up an offer like that and i seriously hope you have been thanked over and over again by now and your offer accepted!
Good luck with getting him back to his former glory. :)
 

ForeverBroke_

Well-Known Member
Joined
4 June 2008
Messages
10,364
Visit site
Hopefully, what a fantastic outcome. Well done TB1 and to the OP for putting up with your sister (runs).

I just looked at the youtube video - he looked like such a poppet.
 
Top