Pearlsasinger
Up in the clouds
Well TBH, I wouldn't have either of your farriers a 2nd time. It does take a while to get poor feet back into shape BUT those photos show very poor shoeing, as others have said, it looks as though the foot was made to fit the shoe rather than the other way round. And if as you said the first farrier made his feet look 'boxy' you don't want that either. I would spend as much time as possible looking at as many local equines as possible, maybe at a local show, and speak to the owners of those whose feet you like the look of (making sure that you know what good feet should look like!) and ask for contact details of their farrier(s). Also pm TheFarrier for advice.