Horse communicator yesterday - Amazing!!

J

jaijai

Well-Known Member
Joined
12 January 2011
Messages
470
Location
Essex
Visit site
Posted a couple of weeks ago and wondered if it would be a case of 'a fool and his money are soon parted'.
Pleased to report I am not a fool!
He was amazing. He saw 4 horses -all very different and he was absolutely spot on with each of them. He only asks horses name, age and how long they have been with you. He stood at the stable door,did not touch them or go in the stable and was so specific in the things he said about each horse it was uncanny.
I am so impressed. I had heard really good things about him but still kept an open mind and was amazed.
 
jaijai said:
Posted a couple of weeks ago and wondered if it would be a case of 'a fool and his money are soon parted'.
Pleased to report I am not a fool!
He was amazing. He saw 4 horses -all very different and he was absolutely spot on with each of them. He only asks horses name, age and how long they have been with you. He stood at the stable door,did not touch them or go in the stable and was so specific in the things he said about each horse it was uncanny.
I am so impressed. I had heard really good things about him but still kept an open mind and was amazed.
Click to expand...

??:confused::confused: I have looked back to all your post as far as May and cannot find any reference to anything like this^^^^:confused:
 
Yes did definitely post as ' Probably mad but........'

I know it's not every ones cup of tea and that's fine. I just found it really interesting and can't work out how he could relate so many specific things just by standing at stable door.
 
nikicb said:
No reason to support/deny the ability of communicators, but OP did post this thread recently.

http://www.horseandhound.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=555865
Click to expand...

I wasn't saying anything about the communicators ability, thats why I looked back to read what had been written before. But thank you for the link I missed that. I was looking for something that said horse communicator in title lol. Thanks again for the link.

OP what did he tell you then?
 
The sceptic in me (that's 100% of me, by the way) says that he needs to know the age and the length of time that you have had the horse so that he can keep his comments to things that you can't possibly say are completely incorrect. The rest of what he said will have been done like a "psychic", either fishing with generalisations and watching for your reaction before he gets more specific, or picking up on clues that you are unconsciously giving him.

I'd be really interested to know if you can convince me that he told you anything that he could not possibly have known or guessed.

What I would be interested to know as well is why you called him (and paid him?) - what were you looking for in the management of your horses that you felt you needed him for?

Not trolling, seriously interested in why something that I can't get my head around at all is valuable for other people.
 
cptrayes said:
The sceptic in me (that's 100% of me, by the way) says that he needs to know the age and the length of time that you have had the horse so that he can keep his comments to things that you can't possibly say are completely incorrect. The rest of what he said will have been done like a "psychic", either fishing with generalisations and watching for your reaction before he gets more specific, or picking up on clues that you are unconsciously giving him.

I'd be really interested to know if you can convince me that he told you anything that he could not possibly have known or guessed.

What I would be interested to know as well is why you called him (and paid him?) - what were you looking for in the management of your horses that you felt you needed him for?

Not trolling, seriously interested in why something that I can't get my head around at all is valuable for other people.
Click to expand...

I'm clicking on the non-exsistant 'Like' button.
 
I'm interested to find out more about this. I don't understand how somebody who has known the particular horse for say half an hour or so can tell an owner/rider/keeper etc the animals entire life story.

Somebody once told me that their friend's pony (who was normally really quiet 'bombproof' type) point blank refused to cross a particular bridge when they were out hacking. They tried everything to get her across but she really didn't like it so eventually gave up and contacted a horse communicator type person who 'spoke' to the pony and found out that the reason she didn't want to cross is because years and years ago a child was playing on the bridge and it collapsed and the child drowned, and the pony was scared to cross incase the same thing happened.

How do we know that this particular person hadn't done a bit of search on t'interweb and found this out? Or even just made it up!

Another person I know had a communicator out to find out why her NF was always really grumpy - apparently it was because he was unhappy about being put in the starvation paddock as he was quite porky! Again, this had come up in a conversation on facebook several weeks prior.

I'd be interested in seeing solid proof that supports that these people can actually communicate with animals. Google is your friend, that is all I'm saying!! :)
 
We once had a physic coming to do human readings, at the time we had kennels full of rescue dogs, on the confirming phone call she asked about a large brindle dog with a white paw and star on his face, we had never met and we did have a dog of that description
 
flirtygerty said:
We once had a physic coming to do human readings, at the time we had kennels full of rescue dogs, on the confirming phone call she asked about a large brindle dog with a white paw and star on his face, we had never met and we did have a dog of that description
Click to expand...

heh. is that really proof tho >?. Isnt there's a good chance she knew of/had seen/been told that dog was there in the first place?
 
Firstly until she arrived she didn't know we were caring for death row dogs,
Secondly she only had my first name and general area, I gave her (complicated) directions on the night and finally it we did not have an open kennels, adopters were invited to meet the dog they were interested in, as most had aggression issues, hence the death row
 
flirtygerty said:
Firstly until she arrived she didn't know we were caring for death row dogs,
Secondly she only had my first name and general area, I gave her (complicated) directions on the night and finally it we did not have an open kennels, adopters were invited to meet the dog they were interested in, as most had aggression issues, hence the death row
Click to expand...

ah ok.
i can understand that then.
im a bit of a cynic by nature but more than prepared to be open minded. it is an interesting topic.
 
We did get Ann Dee out many years ago to read daughters pony and my welsh sec D. Will admit was cynical and still am of certain things but she did get somethings that couldn't have known.
We had just changed daughters pony into a 'bubble' bit because he ran off with her at a BSJA show in a snaffle.Pony 'didn't like his new bit'.Also that he had sore feet-there were issues with farrier not putting on shoes with long enough heel.Also didn't like travelling on his own could we put a jumper of daughters in box with him-this did appear to help him.Daughter and pony were very close practically grew up together.
My welshie said he didn't like his 'new' rider and tbh had stopped girl riding him as instructor felt she had to intervene when girl was hitting battering horse with stick and jumped him a lot when I had said only once week she continually jumped him daily.
said he didnt want to be sent away again -he had went with my neice to a friends yard for a month or two.
Asked her to ask if he liked what he did before - she said he loved his cart! He was driven before I got him and did really well at it,and behaved but was terrible ridden.Most ungenerous horse ever bless him!
Only thing is I knew some of past of my horses so had a baseline so to speak but it is too easy for non genuine people to scam it I think
 
ARRGGHHH. Just taken ages to write a really lengthy reply -kept getting interrupted and then got timed out so wouldn't let me post it. :mad:Will try to get on later tonight to redo it.
 
I totally understand why people are sceptical and to be honest I would normally be the same.
Had heard about him through a friend. He had done some readings on her yard and the owners had been really impressed.
She decided to try him when he next visited. He told her that her horse wanted to know why she had been dumped at 'that other yard'. Was it because she used to knock so many poles down when she jumped? Why did the girl who used to ride her not come to see her any more? She didn't like that other yard because that was when her legs had started to hurt.
The horse used to be ridden by my friends daughter who stopped riding and she went on full loan to a lady at a yard a mile or so away She was there about 3 years. She was showing arthritic changes with intermittent lameness so went back to my friend. She had since been successfully treated with injections for her arthritis and is sound. And yes she did always knock down the poles when they used to take her out jumping. He told her lots of other things which were very specific.
Another mutual friend who is on my yard decided to book him - he will not do more than 4 readings at a time - so she booked for 4 horses and we took one of the places. No specific reason for booking him other than I thought it was interesting and wanted to see what he would say.
He did not know which horses he would be seeing until he got to the yard. We were very careful not to give any information apart from horses name age and how long we had him which is all he asks for.
He gave very specific information on all 4 horses ranging from one who liked the music being played in the new lorry but was upset because the owner moaned at her when she sneezed and made a mess on the walls. (This happened recently).
Another one asked for cooling gel to be put on one of his legs as it often ached after schooling. This was caused by an old injury he sustained when he was on the yard previously and was much younger. He had been on the yard previously and injured that leg when he got it caught in the metal frame of mounting steps. There are no scars to suggest he had an injury there.
He told us that our horses said his new saddle is much more comfortable. The old one restricted the movement in his right shoulder and he was not able to move as freely as he should. He liked the lady saddle fitter as she really understands his needs. We got him a new dressage saddle about 3 months ago as his old one seemed to be restricting his movement in his right shoulder especially in canter and changed from a male saddle fitter to a female one. She has since fitted him with a jumping saddle as well and he seems really happy in both.
I have 8 pages of notes for the reading with our horse so far too much to post on here. I have tried to give examples that show how specific he was. If he had just said random things I am sure some would fit but everything was so detailed. We are in touch with our boys previous owners and have his full history. The sketchiest piece of information was that our horse misses the sound of the church bells. We spoke to his previous owner today and she confirmed he had been stabled in a small village and yes he was able to hear the church bells.
I am not trying to 'convert' anyone and quite understand that many will be highly sceptical about this and I have no problem with that. I am sure there are good and bad communicators as in most things, and can see how easy it would be to scam people. I just thought it was really interesting and cannot work out how he could be so specific about everything he told us as he did not know anything about us or our horse - even our names before he came. He did not ask us any questions and we certainly did not feed him any information. I am still amazed.
 
I'm a sceptic but I'm interested :) My girl and I have had some testing times but I feel like we are the best now we have ever been and I would love to know if she felt the same :) daft maybe but I've spent money on worse lol
 
I have posted about this before on a similar thread.

A trainee horse communicator appealed on here for 'subjects' to communicate with for a course she was doing. Sister responded out of interest and cynicism. Sis and communicator have been in touch several times. On one occasion our horse had told the communicator about a dog in a barrel. We could not make any sense of this and dismissed it. The horse apparently mentioned it in subsequent conversations, so we asked for more details. The dog was laughing, the barrel was blue.
Then we realised that when our very happy JRT bitch died at home the ground was frozen, so we put the body in a blue barrel with a close fitting lid until we could bury her. She was still in the barrel, in the yard, where the horse lives, at the time of the communication.

Needless to say the communicator knew nothing about this - we hadn't broadcast the fact that the body was in the barrel. Even our neighbours/friends didn't know, let alone any-one else, so this info certainly couldn't have been unearthed on the internet or anywhere else.

IMO, there are many things in this world that we do not yet understand/cannot explain.
 
cptrayes said:
The sceptic in me (that's 100% of me, by the way) says that he needs to know the age and the length of time that you have had the horse so that he can keep his comments to things that you can't possibly say are completely incorrect. The rest of what he said will have been done like a "psychic", either fishing with generalisations and watching for your reaction before he gets more specific, or picking up on clues that you are unconsciously giving him.

I'd be really interested to know if you can convince me that he told you anything that he could not possibly have known or guessed.

What I would be interested to know as well is why you called him (and paid him?) - what were you looking for in the management of your horses that you felt you needed him for?

Not trolling, seriously interested in why something that I can't get my head around at all is valuable for other people.
Click to expand...

Seconding the needing a like button. My friend had one out that everyone was raving about, she was a very intelligent woman and stared at me and my friend constantly. Fortunately we have very good poker faces and she couldn't tell a thing from us. Every time she said something we either stared blankly or said "sorry but ask the horse". She concluded the horse had a back and back leg problem, was very confident and some other stuff that was the complete opposite of the horse in question! Horse in question had navicular in the front feet and was the biggest wuss you have ever met.
 
Pearlsasinger said:
I have posted about this before on a similar thread.

A trainee horse communicator appealed on here for 'subjects' to communicate with for a course she was doing. Sister responded out of interest and cynicism. Sis and communicator have been in touch several times. On one occasion our horse had told the communicator about a dog in a barrel. We could not make any sense of this and dismissed it. The horse apparently mentioned it in subsequent conversations, so we asked for more details. The dog was laughing, the barrel was blue.
Then we realised that when our very happy JRT bitch died at home the ground was frozen, so we put the body in a blue barrel with a close fitting lid until we could bury her. She was still in the barrel, in the yard, where the horse lives, at the time of the communication.

Needless to say the communicator knew nothing about this - we hadn't broadcast the fact that the body was in the barrel. Even our neighbours/friends didn't know, let alone any-one else, so this info certainly couldn't have been unearthed on the internet or anywhere else.

IMO, there are many things in this world that we do not yet understand/cannot explain.
Click to expand...

I've read this before .. and it always makes me giggle!! :D the lady on here seems very genuine and i would love her to read my horse ...when i get one!! lol!!
 
Have tried this before, as, although i am sceptical, i would sooo love to know what my boy thinks about everything ......i noted down everything that i might have inadvertently communicated on this forum about him to ensure that this could not be part of the 'communication'. I also chosethe person because they did the communication without seeing the horse ( i have always thought that a communicator with a bit of horse sense could make some general observations that could be quite accurate if they saw a horse, and its type, and its living). Unfortunately,nothing i was told was in the least relevant to my horse. I do think the person in question was very disappointed as they really believed in their work.
Jaijai - could you pm me with details of yours?
 
Question..can this communication be two ways or is it just the horse's point of view? If so there are a few things I'd like to say to the mare who dumped me last week plus I'm now getting suspicious at it might have been accidentally on purpose.
 
TrasaM said:
Question..can this communication be two ways or is it just the horse's point of view? If so there are a few things I'd like to say to the mare who dumped me last week plus I'm now getting suspicious at it might have been accidentally on purpose.
Click to expand...

Lol. :D
You can ask questions too. Wonder what she would say - just wanted to get home and have dinner?:)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top