Horsebox Tragedy

elainemcgovern

New User
Joined
25 January 2007
Messages
3
Location
Wicklow, Ireland
setanta.ucd.ie
I am writing to you because I have no answers for what happened to my lovely horse Sophie who died under the most unfortunate set of circumstances I could imagine and in a vain attempt to prevent other horses falling victim to what I can only call ignorance and not trusting yourself.

To give you a little background into the life of my beautiful girl. She was brought up in a farm dedicated to the breeding of horses. Her first owners had recently made the transition from dairy cow producers to breeding sport horses with international potential. My partner and I had been looking for a new young sport horse with an abundance of presence, talent and above all a kind temperament. After spotting a stunning looking chestnut filly that would jump out of her skin rather than touch a pole, we followed her into the sales ring. The bidding went too high for us to purchase her and we were delighted when she didn’t sell in the end.

So, instead, we followed the horse breeder home to his farm in Wicklow, to see her again in her home environment. I was completely besotted with her. The owners, realising that the chestnut filly may be too small for my partner, decided to show us a selection of his other horses. And then we laid eyes on our beautiful, timid yet gentle Sophie. There was something in her that we loved instantly and from that moment on we knew that she had to be ours. We probably paid severely over the odds but we didn’t care because she had something that no other horse we had seen had. She personified innocence.

We brought her to one very popular riding establishment but she quickly became depressed there and we were forced to mover her to a very exclusive, exceptionally well maintained accommodation. The staff there was 100% genuine. They loved horse and were not there merely because they were being paid. Having not been broken correctly, it had taken months of perseverance and attentiveness to gain her trust and to understand what she wanted of us in terms of riding. She was a darling in the stable, great friend and fancied by every other horse in the yard.

We had just gotten her to the level where we felt confident she would enjoy attending competitions and we had already brought her on her first drag hunt. Yesterday was going to be her second. Hardly even a hunt, it was more so a hack through the beautiful Wicklow mountains.

We attended to her the same way we did every time. Because she was only 6, we put her tack on in the stable for safety. And then put her bandages and sweat rug on also. Then we loaded her into the horsebox as we did every time with the horsebox backed up to the door and quietly lead her up. Even the yard manager was there to double check that safety had been paramount.

We own a horsebox for a 168cm horse and because she is at the very top of that height bracket as well as uncomfortable to travel in confined spaces, we had removed the central partition. My partner had put her chest bar up high to prevent her from trying to jump over the bar and the yard manager had tied her rope secure to ensure she couldn’t fidget too much. We normally drive with both of the windows shut at the back of the trailer to prevent our horses getting fright from passing motorists but had recently read an article that this could make horses claustrophobic and cause them to sweat up also. That, and because the yard manager who has years of experience in the area had also quoted the same reasons we listened to him. I am not fully confident in my abilities to get everything right and am always questioning my actions chose to rely on the experts. My partner, on the other hand, questioned the wisdom about 50 metres down the road as the yard manager knew her less well and did not have her full travel history to go on. No sooner had he said this than we heard an all mighty clatter emanating from the box.

He immediately stopped the car and jumped out, with me in trail. He looked in the front window of the box and had seen that our horse had managed to turn around in the box and some how managed to get her hindquarters under the front bar. As I mentioned earlier, she is 168 if not 170 cm at the withers and had gained a lot of muscle in the last year.

I ran round to the back of the horsebox as my boyfriend tried tirelessly to undo the bar from the outside. But by the time I had reached the back ramp she had already collapsed. I dropped the ramp slowly and could see that the rope that had been tied to the bailer twine attached to the hook where it was attached had not given way. Poor Sophie was in a terrible predicament. We rang the riding establishment and to their merit they were down within less than a minute.

From which point they took over. After a few moments, we pulled her from the box. And from then the staff in the yard really took over, which was very lucky for Sophie because Marcus and I were succumbed with shock. What should have been a fun day out for the horse was quickly deteriorating into a tragic event.

She had gotten cast in the horsebox, and had a natural predisposition to getting tied up. The yard girl who had her wits very much about her, kept sending me on errands, obviously to make me be of some sort of use. Luckily the vet was only 15 minutes away and by the time he had come we had sufficient rugs on her that it would aid with the tying up she was experiencing. He checked her out and gave her something to relieve the shock and said that we should see some improvement within the hour. Telling us that this occurs frequently on the racetrack and horses, once out of shock will choose to get up themselves. He really went above and beyond the call of duty.

After two hours of them waiting and me pleading with Sophie to get up, it began to dawn on me that it was unlikely she was going to. Her front legs were busy trying to stand and although there was movement in her hind legs, there was no reflexive action that should occur with all horses preparing to stand.

The vet took my boyfriend aside and explained the situation. Then when Marcus told him that he couldn’t make the call to end my lovely girls short life, the vet turned to me and again explained that even though her vitals are fine and she was attempting to get up, she couldn’t because she must have fractured a vertebra. It was that which was preventing the synapses travelling down her back to her hind legs, and in today’s equine medicine there is nothing that could be done for her. I could see that she was very uncomfortable and wanted desperately for that to end. So now my pleading for her to get up has turned to immense sorrow and guilt. I was given a few more moments to touch her beautiful head and kiss her like I always did on her nose.

I am so sorry for my poor baby girl and angry because there were no signs of injury. I keep thinking that if only one thing had been done differently she would have gone hunting and today would be resting in her stable. If we had trained her to accept the partition, she would still be here. If we had used weaker bailer twine, she would still be here. If we had closed the ramp door like we always do, she would still be here. If the front bar had popped up like it is supposed to under that kind of pressure, she would still be here. Perhaps, we shouldn’t have moved her out of the box until the vet came. This was an innocent drive that went horribly wrong.

My sorrow and grief drove me to write this and I’m still not sure what I hope to achieve. I have read every possible book on horse care and management and attended the BHS stage 1 and 2 courses in stable management, and still didn’t trust myself to make an accurate decision. If this is read by anyone, I pray that they can learn from this experience. Bad things don’t only happen to bad people and horses don’t just die from neglect and abandonme <font color="blue"> </font> nt. Tragedies happen from the simplest, most innocent cases of ignorance. In our attempts to provide the best for our horse we ended our lovely baby’s life. So please take care of these beautiful fragile creatures. There will never be another Sophie.
 

Bossanova

Well-Known Member
Joined
30 November 2004
Messages
10,284
Visit site
Very, very sorry for your loss but it sounds like a tragic accident, theres always what ifs and maybes but these things happen sometimes and there are always unanswered questions.
Big hugs though
 

JACQSZOO

Well-Known Member
Joined
12 June 2005
Messages
3,127
Location
Shropshire
Visit site
What a terrible tragedy. My heart was in my mouth reading your post. You must not blame yourself, there will always be what ifs and buts. You loved Sophie and gave her the very best you could.
Thoughts are with you.
 

Enfys

Well-Known Member
Joined
11 December 2004
Messages
18,086
Visit site
I am so desperately sorry for you and everyone concerned.

What an awful accident. Please, don't blame yourself or dwell on the what-ifs, from what you say it sounds as if you did nothing wrong.
 

michb52

Well-Known Member
Joined
4 August 2006
Messages
321
Location
Bangor NI
Visit site
I am so so sorry for your loss, but please dont beat yourselves up over what happened, it was a freak accident that no one can explain or justify.
You are very brave talking about it
Thoughts are with you.
 

cheeky girl

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 October 2003
Messages
826
community.webshots.com
Big hugs to all of you. What a horrible accident.
frown.gif
 

vicster

Well-Known Member
Joined
6 September 2005
Messages
1,188
Location
Somerset
Visit site
RIP Sopie, i am so so sorry for your loss, i can't imagine how you must be feeling right now. Please don't blame yourself it wasn't anyone's fault it was just one of those things. My heart goes out to you xx
 

Evadiva1514

Well-Known Member
Joined
7 January 2006
Messages
2,696
Visit site
I am so sorry to hear of your loss Ginny, she sounded like she was a beautiful mare and my thoughts are with you and your partner at this sad and tragic time...

Rest in peace little girl x x x
 

vickers22

Well-Known Member
Joined
10 December 2006
Messages
1,163
Visit site
my friend went through a similar tradgic accident once. They are completely out of the blue and unfortunately no matter what we do to make things safe etc they will always happen once in a while. Im so sorry that it happened to you. You cant blame yourself, although i know what it feels like because of my friend-i was there at the time. Im so sorry, i second that you are very brave for talking and warning others about it.
 

samp

Well-Known Member
Joined
27 June 2006
Messages
2,471
Visit site
OMg I am so sorry to hear of this fragic accident. There is nothing you could have done differently. Unfortunately it was one of those very tragic accidents and very sad loss for yourselves. My heart goes out to you
 

filly190

Well-Known Member
Joined
12 September 2006
Messages
1,714
Visit site
I hope it has helped writing it all down and the support you will receive from us all I am sure will be on-going.

This will stick with you both and only over time will get better. I dont think anyone can say a single word to make you feel better, but to know people are supporting you will hopefully help.

So, take care, try not to be too hard on yourself. No use laying blame in any direction. What is done cant be undone. You have acted quickly and responsibility and the little girl has'nt had to suffer, this will help give you piece of mind.
 

piebaldsparkle

Well-Known Member
Joined
26 July 2006
Messages
13,017
Visit site
RIP Sophie &amp; Best wishes to you and your other half. Please don't beat yourself up this was just a tragic accident. Accidents happen, that's life, if and buts don't help as I fully believe what will be will be. If you hadn't decided to go hunting that day, then it could well of happened another day. You did all you could to keep your horse safe and then as comfortable as you could till help arrived.
 

sherwood'

Well-Known Member
Joined
14 June 2004
Messages
582
Visit site
Oh that is such an awful story. But as others have said- there was nothing that you really did wrong- just bad luck that something like that wud happen. I have done exactly what you did re tying up tight, no partition etc manys a time without mishap.

Thoughts r with you but don’t blame yourself. I do no what its like to loose a horse in tragic circumstances- as many people do. And you keep asking yourself why me- why my horse and if only I had done this etc. It doesn’t get much easier fro a while but it does eventually- but mine happened about 5 years ago but I can still remember every detail of that awful day. Hugs x
 

Theresa_F

Well-Known Member
Joined
10 August 2005
Messages
5,577
Location
London - Essex side
Visit site
Reading this has really choked me up.

I am so sorry, Freak accidents do happen and there is nothing you can do to prevent them or blame yourself for.

You did all you could to make things safe - I have travelled without a trailer partition many times and had my horse snap the rope and turn round - she too hated a partition, I have travelled with tack on for hunting.

All I can do is send big hugs and say how sorry I am and that you will find another horse to love in the future and don't worry about this happening again.
 

JustKickOn

Well-Known Member
Joined
22 November 2006
Messages
16,994
Visit site
that made me cry
frown.gif
please please please do not blame yourself, you wern't to know, you were just doing what you had been told could help, nobody would have known that could happen. my heart really goes out to you. RIP Sophie.

if you need to talk im only a PM away. x
 

kibob

Well-Known Member
Joined
17 September 2006
Messages
2,558
Location
Cornwall
Visit site

That is so tragic. My heart goes out to you and your partner.

Please don't blame yourself, there are always if's and maybe's with any accident. You sound like a very wise and sensible horse owner, it is such a shame that your promising partnership with Sophie ended so suddenly.
 

Ginn

Well-Known Member
Joined
24 November 2005
Messages
4,003
Visit site
What a truely terrible tragedy, my heart really goes out for you. Huge hugs - please don't blame yourself, accidents happen no matter how hard you try to prevent them.
 

Gentle_Warrior

Well-Known Member
Joined
25 December 2006
Messages
2,529
Visit site
I am so sorry, my heart goes to you, your beloved Rosie and OH. I am crying myself xx

I am sure she knew she was loved and that you was not responsible, please dont blame yourself

xxxx
 
Top