Is it foolish not to have lessons?

_MizElz_

Well-Known Member
Joined
16 March 2010
Messages
1,069
Location
In front of my laptop...
Visit site
Ellie and I had our first show jumping session tonight; we've been doing a bit of XC (as most people know, as I do keep going on about it! :o) but have not SJed for aaaaages! We just went out to the show field (our yard has a lovely set of Jump for Joys with scary fillers!) with mum, and had a quiet pop round. I'm really pleased with how it went; we were 'clear' at everything we jumped, although not very tidy! :eek: We popped all the scary fillers, a stile, planks and a couple of wide oxers, all with no problem. And everything was either at the height or a bit bigger (75cm - 90cm) than we will be jumping on Sunday.

However, I am aware that I am very rusty; for some reason, I no longer seem to go with her as well as I used to over fences. In all our old SJ pics I am generally quite good in terms of position, but at the moment I am sitting up too much in mid air - although thankfully I never catch her in the mouth as I have lovely slippable reins! It doesnt hinder Ellie in any way, but I just know it doesnt look pretty and is not 'ideal'. She is also very, very excitable going into her fences, with the result that seeing a stride - again, something I used to be good at - has become quite tricky, as she tends to bounce going into them....! She is better getting deep than taking a long one, but again, it isnt ideal when it happens at the majority of fences.

Driving home, Mum asked me whether I think I should start having lessons again. Lessons have always been a bit of a hang up for me. I'm fine with flatwork lessons - I dont get nervous at all and really enjoy them - but the thought of one-to-one jumping lessons has always freaked me out a bit.

When we were SJing regularly, I had lessons with a very good friend of ours, who has been very successful and who has jumped on the international circuit. He found Ellie for us in the first place, and is the best instructor I have ever known - he really inspires you and gives you confidence. But even with him, I used to get very het up about our jumping lessons - although I always came away with a smile, I think the 'one to one' nature stopped me enjoying them as much as I should.
At Pony Club, I was a bit better largely due to the group situation - we had PC rallies with my instructor and I enjoyed them far more than one-to-ones.

My initial reaction was 'no, I only want to do little, local stuff, I don't want lessons.' There is truth here; I will never jump above 2'6 now as both Ellie and I are happy and confident at that height (although Ellie is better over bigger fences - it's more me who is being fainthearted now!). I have no aspirations to go affiliated - our BSJA days are over as she is out of BN and Discovery anyway, so we wouldnt be able to do the little classes any more. But at the same time, I am quite competitive and I would be wrong to say that I dont have any desire to improve. At the moment, anything we do is purely for fun and to 'get round', but I would like to think we may be able to actually compete for places eventually. I'm still only talking local comps!

Am I being unfair to Ellie by refusing to have lessons? I guess there are several options; there are several people at my yard who would probably be up for some SJ tuition, so I could always try to organise a group session with my old instructor. I could join a riding club, and attend rallies - although obviously there is less personalisation there (for instance, I will never, ever do gridwork again so would have to stand down if ever this were taking place). But is having one-to-one lessons the only real way to improve properly?

Does anyone else have the same kind of hang ups as me? How do/did you overcome them? :confused:
 
No I don't .. lol. I love lessons and have currently asked my boyfriend if i can up my two lessons a week to three (only half an hour, so not expensive!)


I feel personally the more lessons the better BUT this is only with a good instructor and someone who like you said inspires you. I would take lessons but say to them, no point making me nervous (as we all know we do not learn when we are so nervous) can we please do it at my pace. Hopefully taking the pressure off you. Have some fun with what sounds like a fab instructor you have.xx
 
I do understand where you are coming from and am in a similar position, Joined a riding club, inorder to get out more and to do the clinics, but it has come apparent that there are some issues that cannot be solved by just attending clinics. I am now trying to arrange monthly lessons (at the moment anyway) to sort these little niggles, as for me I need to ensure that I am an effective rider and therefore secure in the saddle which then ensures that the confidence remains intact.
 
I have my first lesson in about 10 years next week & it's with a GP dressage rider. I'm terrified. My position is so much worse than it used to be and we definitely are not into our dressage... But I feel after 5 years off regular riding I really needed to swallow my pride and make sure that my riding is good enough to do my girl justice, even though we don't really have any plans to compete in any serious way anytime soon.
 
I have never botherd with lessons while I have just done Endurance rides and hacking for the last 5.5ish years, but now that I have moved to a yard with lots of jumping facilities ie cross country course, menage and show jumps field, I have started having jumping lessons every fortnight, me my daughter and friend share the lesson, for me it works well as I like to have a lesson, then go away and practice for a couple of weeks what I have learnt before the next lesson, plus sharing makes it less intense, having an instructor with the right attitude and you are happy with is big part for me.
I am not looking to do fancy SJ competions, only local shows, it's more a personal riding improvement and enjoyment for myself and the Ginger sausage I am having lessons for.
Only you can decide if you want lessons or not, suppose you need to ask your self what you are aiming for, joint lessons with friends sounds a good idea and probably more fun than a one to one :)
 
My initial reaction was 'no, I only want to do little, local stuff, I don't want lessons.' There is truth here; I will never jump above 2'6 now as both Ellie and I are happy and confident at that height (although Ellie is better over bigger fences - it's more me who is being fainthearted now!).

But didn't you say a while ago that you weren't ever planning on jumping 'properly' again? Look at you now! :)

If you're uncomfortable with one-on-one lessons, why not try and find some clinics? I loooove doing clinics as it's really interesting watching how other people deal with a combination etc. It might also be good for both of you to be getting out and about but not in a competitive environment?
 
When I had my own horse I had one jumping lesson with a 'real' instructor who spent the entire time telling me that I was wasting my horse as he had potential and I would never in a month of Sundays do him justice.
My friend who was on the 'circuit' many moons ago but not an instructor taught me everything but not always in a conventional way. Am I fool for not having lessons??? No...I'm a general all round fool :)

Anyways...
1.You have already worked out what you want to improve on so you are in a position to get an instructor who will work on these aspects.
2.You know you don't like one to one so why not see if you can join a group.
3.Try having just half an hour instructor till you feel comfortable.

Good Luck and remember You and Ellie are supposed to enjoy each other!! As long as you are both safe and having fun together then you have already 'won'.
 
well, I do like clinics better than lessons, as often having lessons for me, with the same person just started to bore me. I didnt feel like I was progressing. But I now realise that I prefer jumping to dressage, and would like some lessons now, to improve from jumping just 40 cm with my newly broken horse. Im aiming on doing 50 -60 by end of the year, she was a broodmare, so finding her balance a bit at the moment. I have taken her out and done some clinics and a local jumping comp, with her.. it was great fun.. and at the end of the day thats what its all about, _having fun!!
 
Top