Let your horse grieve or put to sleep with their beloved friend?

ChwaraeTeg

Well-Known Member
Joined
10 February 2008
Messages
547
Location
UK
Visit site
Do You Let your horses say goodbye?
Do You Let your horses grieve?

Anthropomorphism or attributing human qualities to animals, like the feelings of loss and sadness we experience during bereavement, is not misplaced with our pets. I believe they feel as strongly as you or I when they lose a loved one.

Recently my old friend died - a Welsh pony mare we bought for our first grandchild more than 24 years ago.
We are grieving. She was a member of the family, sharing our home, our lives. Her companion of the last 14 years is grieving too - a 22 year old ex-racehorse.

It was feared the Thoroughbred mare would become loopy or behave hysterically once she realized her friend was gone. She was definitely going to be upset as she would be left alone. In my experience, horses are herd animals and rarely happy without companions. This was going to be a difficult transition for all of us.


We spoke of the options for "when the time came" - to find another/other companion/s before that time? ....
We decided - no, she was too unwell to adjust just yet - we would wait until her health improved, maybe advertise for a livery or 2 -

It was suggested perhaps it would be kinder for the 2 friends to be put to sleep together , when the pony was beyond treatment, especially as the tb mare is given to flighty and explosive behaviour at times. Her grief could well be unbearable for her.......


oh what an awful conundrum it has been. I phoned close friends and family - read H&H online, searched the forums - and still could not decide what would truly be the kindest we could do for our horses.

Fate took a hand - Pony deteriorated very suddenly and sadly had to be put to sleep .The tb mare was loose nearby as pony laid to rest in the stable.
Once vet had left , we skipped out the stables then sat with our pony - door open . The mare joined us, just a sniff of her friend and then went into the stable next door to eat her hay as if nothing had happened.


When we went back into the house , we left just a rope across the open door so that the mare could still nuzzle her friend if she wanted to, but she didn't until the morning. I smoothed the ponys face, and came back out .
The mare was waiting and is not normally one to lick - but she sniffed and licked my hands non stop for a few minutes (very out of character), so I left the stable open for her to go in if she wanted .

She licked the door frames then half in and half out of the stable, she threw her head in the air and started smacking her lips together making a very strange sound while quickly nodding her head up and down. She blew gently and the dead ponys face and stood a while before toiletting and going to the stable next door to stand, head low.


Due to the storms, the pony had to lay there for another day.We covered her head as blood was now coming from nose and mouth). The mare just stood quietly near her. When we came out in the morning, she was eating hay and the weather had settled enough for her to go out in the field when she felt like .

As the lorry arrived to take pony away, I took our subdued mare for a walk out of sight of the stable yard.She was calm and nibbled the grass - a treat as this field had not been open since haymaking time .The lorry left and a while later we approached the yard. Before turning the corner, the mare started neighing, grew at least 2 hands in height and became her old prancing self.
Panic was in her face - she moves faster than me, so I let her go on to the stables.(They were now cleaned and yard hosed down).
She came to an abrupt halt outside ponys stable, went in and sniffed - there was now an unpleasant odour.

Next she went across the yard to the shelter and stayed there either looking at the empty stable or in our kitchen window.
Her expression and demeanour was that of a lost uncertain, lonely soul .

It looks like she did not move from the shelter during the night. Droppings were loose, in one place and hind fetlocks were puffy. When I brought the wheelbarrow to finish cleaning ponys stable, the mare overtook me and stood tall in the ponys stable, refusing to move. No problems, I had plenty of other stuff to be getting on with - preparing for her new companions who were arriving in an hour or 2.

When I went out into the field to check and adjust the fencing, she was with me - back to the yard for a forgotten hammer - she was with me . Up to the top field - she was with me, neighing occasionally and looking about.

Now her friends are here, I do not exist. It is as it should be, she is with her kind again, grazing , sharing a shelter looking calm. No doubt she is still grieving , but it is not so obvious today.

Sorry for the marathon. I had to write, while I could remember. Could not write her name, but she was my username here.
 
I do not know what is the 'right' thing to do but you have done absolutely the best you can for both your old friends. It is heartbreaking to watch them grieve, especially at a time when you are hurting too. But it's reassuring that now she has new companions her mind is occupied elsewhere, maybe there is a lesson worth learning there for you too. :-)

Sending my sympathies and best wishes.
 
You did the right thing by both your beloved horses, the mare will miss her friend but will get over it. I have had to put down foals while still on their mothers (and there is no bond stronger than a nursing mother's); after sniffing and pawing the mares slowly grazed away from the little bodies, no doubt sad, but never hysterical. Nature is a far better rationalist than we can ever be.
 
**Gulp, sniff**
So sorry that you've lost your old friend, even when it's the right thing to do it never gets any easier...

Thank you for posting tho - it's something that I'm going to have to face soonish and it has helped me to know that the one left behind is ok now her new friends are with her! My youngster's nanny is struggling a bit with her knee and I'm going to get a new friend for her so that when the day comes when the old pony needs to be pts it's not such a shock. However they've been together for 3 years and I know my youngster will feel the loss. I will let her sniff her friend and hopefully she'll understand and move on...
 
We were wondering this recently. A horse was PTS at the yard and we were worried about how the one left behind would react, as they had been together for almost 20 years. However, when he was PTS, the one left behind couldn't have cared less! We left his rug on the stable door and he didn't even sniff it. It was a little sad to see that he didn't care, but it did make it easier for all involved!

So sorry to hear about your pony *big hugs* Though glad to hear your mare is enjoying the company of her new friends!
 
We had a similar dilemma. We had 2 mares who had been together for 20 yrs, within a herd of 4. One was 4 yrs older than the other we expected her to go first and often wondered if we should have the younger one pts at the same time. However events overtook us and the younger mare had stroke in her stable one night. The other mare was in her adjoinging stable with the exit blocked. The hunt came to pts, which had to be done in full view of the older mare, who also had a companion on her other side.
The one left behind was very subdued but didn't call. A few weeks later we got our 2nd Appaloosa, who is solid coloured and it was just as if they recognised each other as Appies. They were firm friends, if not as close as the original 2 for the 2 yrs or so until the old lady had to be pts before the start of another winter.
There is no right or wrong in many situations, we just do the best we can under the circumstances.
 
So sorry for your loss.

I was taught by an excellent vet that it is always best to allow a remaining horse/s to be able to sniff/see/touch a horse after it has been PTS as they understand and accept death, but simple" loss" ( gone missing) they struggle with. I have always done this and it does seem to be the right thing to do.
 
My overriding thought reading was what lucky horses you have/had to have owners take such thought and care to the end and beyond.

I'm glad your mare is enjoying her new friends.

The subject of your post is something I think about often as I have an aging 20 year old and a 7 year old who has grown up since 18 months with the old mare. I dread the day my old girl leaves us for so many reasons one of which is how my sensitive young horse will cope.
 
I have witnessed closure three times (and a fourth I couldn't bear to watch) which all Went exactly the same as yours, OP. They seem to know death is final and accept it immediately. There are no histrionics, just quiet acceptance. The grieving period I expect varies. But solitude will not be helpful and 'like company', probably essential.

I'm very sorry to hear of your loss. We lost a much loved pony (in my avatar) and I'm grieving still, several years later. Some losses hit harder than others, but happily, horses seem to move allegiance fairly quickly as long as they are given the chance.
 
...

The subject of your post is something I think about often as I have an aging 20 year old and a 7 year old who has grown up since 18 months with the old mare. I dread the day my old girl leaves us for so many reasons one of which is how my sensitive young horse will cope.

Allow closure and all will be fine. If your horse is to be euthanised by injection, having her companion grazing close by will help her to be unsuspecting (I know, it's awful but three of the PTS I have been at were with pair bond close by) then you leave them together. I'd be arranging some sort of company after that, or before if you have to make the call and have chance to plan.

You will need wine and hankies.
 
We had mega histrionics when we had my old mate PTS a few weeks ago. She had been grazing with one of our TB geldings for about a month - just the two of them.
The gelding was held on a headcollar whilst the mare was injected. When the Vet had checked she was truly gone the gelding was released. He went to her immediately and started violently pawing her and biting her neck and trying to lift her head. Once he had finished trying to get her up - that is for all the world what he looked as though he was doing, he galloped flat out around the filed screaming for what seemed like an eternity. The Vet did say she had never seen a horse react so violently to the loss of a mate.
When he had finished his insane galloping and screaming he then calmly began to graze. He has never fretted for her since.
 
What a caring thoughtful owner xx

I have a youngster who spent her first three years of life with an old horse of mine. The old girl was taken from her stable one night away from the youngster and never returned, they'd shared a field and stable block just the two of them for three years. I feel this has effected my youngster massively sadly. Giving the situation at the time it never crossed my mind to let her say goodbye, I wish I could go back and change this if I could!

A few months ago I assisted a horse being PTS for my vet on behalf of the owner and we let the owners other pony spend time with the body afterwards, horse seemed to accept its friend had gone after pawing the horse and calling for 10 mins he just walked away and has been fine since.
 
OP, I'm so sorry for your loss, but it's great that your mare has settled with her new friends.

I think it's important to allow the living horses access to the body afterwards if possible. As said, they seem to suss it out and accept it better that way. Mine have had much more long term stress on the occasions when a horse has gone off to horsepital and never come back.
 
Allow closure and all will be fine. If your horse is to be euthanised by injection, having her companion grazing close by will help her to be unsuspecting (I know, it's awful but three of the PTS I have been at were with pair bond close by) then you leave them together. I'd be arranging some sort of company after that, or before if you have to make the call and have chance to plan.

You will need wine and hankies.

Thank you, hoping it will be a while yet, but I like to feel prepared. Company wouldn't be an issue as have horses they know around. Wine and hankies a definite though.
 
Top