Magnitude vs. So Kalm Plus

[sachak]

Which of these products do you rate, do you have an alternative product in the calmer world you couldn't live without... why?
What sort of horse do you use the product on, why, and with what effect?
Cost wise, how does feeding the calmer fare.. expensive, reasonable chap etc?

Sorry loads of questions but doing some research. These two are both EA products and seem to boast th same end result, keeping a lid on it without sacrificing performance.

help

Sacha x

 

[punk]

Have tried EVERYTHING - you name it we've tried!!!

Right now, I would say Oxyshot had a really good effect.

BUT - having tried ProKalm over a fairly short period (including a 1* 3-day-event) I am cautiously saying this is the best yet.

I say cautiously because I think the proof is in the next few stressful situations, and we haven't had it long enough for that. Certainly seemed to work miricals though!!

 

[little_flea]

Most people I know swear by Nupafeed. Two of my friends horses were put on Magnitude to reduce costs, and they think the effect is much less than with Nupafeed.

 

[Nosey]

I for one would rec. Nupafeed. Only other one I have tried tho was Naf Magic which didn't do a lot to be honest.

 

[Peanot]

Hi, I used the magnitude on my WB mare who is exciteable and stressy and although she has the ability to move very well and do a gorgeous dressage test, her spookiness lets us down. I wasn`t sure if the magnitude was working so I stopped using it as I ran out. Well, she has gone worse over the last couple of months so perhaps it was working! Well as I said I wasnt definatley sure so I bought So-kalm and she has been on it for about 3 weeks and TBH I havent noticed any difference. I took her to a dressage test after feeding an extra dose to her 2 hrs previous and it didnt make any difference. She was still spooky and we ended up with 60%. Previously 2 weeks before, she was on a good day and we got 66.5% in a novice and 67.4% in a prelim, what a difference. I`m thinking about trying the nupafeed. Hope this helps.

 

[MegaBeast]

Nupafeed has had amazing results on a couple of horses I know

One was a complete nut case but since being on nupafeed is now sane enough to team chase and interval train in company as well as jump sensibly.

One has suddenly developed the most amazing trot and is less spooky.

However doesn't work on all.

Have been giving my mare magnitude for a couple of weeks now but unsure yet as to whether or not it's working.

Seems to be a matter of experimenting with different ones.

Equistro Equiliser is good on some as well!