Not bonding with new horse

Kat

Well-Known Member
Joined
25 January 2008
Messages
13,164
Location
Derbyshire
Visit site
Take the pressure off yourself, you can't force a bond and fretting about it will make matters worse not better.

This horse doesn't have to be your next horse of a lifetime. If you don't gel you can sell and try again. But don't raise your expectations of the bond being like something out of a pony book, realistically you want a horse who makes you smile when it puts its head over the stable door, not all the fiction for preteen girls.

It is really difficult to follow an amazing horse and sometimes it is better not to try but to get a project/short term horse to have fun with to tide you over and keep you going like that until you find your special horse (which might actually be that project horse anyway). There is no shame in buying a horse and selling on, it isn't an admission of failure or letting the horse down, most of us need people to sell nice horses so that there are nice horses out there to buy. Unless they bred the horse themselves everyone's horse of a lifetime was someone else's not quite right horse or not right now horse.

Why not look at making this horse into a good citizen that can be sold on for at least as much as you paid, treat it as part hobby part job and see how you get on. If you still aren't loving the horse when you have had it six months have a look at what else you could buy if you sold up. Maybe even write an advert for your horse. Then see how you feel, see if you want to give it another six months or sell and keep going like that. You will either find that you have fallen in love with this horse or you will give yourself permission to sell and buy something else.

The other thing to think quite hard about is whether you really love doing the groundwork with a youngster or whether if you can only afford one horse you would be better getting one that you can ride straight away, it is much easier to love a horse that you are having fun riding than one that is a lot of work for very little return.
 

Muddywellies

Well-Known Member
Joined
22 July 2007
Messages
1,774
Visit site
Another modern idea is 'instant results'. So many people want things 'now' without appreciating some things can take a lifetime to achieve. I'm guessing you probably had your old horse a long time? It's truly impossible to achieve any sort of relationship with anything after 8 weeks. If you actually don't like the horse, then sell him on. If you do, then just lower your expectations and accept him for what he is, go with the flow and see where life takes you both.
 

LEC

Opinions are like bum holes, everyone has one.
Joined
22 July 2005
Messages
11,220
Visit site
I don't know any 2/3yo I think is particularly wonderful. I limit my interaction with them on purpose so they can just be horses and they are untrained apart from the essentials so I don't spend much time with them etc and I try to avoid feeding them much so they don't even look at me as the provider!

There is a nice piece of science now to say the magical bond that humans expect doesn't exist with horses and horses are just as fine with strangers. This isn't quite my experience as depends on the human and their behaviour around horses (some people alarm them), but mine are not fussy who looks after them and who sees them on a daily basis.

A lot of my horses get turned away for various reasons usually injury and I find it interesting that the longer they are turned away, the less they interact with humans. When I first turn them away they will be all over you when you check them. If you don't feed treats, as the weeks go on they don't care and can be barely bothered to look up.

We put so much idea into this idea of a magical bond but it really doesn't exist. I have interacted with thousands of horses over the years and some I get on better with than their owner just because I communicate with them in a way they can deal with - I am calm, never in their face, strict and very clear about my expectations. Its helpful if you like the horse as well.
 

ILuvCowparsely

Well-Known Member
Joined
5 April 2010
Messages
14,683
Visit site
I lost my horse of a lifetime about 8 years ago and took a break from horses until now.
I just bought a 2 yo around 2 months ago but am struggling to bond with him. I spend time grooming, leading him etc but it only seems to make me feel the loss of my old horse all the more. I’m just not attached or bonding with the new guy. Do you think it’s just a matter of time, because he’s not rideable yet so we don’t have that relationship or if I don’t feel it now maybe I never will?
Hey I am in my 5th Year after I lost my mare of a lifetime. I can honestly say, even though I had broken humerus and could not ride her ( off my boy) then months off then then she fell on the road and gave me shoulder dislocation. (accident) It took me 3. 1.2 years before I could admit out loud and inside I love her. It takes time, comparisons, painful memories, missing your old horse takes time to bond.
 

AmyMay

Situation normal
Joined
1 July 2004
Messages
66,617
Location
South
Visit site
Sorry to be clear I mean bonding as in how I feel about him. I’m not attached at all and he is supposed to be the horse I keep for life. I’m not sure if it’s his personality - there’s nothing bad in it but he’s fairly stand offish, or me just not feeling it.
Its important to me to have that feeling as it’s a big time and money commitment for something I don’t adore

I think two months is also a short time. However being attached to him is not the end of the world. Focus on turning him into a nice horse, with no expectation of ‘attachment’ and then sell him as a four year old.
 

ILuvCowparsely

Well-Known Member
Joined
5 April 2010
Messages
14,683
Visit site
I lost my horse of a lifetime about 8 years ago and took a break from horses until now.
I just bought a 2 yo around 2 months ago but am struggling to bond with him. I spend time grooming, leading him etc but it only seems to make me feel the loss of my old horse all the more. I’m just not attached or bonding with the new guy. Do you think it’s just a matter of time, because he’s not rideable yet so we don’t have that relationship or if I don’t feel it now maybe I never will?


You wait, once you start experience affection from him by the breaking in time and riding , it will come. My mare was diagnosed with mild navicular in August along with a collateral ligament injury, was box rested 2 weeks then walking in hand. The her vest slipped over her head in the field, and when catching her in she was hobbling a bit. Scans showed check ligament injury 3 - 6 months off. Normally a stress head, she has been amazing on box rest, just like my late mare. out loud I LOVE HER TO PIECES.

Despite her being a donut and spooky. Grooming alone wont be enough. TIME will help don't rush it.
 

cumbriamax

Well-Known Member
Joined
29 August 2010
Messages
761
Location
cumbria - middle of no-where
Visit site
Are you thinking that you might struggle to bond with any horse at the moment or do you think he isn't for you?

I've a few youngsters ( fell pony) and one pony just isn't as personable as the others but he came straight off the fell so is very independent. Like others have said it might just take time.
 

TPO

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 November 2008
Messages
9,913
Location
Kinross
Visit site
I lost my "one in a million" June 2010. I havent felt the same way about any of the horses that I've owned since. Dont get me wrong I've loved all my horses but not in the same way that I felt about TPO.

I think you need to stop trying to replicate a lifetime of experiences and memories within two months with a youngster.

I bought a 2yr old, 6yrs ago now, and it is totally different having a youngster compared to buying a riding horse that you can crack on with.
 

Littlebear

Well-Known Member
Joined
27 November 2017
Messages
676
Visit site
Another one here that lost their 'horse of a lifetime' then has never truly felt that bond again with anything else. It takes away something from you when you suffer that kind of devastating loss and almost makes you more numb to anything else.
I have had several horses since and haven't really ever felt the same, so i bred one as i felt that would be the way to get that attachment back again and in a way it does but it comes over many years, with the ups and downs and although a 2yr old is limited in what you can do age 3 is another ball game, you will be long reining, introducing tack and getting everything ready for backing, the highs and lows of that and the trust you find in each other will help create that bond you are looking for x
 

HappyHollyDays

Slave to a house cat, 4 yard cats and 2 ponies
Joined
2 November 2013
Messages
13,749
Location
On the edge of the Cotswolds
Visit site
You could be describing exactly what happened to me. My first horse was 6 months old when I bought him and he was and still is my perfect horse but that was in 1978 and we all have to move on. I bought DP on a whim in my 50’s after 25 years off and it was awful. He was 3, I was very rusty and we just didn't get on. He was young, pushy, opinionated and we tolerated each other. 7 years on I love him to pieces and will never ever part with him. What changed? I’m not sure but please give your new horse time.
 
Top