One for the tack gurus - buckle guards on saddles

catkin

Well-Known Member
Joined
14 July 2010
Messages
2,725
Location
South West
Visit site
Sorry if this seems a bit of a daft question - but if you don't know and don't ask you never find out:)

What is the reasoning and mechanics behind the different shapes of buckle guards on short girth-billet saddles? (I know what they DO:D.....)

On my older saddles the buckle guards are long, are attached at the top of the straps by the webbing and cover the whole of the holed bit (I like these - very easy to quickly alter the girth from up-top and seem to allow the girth straps to nestle into place even on rotund natives who can be a bit hard to fit)

A new saddle I have (well, new-to-me, but doubt if it's more than a couple of years old) has small buckle guards threaded onto the leather strap bits themselves. Personally I'm finding this a bit of a faff after the older style - the straps 'fix' the distance so there isn't the 'settling' of the girth and I keep getting the things in the wrong place on the strap so they don't always cover the buckle. (my temporary fix until I get them replaced by the longer versions is to loop 'em onto the spare strap only which is a bit better - until I drop one in the mud of course:))

Is there a reason for this design that I'm missing?
 
Possibly cheaper.

Possibly less bulk.

I know pretty much where my girth will end up, so I have the guards up by about the depth of them, 'cos then they'll be about right when the girth is at the right tension.
 
God, I take them off if they are on the straps. They're infuriating.

Fortunately neither of my current saddles have the second kind. Mine are both attached at the top!
 
God, I take them off if they are on the straps. They're infuriating.

But then you stand the chance of the buckles making holes in the underside of the main flap and I've seen too many damaged that way! :eek: They can make a right mess of them particularly if they're thin flaps to start with so if you treasure your saddles please always use buckle guards.
 
Top