Ereiam_jh
Well-Known Member
What is the ordinary English meaning of 'to hunt'.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Question #2 for LACS
- Thread starter Ereiam_jh
- Start date
allijudd
Well-Known Member
At the moment I think it depends on what day it is! LOL
LACS
Well-Known Member
Let me answer by illustration: I think stag hunting is hunting. You know, the activity which you concede is cruel yet would allow under the Giles Anti-Cruelty Act.
Ereiam_jh
Well-Known Member
What about searching?
You completely misunderstand the nature of the law I am proposing, it wouldn't be up to me wether stag hunting was allowed under the act. It would be up to the courts to decide whether or not it was cruel.
You completely misunderstand the nature of the law I am proposing, it wouldn't be up to me wether stag hunting was allowed under the act. It would be up to the courts to decide whether or not it was cruel.
Ereiam_jh
Well-Known Member
What about dispersing? Is that hunting?
How about flushing an animal out? The law says that is exempt hunting, is it even hunting in your view?
How about flushing an animal out? The law says that is exempt hunting, is it even hunting in your view?
LACS
Well-Known Member
"It would be up to the courts to decide whether or not it was cruel."
And in exactly the same way it's up to the courts to decide whether an activity is hunting or not. Thank you.
And in exactly the same way it's up to the courts to decide whether an activity is hunting or not. Thank you.
Ereiam_jh
Well-Known Member
No it's not. It's up to them to decide whether something is flushing out. The law defines flushing out as hunting, even though we agree in reality it isn't.
Ereiam_jh
Well-Known Member
You actuall beleive it's legal to deliberately flush out mammals with a pack of dogs. Do you know what you are talking about?
I thought the limit was two.
I thought the limit was two.
LACS
Well-Known Member
I refer you to my latest reply on the thread "Question for LACS".
Ereiam_jh
Well-Known Member
Can I legally chase deer with dogs?
LACS
Well-Known Member
Hunting with dogs is illegal unless one of the exemptions has been satisfied. It's really very simple.
Ereiam_jh
Well-Known Member
Is it legall to flush out a deer from cover with say twenty dogs?
The ;law says flushing out is hunting?
What is your understanding of the word hunt?
The ;law says flushing out is hunting?
What is your understanding of the word hunt?
Hercules
Well-Known Member
Surely AA is not satisfying the criteria set for the exempt form of hunting that is classed as flushing.
Why hasn't he been prosecuted?
Why hasn't he been prosecuted?
Ereiam_jh
Well-Known Member
I use four dogs, don't shoot the deer.
I've even attempted to flush out deer at the LACS sanctury, without permission not to protect crops while being videoed by twenty hunt monitors.
There does seem to be something a little awry with this law.
I've even attempted to flush out deer at the LACS sanctury, without permission not to protect crops while being videoed by twenty hunt monitors.
There does seem to be something a little awry with this law.