response to yesterdays huge thread...

Status
Not open for further replies.
Fantasy world: I can't quote but yes I agree, people should think long and hard before taking on a rescue or welfare case, but actually this is the case with ANY horse and as some have said we do not have the luxury of a crystal ball! Just because we sometimes fail to turn a horse around it is not always because we are lacking in ability, sometimes it is.

My story now (as brief as I can) as a background I will tell you that I had taken on 5 horses prior to this that had issues, my first was a pony at the age of 13 I was very lucky to have the support of a large yard and about 6 instructors based at the yard, when he arrived he had a cut up mouth, spur cuts on his side, and reared on the lunge when he saw the whip, this was just the start, with love and perseverence he came through. Later in life I took on ebony, not a welfare case, never beaten, but one hell of a challenge, took me a couple of years to sort her out, 3 beaten neglected ponies of one of the most horrible dealers... All three came around with love and gentleness, one cob who is owned by a forum member, again beaten and treated badly by a gypsy who is notorious, took ages with some of her quirks. I then got offered a welsh cob x appy, many methods had failed her, she'd been to lots of nh clinics, she was unridable, and having seen her under saddle we nicknamed her the killer! On the ground she was great to handle, a bit nervy though and her flight instinct was strong as was her fight, she was aggressive to other horses, my mare being the only one who could put her in her place, in the school she would shake from head to toe, gallop around, sweat till it was running off her. I worked at first on the ground, and then we worked on the school, it became a safer 'fun' and calm place, she had all her checks done, and despite a history of muscle wastage she had the all clear, we started lightly, little 15 min hacks with no pressure, it was always like sitting on something that was a cross between a coiled spring and a ice sculpture that could fracture and smash at any point, but she would try so very hard, and eventually calmed. We then put her in the school, no aggression had been displayed, all nerves gone from that environment, over a few days tack was introduced and then a friend was going to get on her so I could stay with her head and talk her through it. We were going to do 10 mins max in walk and a few strides of trot (she had begun cantering on hacks by this point). I have never stood next to a bomb when it explodes but I figure it's the same thing!!! The first sign was that saliva started running from her mouth then the first tack was to literally turn her head, bare her teeth and try and rip her rider off her back by the leg!!! We continued, our only intention from that point was to get her to calm, walk two strides, stand, have a pat and then get off, the age old end on a good note!!! We did not want this mare to believe she could scare someone off her back. Whilst trying to rip her rider off she then reared (head still) twisted around!!! Came down and bucked so bleeding high! Rider sat it out, she stood shocked, I think that her tactic hadn't worked, she kind of shocked herself out of it for a minute, we said 'right, all we will do is ask her to stand her calm for about 10 secs stroke her, talk nicely and then get off, all we were looking for was SOMETHING!!! Some evidence of willingness, again, I have seen a horse walk backwards but this one ran! Straight for the fence, reared and spun trying to throw the rider onto the fence. I have never had such a sinking feeling watching this horse it really felt like there was nothing in her worth saving, she was a sweetie and great to handle, but even if I fixed her to ride I could not sell her on to be ridden having seen what I saw that day. Both the rider and I have many years experience, we popped the girl into the field, and promptly shared a load of vodka and thrashed out my options, I was supposed to be 'last chance saloon' for this one but she was beyond us. I had at that point two choices, not at all my style but she challenged eveyway of thinking that I had, choice one, shoot her. Choice 2 pay for two weeks at a braking yard, with someone I respect, but also someone who would win a fight with her if anyone could, he was an old school tough man. It was not an approach I'd ever had to consider but there was so much anger in this mare, I didn't know what to do. After 2 weeks we would have assessed any progress and considered if continuation was worth it. But I still thought about what I had witnessed, and doubted whether I could guarantee that she would remain rideable for someone in the future. I made the decision to pts. There is a lovely young girl at my yard, she has an older friend with her own land and stables, who begged me to let her have the mare, I really struggled with this, but I knew the woman, she would have kept madam for all her life as a field ornament if that's what it came to. She had absolutely fallen for her, she also did a lot of parelli, and whilst I did not, I knew the basics and enough to spot that this mare had done lots too. The woman would have played the games with her, and loved her. The absolute hardest decision I made, But I sold her to the woman for a pound, the bill of sale including a full disclosure and a recxomendation that she should not be ridden or bred from in my opinion. Much has happened with this mare since I sold her, she went to a show and bolted down the main road, she was luckily safe and the owner admits it was a huge wake up call as to the severity of her issues (that was about 3yrs ago). She is now loving xc, hacking, weekly lessons, parelli clinics, her field with her companion, and her new family. It came to light that her first owner hated her, she was a really sharp youngster, she fell through a conservatory in that home, whilst she did parelli, she was also thrown into many other nh clinics, all with different approaches. Poor girl just fell apart. I am so lucky it turned out well for her and glad that I didn't pts, but most of all I am glad that I knew the woman who took her on, believe me, she would not have gone to anyone else, she would have died that week and I would not have second guessed my decision for without the woman it would have been the right one.

Once again op x you did do the right thing x

And to those 3 that made crass and inappropriate comments on here. Absolute shame on you!! I only hope that someone does not offer such insensitive words of naive and narrow minded, ill timed and ill judged words of wisdom to you when you lose your horses
 
It's sad that a thread that must have been so agonisingly painful to start is now descending into more accusations by a pathetic few who believe they know better.

Have some sympathy for the OP for goodness sake. Even if you think she was wrong she did what she BELIEVED was right.. she did her best and that's all you can ask of anyone. She loved the pony, she had been down many roads to find a way for him and none of them worked. Apparently he wasn't in the best of health and remained fearful to a degree. Have you any idea what it is like to live in a constant state of fear? How could she live with herself if she had passed him to someone else? The chances were it would have been the beginning of the downward spiral for the pony so surely PTS whilst he was happy and loved has to be the better option?

And then of course someone has to accuse her of troll posting..... people (some of you) look deep inside yourself and see if you can find just a gram or two of compassion. No matter what your personal take on the situation, this poor lady has lost her much loved pony. Try being nice instead of dropping in the snide and cruel comments. It might well make you a better person.
 
Having read both threads all the way through, I find it unbelievable that this thread is now being turned into a slanging match. Why cant you leave things be now, you have heard both sides of the story and made your conclusions, nothing further can be gained from continuing to debate the ins and outs. At the end of the day whatever you think it was the owners decision and nothing to do with us.
 
It's sad that a thread that must have been so agonisingly painful to start is now descending into more accusations by a pathetic few who believe they know better.

Have some sympathy for the OP for goodness sake. Even if you think she was wrong she did what she BELIEVED was right.. she did her best and that's all you can ask of anyone. She loved the pony, she had been down many roads to find a way for him and none of them worked. Apparently he wasn't in the best of health and remained fearful to a degree. Have you any idea what it is like to live in a constant state of fear? How could she live with herself if she had passed him to someone else? The chances were it would have been the beginning of the downward spiral for the pony so surely PTS whilst he was happy and loved has to be the better option?

And then of course someone has to accuse her of troll posting..... people (some of you) look deep inside yourself and see if you can find just a [U/]SIZE="6"]gram or two of compassion[/SIZE][/U]. No matter what your personal take on the situation, this poor lady has lost her much loved pony. Try being nice instead of dropping in the snide and cruel comments. It might well make you a better person.


Wow, I really should read things properly :rolleyes:
 
A brave decision to come on here and defend yourself and a brave and tough decision to put your horse to sleep.

You did what you thought was best and no one has the right to question you on that.

x
 
Ladyinred, I don't think it has to do with compassion, it's just that some people will always think they know better and feel that they have to express that thought, regardless of the circumstances. Reining yourself in is a difficult skill to master for some!
 
I wish that some people had shown enough compassion for Op to keep their opinions for another thread, and let this thread be populated by those who want to offer her some comfort and support. It's not compulsory to post. There is a real person experiencing real heartache behind this thread.
 
It's sad that a thread that must have been so agonisingly painful to start is now descending into more accusations by a pathetic few who believe they know better.

Have some sympathy for the OP for goodness sake. Even if you think she was wrong she did what she BELIEVED was right.. she did her best and that's all you can ask of anyone. She loved the pony, she had been down many roads to find a way for him and none of them worked. Apparently he wasn't in the best of health and remained fearful to a degree. Have you any idea what it is like to live in a constant state of fear? How could she live with herself if she had passed him to someone else? The chances were it would have been the beginning of the downward spiral for the pony so surely PTS whilst he was happy and loved has to be the better option?

And then of course someone has to accuse her of troll posting..... people (some of you) look deep inside yourself and see if you can find just a gram or two of compassion. No matter what your personal take on the situation, this poor lady has lost her much loved pony. Try being nice instead of dropping in the snide and cruel comments. It might well make you a better person.

Whilst I agree with your sentiments, the accusation of Troll was actually directed at the OP of the OTHER thread, MV22 actually posted here in SUPPORT of Exhausted :)
 
I did not comment on previous thread and read alot but not all of the thread so don't know what happened in the end.

I don't know either poster from Adam but it's funny how some people choose to believe this one rather than the previous poster - you don't know 'Exhausted' isn't just another troll or a liar or fantasist any more than the original OP.

Personally I think people choose to believe what they want to believe to affirm their own feelings on the subject.

But isn't that a truism of life in an internet forum? Participating in something as bizarre as communicating without being face-to-face or ever having met the people with whom you are communicating requires a leap of faith of some description.

BTW, I'm not so sure it's as simple as just "believing what you want to believe" . . . communication between human beings (even over a medium as potentially sterile as the interweb) is much more complex and subtle than that.

You are quite right that either of these two people could be lying/fantasizing/telling fairy tales . . . but most people aren't actually compulsive liars, fantasists or trolls - so I suspect what we read was a single issue told from two very different viewpoints . . . in which case I (and some others it seems) will tend to give more credence to "the horse's mouth" (pardon the pun).

My interpretation of "that" thread is that what put people's backs up was that the OP saw fit to opine publicly on an issue that was, essentially, none of her business. Even if she was right, she had no business airing another person's dirty laundry in such a public way, without his/her consent. Call me old-fashioned, but to me it's just so very wrong. Beyond rude and I guess could be construed as slanderous? (I'm sure the legal eagles on here will put me straight either way).

As for this thread - I think it's very sad that it has degenerated once again into who's right and who's wrong. The OP has given her side of the story - from what she wrote I think she seems like a rational human being (because that is all I have to go on) and I find it unutterably sad that she should feel the need to justify herself at such an emotionally difficult time. You'd have to have a heart of stone not to accede that, whether or not her decision was the right one - and I don't know because I don't know her or the pony, etc. - making such a decision and having it carried out must be monumentally difficult . . . so . . .

Exhausted - I'm so sorry for your loss . . . and for the added drama surrounding your decision (which was, in my view, totally unnecessary and in fact cruel) . . . best of luck with your old boy (and if I were you I would move yards).

P
 
I wish that some people had shown enough compassion for Op to keep their opinions for another thread, and let this thread be populated by those who want to offer her some comfort and support. It's not compulsory to post. There is a real person experiencing real heartache behind this thread.

^^^^^^^^^
This
 
You are taking my comments out of context sheesh.......
I said that the first horses I mentioned were not being discussed in my post as that was another matter. Here I was discussing the average horse, owned by the average owner. The debates on over breeding, auction/sale horses and breeding for meat is another subject for another day. I did not say that any one horse has more of a right to live over another.
I find the horse meat trade deplorable and I am ashamed with the over production of horses and ponies, many of which go for meat for one animal or another. However that is a debate for another day and not what I was trying to discuss here.
I hope that alleviates your confusion.

But FW, what happens when you are the average owner on the average yard with the non average horse?

As I said before I have a 17yo horse who I have had since weaning. Looking at him you would think that he is perfectly healthy (he is physically, been vet checked to the nth degree) He's always been the silly, spooky type but his problem is that he takes it to extremes that mean he can be dangerous because when he loses the plot, he really does lose it. People who see him slopping along beside me or falling asleep while his tail is brushed out (his very favourite thing in the whole world :D) raise eyebrows because he is led with a rope over his nose and all gates are kept shut while he is on the yard. What they forget or don't know (and how would they? On that yard nobody else was allowed handle him - I even had to put in writing that if he had an accident in the field that he was to be left in there until the vet or I arrived because that was just the type of situation that could cause him to flip and somebody would be hurt) is just how much of a liability he can be.

In the past if something scared him in hand he would pull loose, than hammer flat out up and down in blind panic going into people, walls, fences and vehicles. No malice, he just didn't see them. With a rope over his nose you could hold him and he would calm down quickly because he trusts me. I can be calm because I know I've got him and a potentially nasty incident is averted. Under saddle he is very talented, good with traffic etc as long as the rider can stay calm - I mean to almost zen like standards - when something scares him. Otherwise he would go straight up and over. Sadly, mainly due to some very nasty experiences with him I'm not a zen like rider so he was retired at 10. Most people who are good enough to handle him don't want to ride him - he's not that talented...but many with a little bit of knowledge think they can and that's when it all goes south. The other issue is whether it was my legal liability or not is that I didn't want to see anybody hurt. I had professional help, nor am I a novice. Of course I can look back and see what I could have done differently and where I got things wrong but would that have changed his basic personality? It's telling that my vet would have supported PTS at any time in the past 10 years but even if they didn't I would have made what I thought was the best decision for my horse at the time.

Luckily I'm in a financial position that I can afford to keep him and my old boy in retirement and that I was able to find a suitable place to do it safely but I'm very aware that if I can't then I will PTS - not without heartache but because I do love him dearly and will not take the chance that he will find that one home in a thousand that can and wants to cope with him.

From another POV - how many people would be happy to have a dangerous/difficult horse on a yard with them? If it was you, your kids, your dog or your vehicle being damaged on a regular basis? Horses like that get thrown off yards regularly (TBF I can understand why, they are a liability) or slapped and shouted at by random people who are scared of them which tends to make matters worse.

It's not as easy to keep them well and happy as you are making out. Sometimes the best for them is PTS IMHO and it isn't the easy option. The easy option( for a person) is waving off the trailer while convincing yourself that it'll all be fine...

How would you feel a year down the line when you were contacted by someone who had bought them at the sales and the passport showed they had had multiple homes in a short period. It happens and they are the lucky ones in a very odd way.Somebody cares enough to try and investigate their history.
 
Last edited:
I don't like the way that this thread is turning so... Hoping I will be able to resist posting on here again. I think that being so closely linked to the previous thread had caused a number of issues to 'tumble' into this on, without need. For any other topics: civil rights of horses, criteria for pts, health and safety, experience and knowledge, and general sparing or offensive insensitive attitudes. Could we not discuss them on this thread, I am not speculating on who is right and who is wrong, I'm pig sick of people using other peoples grief as an excuse to stir up trouble and conflict and that goes for some of the posters on this thread as well as the other. You want to discuss those topics then show som maturity and compassion and create another thread for your debate and squabble. Op, you know u can pm me if u need a shoulder
 
I did not comment on previous thread and read alot but not all of the thread so don't know what happened in the end.

I don't know either poster from Adam but it's funny how some people choose to believe this one rather than the previous poster - you don't know 'Exhausted' isn't just another troll or a liar or fantasist any more than the original OP.

Personally I think people choose to believe what they want to believe to affirm their own feelings on the subject.

I actually think that both are telling the truth from their perspective. However, the owner is the one who has ALL the facts. Only she knows them. I believe that both people in this case are decent and genuine.
 
I don't like the way that this thread is turning so... Hoping I will be able to resist posting on here again. I think that being so closely linked to the previous thread had caused a number of issues to 'tumble' into this on, without need. For any other topics: civil rights of horses, criteria for pts, health and safety, experience and knowledge, and general sparing or offensive insensitive attitudes. Could we not discuss them on this thread, I am not speculating on who is right and who is wrong, I'm pig sick of people using other peoples grief as an excuse to stir up trouble and conflict and that goes for some of the posters on this thread as well as the other. You want to discuss those topics then show som maturity and compassion and create another thread for your debate and squabble. Op, you know u can pm me if u need a shoulder

Very well said QB. I think this thread has become tawdry, childish and downright mean . . . when it should simply have been a place of comfort for Exhausted.

I love HHO, most of the time, but this thread - and the other one - have actually left a really nasty taste in my mouth.

FWIW, I am thinking of you Exhausted and wishing you some peace.

P
 
As Stacie is currently reading this thread, let's hope she's preparing to offer exhausted some words of condolence at this sad time.
 
Exhausted I didn't read the original thread as I could guess the type of post it would be from the silly and emotive title but I have read your post and I just wanted to add my thoughts that I think you have done exactly the right thing and acted responsibly and with love and care.
 
It looks like the judgemental and self elevated people are back in force...

I don't believe that people should of commented on this post unless they were in support of the decision made. At the end of the day we don't know this person, or the horse in question... I think people had their chance yesterday. There is no need to turn this post in to something it isn't nor draw attention to your own self importance.

I will stand by my original comment on the original post, "it was a shame some of the people on here couldn't be PTS with their judgemental and self elevated opinions"
 
As Stacie is currently reading this thread, let's hope she's preparing to offer exhausted some words of condolence at this sad time.

Please stop. This does nothing but fan the flames and reduces this thread to further unnecessary sniping. What Stacie says or does is up to her . . . just as what Exhausted did with her pony was up to her.

It's done. All that's left is to offer our support to Exhausted who lost a dear friend yesterday. Jumping on Stacie again serves no purpose. When is enough enough?

P
 
I suppose the one good thing that has come from these threads is that a few people have said that they opened their eyes to the dangers of passing on some horses...

Exhausted,

I hope you're ok. x
 
Please stop. This does nothing but fan the flames and reduces this thread to further unnecessary sniping. What Stacie says or does is up to her . . . just as what Exhausted did with her pony was up to her.

It's done. All that's left is to offer our support to Exhausted who lost a dear friend yesterday. Jumping on Stacie again serves no purpose. When is enough enough?

P

Absolutely agree PolarSkye...

People just don't know when to shut their massive gobs! Why do some people feed off complete bitchiness, do you get a kick out of it or something... get a life for god's sake!
 
Please stop. This does nothing but fan the flames and reduces this thread to further unnecessary sniping. What Stacie says or does is up to her . . . just as what Exhausted did with her pony was up to her.

It's done. All that's left is to offer our support to Exhausted who lost a dear friend yesterday. Jumping on Stacie again serves no purpose. When is enough enough?

P

Well said!
 
I wasnt going to write a response as i do not want this to turn into another battle thread like the last one, which yes i started.

I offer my sincere condolences to what the OP has had to go through, losing an animal is one of the most gut wrenching feelings in the world like im sure you all are fully aware. I pulically appologized yesterday for the way i worded my first post, and for the things id said which were agianst the OP of this thread but i will still stand by my view. That may make me, stubborn, selfish, childish, heartless or what ever else you would like to call me but that is my view and we are all intitled to our own opinions, whether they be right or wrong, this view is right to me. I know what i know and i know what i have seen. I will not comment any further towards the OP or her pony, because quite frankly she is having to cope with enough as it is right now, but i will applaud her for coming on here and writing a very nice story of the ponys life. It shouldnt have had to come to this, one forum member letting off steam and typing before she speaks has led to much controversy, name calling, cattyness and a few PM's!

Judge and decide of me what you will, we are all human and its human nature to make mistakes. For mine, i am sorry.
 
Best of luck in a difficult time with your boy, and am so sorry on behalf of everyone on the forum.. It must be a horrid thing to go through and the last thing you want/need is somebody starting up a thread discussing whether your actions are right or wrong- thats partly what puts me off ever keeping my boy at yard- I dread to think about some of the comments to the many near-misses etc I have had in the past... I mean it's just part of horse ownership- got to take the rough with the smooth... All the best for the future
Abbeyandapache xxxxxxx
 
Absolutely agree PolarSkye...

People just don't know when to shut their massive gobs! Why do some people feed off complete bitchiness, do you get a kick out of it or something... get a life for god's sake!

Wow. Absolutely no need to be quite so offensive.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top