Returning a horse not fit for purpose

This is an interesting thread from which many of us have learnt things!

My one worry is that I am not so sure "sold as seen" can be used as a get out clause, at least by a professional seller. There is such a thing as misrepresentation and can mental health problems in a horse really "be seen"? Are they necessarily going to be seen from a brief trial and an external examination, even by a vet?

Quote….

Misrepresentation
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This article is about a legal term. For the sociological one, see Misrepresentation (sociology).
Misrepresentation is a concept in the contract law of England and some other Commonwealth countries, referring to a false statement of fact made by one party to another party, which has the effect of inducing that party into the contract. For example, under certain circumstances, false statements or promises made by a seller of goods regarding the quality or nature of the product that the seller has may constitute misrepresentation. A finding of misrepresentation allows for a remedy of rescission and sometimes damages depending on the type of misrepresentation.[citation needed]

According to the judgment in the English case Gordon v Selico (1986) 18 HLR 219 it is possible to make a misrepresentation either by words or by conduct, although not everything said or done is capable of constituting a misrepresentation. Generally, statements of opinion or intention are not statements of fact in the context of misrepresentation.[1] If one party claims specialist knowledge on the topic discussed, then it is more likely for the courts to hold a statement of opinion by that party as a statement of fact.[2]


The courts are not very sympathetic when sellers impose a get out clause clearly intended to protect themselves.
 
I bought my horse from a local dealer who promised if my horse wasn't as sold, quiet and suitable for all the family, she would stand by it. When the horse turned out to be bolshy, impossible to tie up, had no brakes etc we asked her to take him back. Thats when things got nasty. Long story short, I've had him 17 years and hes my best friend. Hes still on occasion bolshy etc but I bought a control halter and learnt as much as I could about natural horsemanship, little by little we got there. Hope you find a solution.
 
Thank you for the update. I am pleased you got a result of sorts. Your friend knew exactly what she was buying and looking at it from an outsiders perspective I think you both (you and Lolli) got the best possible outcome.
 
I have a haffy, if you allow them an inch they will take a mile and very very quickly spiral out of control and turn into bolshy, monsters! Groundwork, groundwork and more groundwork, don't let them into your space no matter how innocuous it may seem, the odd nuzzle becomes a head butt next time. Don't let them stop for a poo, stop for a look at the view, they are taking control, you have to be in control at all times. . She'll teach you to be very forward thinking, get professional help if you can't face it alone, I think she's adapting to a new life and she needs very clear instructions on what is expected of her.
 
Just come across this old thread of mine and wanted to update anyone that commented.
My friend bought the mare of me in the end as she said she felt sorry for her to be passed about again or go back to the trekking center. She tried to completly restart her using natural horsemanship. Varying degrees of success. She did manage to sort out some issues but even she had to admit defeat in the end that she would ever be a rideable horse. She still has the mare, lucky girl she's got a home for life where she will never be ridden although she has recently started doing some work with her to break her to driving which seems to be more acceptable to the mare than being ridden. Thanks everyone for your past advice
 
Hi no xray although I did have someone check her back to start with. She's happy in the field, she's just very stubborn and knows she can get away with it I think. Living her best life being a pet
 
Hi no xray although I did have someone check her back to start with. She's happy in the field, she's just very stubborn and knows she can get away with it I think. Living her best life being a pet


Unfortunately even vets don't have x-ray eyes. Can I ask if you bought her in Yorkshire? If so, I think I might have viewed the horse when she was for sale.
 
Top