Same make saddle for jumping and dressage?

[FabioandFreddy]

Just a pondering.....have had the saddler out and Albion K2 was the best suit jump for me and Fabio. However, will be looking for a new dressage saddle in the not too distant future. As a rule of thumb, if a certain brand jump saddle suits the horse then is it likely the dressage will too? I'll get the saddler out when i come to look but just interested if this would be likely or not?

 

[ellie_e]

I had an Albion K2 jump saddle which was fitted by a saddler, bought the same saddle dressage cut online and had the saddler fit it, no probs at all, in fact the dressage saddle I bought online fits better!

 

[Aurorab]

I have two Sue Carsons both fitted by a qualified saddle fitter. one dressage -love it & fits horse perfectly! The other is a jump saddle & I hate it!! Doesn't fit her quite right & has to have a pad. Can't wait to save up & get a new one!!
The jump I bought in a hurry as my mare was lame in her old Pessoa jump saddle. She is at least sound in the new one...!