The pony in the rug has white hooves on the rear with black shading, I would get a blown up picture of the hooves and compare stripes as I do not think they alter.
Looks like the same pony to me. As others have said the head looks similaron both and is has a white sock on his hind leg just visible at the bottom of the boots its wearing
Her previous owner is currently on holiday but I am hoping she will have some other pictures. The dealer has got away scot free with this because she was selling on behalf of a client. I am facing said client in court on Monday. Makes me sick, the main reason I bought from a dealer was because I thought I would have more comeback and support. So beware if you are considering buying from a dealer, you may end up with no more rights than you would have with a private sale! I have had nothing but heartache and stress for the past 10 months so am really hoping for a positive outcome.