EQUIDAE
Well-Known Member
In response to both of these - I didn't want to be so rude as to call her a fat biffer as she wasn't, but she was definitely on the heavier side and likely over 20%.
Show makes overweight riders dismount
- Thread starter only_me
- Start date
In response to both of these - I didn't want to be so rude as to call her a fat biffer as she wasn't, but she was definitely on the heavier side and likely over 20%.
Nancykitt
Well-Known Member
Probably more about weight than height? - in which case yes, I would share your concern.
It's got me thinking about the whole question of proportion too. I once knew a woman who bought a weanling 'likely to make 15.2'. She was 4ft 10 with short legs so would probably have looked quite small on a 15.2 - but the horse actually made 17hh and I have to say that not only did they look a little 'wrong' but the position of her legs would surely have affected leg aids? Having said that, they did seem to enjoy hacking out together so it's not really fair of me to criticise.
EQUIDAE
Well-Known Member
Being only 5ft1 myself - it is difficult to find the 'buttons' on a horse that has been trained by a tall person. My new 16h1 has taken a few weeks to get used to.
Nancykitt
Well-Known Member
Very interesting - my current pony (the one I felt I 'clicked' with instantly the first time I rode him) was trained by a short person, just like me.
My Connie had previously been schooled by a very tall rider and it took ages for me to learn how to get him to respond to certain things.
So it's hard for me to understand how riders who are clearly much too tall for small ponies can communicate clearly to them. Obviously not as much of a welfare issue as small ponies with heavy adults on board, but interesting nevertheless.
ester
Not slacking multitasking
no, I specifically quoted you on your comment about leg length, which I thought a bit odd.
You also only initially mentioned the riders height, which when we weren't talking a 12.2 also seemed a bit strange.
If you had said I found out an adult likely close to 20% was going to ride so I declined to sell that would have made a lot more sense rather than her height.
Last edited:
HiPo'sHuman
Well-Known Member
I was told that my highland was overweight by a judge last month and she came last in her class. She's bigger than ideal but not massive, she's backed now so that'll help to slim her down. Good to see some judges are taking on board the health and subsequent longevity of working life for our beloved ponies.
Wagtail
Horse servant
Bloody hell, that's disgusting. Poor ponies.
Wagtail
Horse servant
I'm afraid I would have stepped in and said something. There would have been a scene.
EmmasMummy
Well-Known Member
I had someone come to ride my Sec A who tole me she was under a certain weight - should have been the same as the girl who backed him and she wasn't hugely tall. Pony clearly could tell otherwise and girls arse touched the saddle he took 2 steps back and dumped her on her arse.
ycbm
Overwhelmed
This. I think people are also forgetting, or never being told, that a weight over 1.5lbs per square inch over a sustained time is considered harmful. That means that a rider who is only ten stone needs well over ninety square inches of well fitting saddle in contact with the horse's back to spread the weight.
It's impossible to find a saddle which would achieve that and fit the horse for some heavier riders on small/mid horses, and for the biggest riders on anything but the biggest horse on a huge panel saddle.
Going back to the report, it's a great start by this show. Unconnected with weight, I'd like to see the rule for children's ponies be that it can only be warmed up by a child of an appropriate age for the class.
Ddraig_wen
Well-Known Member
I see RoR are now going to disqualify overweight riders : http://www.horseandhound.co.uk/news/ror-disqualify-overweight-riders-shows-602442
DD
Well-Known Member
about time too.