Size and Weight Carrying Power

Orangehorse

Well-Known Member
Joined
25 November 2005
Messages
13,262
Visit site
Found it - the book by Col Goldschmidt published in 1937 by Country Life called An Eye for a Horse.

"For my own riding I do not care for anything over 16 hands, in fact I consider 15.3 the ideal height for a hunter to carry even a great weight and 15 hands for a polo pony. I am 5ft 11" and ride 14st. Much of my hunting ..... was on polo ponies measuring around 15 hands, but our fences, if tricky, are small........
The nearer a horse is to 15 hands the nearer he is likely to approach perfection of conformation..........

Whenever I ask my friends to describe the favourite hunter of their lives the recital of the animal's virtues and prowess generally finishes with 'but he was only 15.2' or 'if he had only been two inches bigger I suppose I could not have afforded to keep him' ............My contention is that it was just the 2 inches in height that made for the compactness and activity which raised the horse above the ordinary."

I take that "riding at 14 stone" is dressed in riding clothes and does not include the saddle.
 

JDChaser

Well-Known Member
Joined
20 August 2009
Messages
1,215
Location
Gloucestershire
Visit site
My friend rides my highland x. She's probably about 14/5 stone, he's only about 15hh and not as chunky as a highland. They are absolutely fine together and he isnt bothered. He will make a fabulous hunter one day.
 

palo1

Well-Known Member
Joined
27 July 2012
Messages
6,361
Visit site
I believe there are excellent conformational reasons for a 15.2 horse to be the 'best' size as this is the size that makes best use of the size of the heart, lungs, stride length and weight carrying mechanics. Above about 15.2 and a horse can start to have engineering compromises but much below that he/she cannot maximise the potential of heart/lungs/stride etc. It is really interesting. :) Obviously a lot of native ponies which are smaller (and I include Arabs in that) have a health/design advantage but then they lose the advantage (for the rider) because of their shorter stride. Having said that, a great many smaller horses can 'out-perform' their size. :)
 
Top