Snaffle or hackamore?

Mousesmom

Member
Joined
24 August 2021
Messages
14
Visit site
I've been riding my mare in a hackamore for about a year now, stumbling upon a bit vs bitless article looks to have led me down a rabbit hole now though. I hear that hackamores are terrible, bruising, broken noses, unclear signals ect and then I also hear snaffles are bad, sensitive mouth nerves, blisters, bruising ect.
I use this hackamore except I swapped out the curb chain for a leather strap 1641178565031.png


She's terrific in the hackamore, I only have to be very, very light for her to listen, neck reining is much better, I can control her at full gallop easily, no head tossing, chewing, fidgeting or anything like that.
In a snaffle she was terrible. She'd chew all day long, head toss and fidget and I couldn't control her at any faster than a trot without pulling her face off. I saw bruising on her bars once, probably due to my hard hands. Her ex owner was my ex trainer and told me that this is normal and how you should do it, I guess I didn't know any better. I wouldn't be surprised if she associates the bit with pain.

I am currently 'training' my little sister, and I have put her horse in a snaffle. Poppit (the horse) doesn't fidget or chew (much) and is very nice and responsive. I have tested her out in other bitless bridles but I find that she is best in her snaffle. Same with my mare except with a hackamore instead, I have tried different bits and bitless bridles but I always found she was best in a hackamore.

Some days I feel like I should have both horses in bits and other days I feel like I should have both horses in bitless bridles. I guess I'm asking if just using what the horses respond best to is the right way to choose their bridle
 

Attachments

  • 1641178410800.png
    1641178410800.png
    44.3 KB · Views: 0

Lyle

Well-Known Member
Joined
23 October 2010
Messages
1,070
Visit site
Have you tried different styles of bitless? I really like the cross under styles, like the Dr Cooks. I jump one of mine up to 1.10m in a cross under and can easily school flatwork. Might be worth exploring.
 

SEL

Well-Known Member
Joined
25 February 2016
Messages
13,782
Location
Buckinghamshire
Visit site
I'm riding one of mine in a hackamore. She has a problem with her soft palate which means she finds a bit very uncomfortable - & I've tried loads. I've also tried other bitless options and this is the one the pony seems to prefer. It's quite a cheap hackamore but now I know she likes it I'll upgrade - you have to learn to ride differently so you aren't putting too much pressure on the nose but like any "control" it's the hands that make the difference.
 

Mousesmom

Member
Joined
24 August 2021
Messages
14
Visit site
Have you tried different styles of bitless? I really like the cross under styles, like the Dr Cooks. I jump one of mine up to 1.10m in a cross under and can easily school flatwork. Might be worth exploring.
I have, she's eventually decided that she wont listen in most of the other ones, she was ok with the cross under ones but I did have problems with it tightening and not releasing though so I stopped. Do you find that with yours? Perhaps it was just the model/brand I was using
 

ILuvCowparsely

Well-Known Member
Joined
5 April 2010
Messages
14,703
Visit site
I've been riding my mare in a hackamore for about a year now, stumbling upon a bit vs bitless article looks to have led me down a rabbit hole now though. I hear that hackamores are terrible, bruising, broken noses, unclear signals ect and then I also hear snaffles are bad, sensitive mouth nerves, blisters, bruising ect.
I use this hackamore except I swapped out the curb chain for a leather strap View attachment 85287


She's terrific in the hackamore, I only have to be very, very light for her to listen, neck reining is much better, I can control her at full gallop easily, no head tossing, chewing, fidgeting or anything like that.
In a snaffle she was terrible. She'd chew all day long, head toss and fidget and I couldn't control her at any faster than a trot without pulling her face off. I saw bruising on her bars once, probably due to my hard hands. Her ex owner was my ex trainer and told me that this is normal and how you should do it, I guess I didn't know any better. I wouldn't be surprised if she associates the bit with pain.

I am currently 'training' my little sister, and I have put her horse in a snaffle. Poppit (the horse) doesn't fidget or chew (much) and is very nice and responsive. I have tested her out in other bitless bridles but I find that she is best in her snaffle. Same with my mare except with a hackamore instead, I have tried different bits and bitless bridles but I always found she was best in a hackamore.

Some days I feel like I should have both horses in bits and other days I feel like I should have both horses in bitless bridles. I guess I'm asking if just using what the horses respond best to is the right way to choose their bridle
a lot of the severity of a bit is in the riders hands - any bit can cause damage in the wrong hands.

I love hackamores never any damage
 
Top