Some feeding advice - if it ain't broke don't fix it? (Long - sorry)

FinkleyAlex

Well-Known Member
Joined
11 October 2006
Messages
1,407
Visit site
Hi all - looking for some advice for my 14.2 PBA ex-lammi who is currently out on loan. I've owned him for eleven years and he got injury-related lammi about six years ago but has been fine since with careful management. He is not a good doer (but not poor either) and under the vets advice has never needed his grazing restricted or a muzzle and is out from 8am-4/5pm all year round. He then comes in and has a large soaked hay-net with small holes overnight. He maintains a nice weight (slightly just on the leaner side which I prefer given his past) and does not need hard-feed as is only in light work. He does have arthritis though and gets a small handful of happy hoof to put his medicine/supplements in at the start of the day. I know happy hoof is controversial due to the molasses but our vet recommended it years ago when he first came down with lammi and it has never triggered him so I'm reluctant to change it if its not causing a problem (and he won't eat other chaff).

I will re-iterate that he has never had a problem in six years following the above management, EXCEPT in February when his loaner had been hospitalised for weeks due to ill-health and the yard took over his feed, increasing it until he was having more than I have ever fed my fit show-jumpers in the past (literally HUGE feeds - I was livid when I found what they were planning on feeding him) and giving him ad-lib hay (not soaked at the time) until he became overweight. One day he came out of his stable footy - vet was called who said he was overweight etc and I drove the 200 mile round-trip and implemented a strict routine again - limited soaked hay, no turnout and back to a handful of happy hoof until his weight came off, whereby we increased the amount of hay he got and increased the amount of time he spent in the field until he was back to a normal weight. Staff were told off and YO apologised on their behalf (loaner was very upset as she had been in hospital trusting them the whole time).

He is now back to his correct weight and back to his usual routine. His loaner had a nutritionist come and look at him (from Allen and Page as she was doing the whole yard). The nutritionist said his weight is good and body scored him just under 3 (where I like him to be). However she wants him to have a whole scoop of fast fibre morning and night instead of the handful of happy hoof and adlib hay (not soaked). There's no way he can have ad-lib unsoaked hay and not put on weight and he's never had that much feed in over six years, even though I know its low sugar/starch I'm really worried he would put weight on where I can't be there to keep an eye on him and risk having another attack. He doesn't actually need the hard-feed for weight, and has grass all day and un-soaked hay all night so as far as I'm concerned he has enough fibre. Is it worth ignoring her advice and maintaining what has worked for him for so long? With his recent scare and the sheer number of horses coming down with lammi at the moment I'm absolutely terrified of doing anything that might trigger it, but I feel bad that my loaner has paid for the nutritionist's services and that I'm blocking any changes to my boy's feed at the moment until I have some other opinions!
 
I am no expert but in my experience your approach is more sensible. They only need fibre in the form of hay and grass and sufficient minerals unless in seriously hard work. Your approach of just sufficient hard food to get minerals in seems sensible to me.
 
If it ain't broke . . . don't fix it. Trust your gut. Leave him on the same routine. I am a sucker for a marketing campaign especially horse feeding ones and I have been caught out in the past. You know your horse! :)
 
It sounds as if he is fine on the diet he is on, they are recommending a change really just for the sake of it, I like Fast Fibre, mine are on it and have done really well including a laminitic but why change yours.

Soaking hay gets rid of the sugars which is probably why he can cope with unrestricted grass by giving him unsoaked ad lib hay there is a strong possibility he may then need his grazing restricted, if I was your horse I know what I would prefer.
A mineral supplement may be a good idea to replace the goodness soaked out of the hay otherwise I would stick with what he does well on.
 
I agree with others, keep to feeding soaked hay, the Fast Fibre has all the vitamins and minerals which he needs but does not come in to the category of hard feed imho. I feed it all year round every day to provide essential minerals and vitamins. I also added a small amount of Laminator this year. By soaking the hay you are removing the sugars., but also some of the nutrients.
I have seen a little clip from a D&H nutritionist that as horses get older, they will be more likely to get metabolic diseases including laminitis due to long term over feeding of calories and under feeding of nutrients, not that I am suggesting you are overfeeding calories, but it is something to think about.
You could try Dengie non molassed chaff [the lo alfa], it is expensive but very tasty, look out for £2.00 off label.
 
Last edited:
I love fast fibre it brilliant stuff, but I don't see any reason for you to change onto it, your regime seems fine and is maintaining your horse well, I can't quite understand the recxomendation for adlib unsoaked hay?! I'd stick exactly as you are
 
I could actually cry at some of the advice given out by 'equine nutritionists' who seem to think that every horse will fit neatly into their calculations :rolleyes:

Your horse, your decision. You are obviously doing a good job so I wouldn't be in any hurry whatsoever to do anything different..
 
Agree with everyone else..she's probably working on commission lol..the more of their food she can flog off on people the more alcohol money she gets :p
 
Top