Nikki J
Well-Known Member
I would suggest that before electric shock treatment is considered, those who would plan to use them, consider that if they aren't able to teach a dog, either because of their own lack of experience, or the dog's breed temperament, then they should ask the question, "Have I the right breed of dog", which poses a second question, "Why do people buy dogs which have natural and known tendencies towards what would appear to be delinquent behaviour, and then come on here, and ask for help"? This isn't a direct attack against you, RCP, but the question is valid.
I've made my views obvious previously, and have conceded that in the most experienced of hands, there "may" be a place for electric collars, but then this raises the point that I've known some highly experienced trainers, who've operated at National level, in a variety of disciplines, and don't know of one who's used an electric collar.
In the wrong hands, an electric collar would be cruel, and with certain breeds and types, pain will all so often have the opposite effect than what's desired, and as we whip a horse to make it go faster, so pain created by electric shocks can drive the dog ever onwards.
I would, as always, advise others that they think very carefully before they experiment with electric collars.
Alec.
I entirely agree with what you say that in the wrong hands, an e collar is cruel. But you can apply that to any tool - a choke chain, a slip lead, anything.
In the right hands ... and I do not include my hands in that statement ... it is a very useful tool to enable dogs that normally would not be safe to let off the lead anywhere except the most secure of enclosures, to be exercised off the lead - something to me which is absolutely vital, as I consider it cruel to confine a dog to a lead for the whole of its life. If I had to do that with my dogs, then I would quite simply not have them. But I have at my fingertips, thanks to my hubby, a tool that enables my recalcitrant, intransigent boy Ben to run free, safe in the knowledge that we can recall him irrespective of whether he is pursuing a deer, a bitch, or just being plain naughty. It never fails, even when he is not wearing the collar! When he is commanded to Come, he comes!